The Redskins Fire Sale

Pete WilliamsCorrespondent IApril 7, 2010

ASHURN, VA - APRIL 6:  Mike Shanahan, head coach of the Washington Redskins presents Donovan McNabb with his new jersey during a press conference on April 6, 2010 at Redskin Park in Ashburn, Virginia.  (Photo by Mitchell Layton/Getty Images)
Mitchell Layton/Getty Images

With the McNab trade it seems like the Redskins just continued with their old bad habits of trying to build a team through trade and free agency instead of through the draft. The organization doesn't seem to have any kind of patience - and it shows in bad results.

What further puzzels me was that McNab stated on NFL.com that he didn't even meet Shanahan prior to the trade - I just hope this isn't true. How can you invest the teams future in a guy that you haven't had extensive talks with.

The other point about the trade for McNab and trying to push Haynesworth into it - have just pummeled the trade stock of both Campbell and Haynesworth. Campbell was worth a 2nd rd pick - now he is deemed maybe a 3rd, probably a 4th rd. pick. Haynesworth would have been a low 1st rd pick and now a mediocre 2nd rd.

And I haven't even mentioned the loss of the 37th pick (pratically a 1st) and 2-3rd pick in 2011.

Now Im not saying that Campbell wont be a great QB, but I think that the Redskins are gambling with the future of the franchise - and risk a decade in the dark. Just imagine if McNab gets hurt, which is quite possible because no matter what he will be working behind an O-line in a rebuilding process (to put it mildly) and McNab isn't the man made of steel (to put it mildly - again)

In my mind the Redskins will have to do anything to get more picks in the top 100. That includes:

  1. Trading down from the no 4 pick for a mid 1st round and a high 2nd rd pick.
  2. Starting a fire sale on all expendable players on the rooster
  • Haynesworth for a 2nd round
  • Cooley for a 2nd round
  • Campbell for a low 3rd round
  • Andre Carter for a 4th round
This could amount to:
  • Anthony Davies LT (mid 1st)
  • Demarius Thomas, WR (high 2nd) (maybe a trade for Brandon Marshall)
  • Cam Thomas, NT (2nd)
  • Roger Saffold, RT/RG (2nd)
  • Mitch Petrus, C (low 3rd)
  • Myron Rolle, S (4th rd)
With a little luck the pre-McNab option could have been 4 1st rd picks: 
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/368882-the-redskins-monster-trade-scenario-2010
And then the Redskins still could have gone for McNab.
In conclusion I think the Redskins played their cards totally in the wrong order. Shanahan should have talked up Campbell - now he is just left overs.
But hey I'm just a sofa "expert" please Shanahan - prove me wrong !!

Related

    Fox Going After Rights to TNF

    NFL logo
    NFL

    Fox Going After Rights to TNF

    Lucas Shaw
    via Bloomberg.com

    Jacksonville Bakery Trolls Roethlisberger

    NFL logo
    NFL

    Jacksonville Bakery Trolls Roethlisberger

    Maurice Moton
    via Bleacher Report

    Steelers Part Ways with OC Haley

    NFL logo
    NFL

    Steelers Part Ways with OC Haley

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report

    Campbell: Jags Can Talk Trash Because They Back It Up

    NFL logo
    NFL

    Campbell: Jags Can Talk Trash Because They Back It Up

    Vsporto
    via Vsporto