The Phillies played two games on Saturday in split squad action. Kyle Kendrick started against the Rays in Clearwater and Vance Worley took the mound against the Pirates in Bradenton.
Worley did well and allowed just one run over 3.1 innings on two hits and two walks while striking out five batters. Kendrick, on the other hand, looked good for two innings, but was then slammed with three homers from lefties in his final two innings. The five runs Kendrick surrendered contributed to a 6-2 Phillies loss.
While it is only spring training, the question of whether or not Kendrick can get left-handed batters out still remains. In four seasons with the Phillies, Kendrick has been consistently inconsistent. The issues with lefties, a sinker ball that does not always sink and his tendency to become frustrated on the mound are concerning.
With all the experience he has gained over the years, the time for Kendrick to get it together into one complete package may be now or never.
Worley, 23, is younger and has less experience. But in the long run, he may turn out to be the better pitcher between the two. In 13 innings with the big club last year, Worley posted a 1.38 ERA and a 0.92 WHIP. His minor league lifetime WHIP is 1.280.
In addition, Worley has a variety of pitches, including both a two-seam and four-seam fastball, slider, curve and cut fastball.
It is possible that Worley will have outpitched Kendrick by the end of spring? If so, do the Phillies go with Worley or stick with experience in Kendrick?
There is a different possibility as well. If another bullpen pitcher bombs, like Danys Baez for example, there could be room for both players. This also gives the Phillies additional options in the case that a starting pitcher gets injured. Although, having two long-men in the bullpen seems unlikely, as Worley could easily be recalled from the minors if needed.
With only a few weeks left this spring, both pitchers will need to bring their A-games.