Soccer Punditry At Its Best: Eamonn Dunphy

Eamonn Dunphy is one of Ireland's most controversial television celebrities. Keith Griffin gives examples as to why.

by Keith Griffin (Columnist)

8

769 reads

Editorial

June 13, 2008

World Football, Ireland, Editorial

There is probably no-one within Bleacher Report who will know who I am talking about in this article (apart from maybe Marc Kaveh), but I urge you to read on regardless.

If you are lucky enough to ever watch the coverage of any Champions League or Euro 2008 match on Irish television, it’s absolutely brilliant.

It’s hosted by a man on the wrong side of 60 named Bill O'Herlihy and the pundits who accompany him are none other than the Ireland and Arsenal legend Liam Brady, Liverpool great Graeme Souness, and Leeds' former midfield maestro Johnny Giles who would all be considered very respectable figures within the football world.

But another pundit who also joins them is the real gem in this group of past masters: Eamonn Dunphy.

Although not on the same legendry player status as the others, (although he did play for Manchester United if only for three games and Milwall) Dunphy has a far more potent weapon to wield than football skills and shiny medals of leagues and cups won in the years gone by.

He can just slate any football figure on television without as much as thinking of the repercussions, and in fact, he just doesn't seem to actually care if he is right or wrong. He makes his opinions and sticks by them.

Eamonn Dunphy is a renowned journalist within Ireland and also the author of a number of bestsellers including 'Only a Game?' and more famously and controversially Roy Keane's autobiography.

He especially hates Cristiano Ronaldo. And I do mean hate. He will single him out for criticism at the very first minute of the program, as you will see by the some of the quotes I have listed below.

He is very fond of Roy Keane and considers him an Irish legend, as he does Ryan Giggs and Paul Scholes as well as John Terry and Michael Essien.

So you can see what sort of player he prefers, the hard grafting, old fashioned footballer who plays the game to for the team and always looks to win with good simple passionate football.

Maybe that's how we can explain his hatred for Ronaldo.  He doesn't like the step-overs and dummies etc.

The reason so many people listen to Dunphy is simple.  What he says about players is absolutely hilarious. Even if you love Ronaldo or Gerrard or whoever he is slating that day, you can't help but laugh.

Listed below are some of my favorites, and I guarantee you won’t hear Gary Lineker or Alan Shearer saying this stuff.

 

On Luis Garcia:

"They (Liverpool) should put Garcia where he belongs—in the dustbin."

On Cristiano Ronaldo:

"The way Ronaldo clicks his heels, is the most wicked thing in the game." 
"a simple cheat" 
or  "Poof ball."

On Kevin Kilbane:

"Kilbane's head is better than his feet. If only he had three heads, one on the end of each leg."

On Michael Carrick:

"Carrick was signed for Spurs a few years back for £3m. That's the level he is at. He is a nothing player. He is one-paced. He doesn't have the personality to always get on the ball like a United player should. "

A "nothing player" is one of Dunphy's favorite sayings.


On the Alex Ferguson and Gordon Strachan feud:

Eamon: "Scots they're either nice or they're horrid and these two are horrid. 
Bill: "The Scots wont like that Eamon, that's bordering on racism". 
Eamon: "It’s not racism its ethnic criticism Bill."

Ok, that one ain't funny but shows how far Eamonn Dunphy can go, and this you must remember is on live television.

On the very hostile boardroom at Real Madrid:

"Bill, Bill... those directors over there are on another planet. They're on mushrooms or something...THEY'RE ON ACID BILL!!!"

On John Hartson:

"Bill, Hartson is not a 7million pound player...it’s a disgrace, a shambles! This is the state of football today Bill. I have a clip here of why Hartson is NOT a £7million player....Roll it there Bill!(literally 1 second in to the clip) OKAY, HOLD IT THERE BILL!!! (draws a circle around Hartson's arse) Bill, that is NOT the arse of a £7million player!''

On Rio Ferdinhand:

"Ferdinand is a clown. He was a liability for the first goal and he is always a liability. It was Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink against Rio Ferdinand of Barclays Bank."

On Liverpool vs Barcelona:

"I was hoping in the last fifteen minutes that Barcelona would beat them. I've made my mind up on Benitez tonight. He's a nice man but he's got a huge negative streak running through him. Liverpool was terrible in the second half. They didn't play football. If that was a concert, you'd boo. Gerrard: found out. A nothing player. They were terrible. Terrible."

On Fabio Cannavaro:

"If Rio Ferdinand is worth £100,000 a week, then this guy is worth EUR100 million . . . . . a day."

On Harry Kewell:

"Kewell should have been yanked off the pitch at half time and put in a hot bath, a boiling hot bath."

"Fat and a clown. A fat clown for all to see"

On Djibril Cisse:

"Here we have Cisse, right wing, attempts to put in a cross, BANG...hits the full back, again BANG hits the full back, BANG...off the full back again, and once more, BANG...smacks the full back again.... Millions of euro and he can't clear the first man, I mean...what's he trying to do to the full back here, Kill him??"

On Sergio Ramos:

"He's a nothing player, he's like Paul McShane on steroids, costs more but just as likely to get you shot in the head."

Before Man United hammered Roma 7-1:

"O'shea not good enough, Ferdinand and Brown dodgy, Ronaldo a puff ball, Fletcher and Carrick nothing players, Rooney has never done it on the big stage."

So as you can see, 'the Dunph' takes no prisoners. And if you can imagine this on live television, it brings quite a few gasps! Included here are a few links to watch the man in action.

 

Slating Ronaldo after semi final 1st leg vs. Barcelona.

Dunphy and Liam Brady argue over Liverpool vs. Arsenal game semi final 2nd leg. Remember Liam Brady is coach of Arsenal youths and is slightly biased, but the Dunphy doesn't seem to care.

Dunphy slating BBC pundits Lineker and Shearer.

Dunphy calling Ronaldo a "brat"

And last but not least, the major fight between the pundits over Roy Keane leaving United. Sound quality is poor to start, but it's a worthy watch. Believe me

 

Anyway, check it out and hope you enjoy. It really is pure cheekiness on television.

Editorial

769 views

Share:

  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Email
  • Print

comments (8) write a comment »

  1. some of those quotes are hilarious :p sounds like we're missing out watching english champs league coverages
    "ethnic" criticism is my faveourite :p

    1. Ah mate I swear its just hilarious...Dunphy is a actually an idiot but he is just 'stupid funny' if you know what I mean.

      Not too long ago there, he wrote that he was wrong about Ronaldo, that he is a phenomenon. Ronaldo misses penalty against Barca? Worst player in the world again. Its just hilarious!

  2. He said something controversial about Arsene Wenger in the studio too.. and Liam Brady was there as a guest and told him "That is disgraceful.. ".. and this joker actually stood up for what he was doing.. he's a joker, that's what he is!

    1. Well Brady is a regular, and what happened was rte put together a collection of clips from during the defeat to Liverpool of Wenger supposedly 'losing it'. Brady just turned around and said 'if i had known that was going to be shown I wouldnt have came here tonight' then a big arguement started. The link is above for it.

      Hahaha your right Shyam, a joker is exactly what he is. Thanks for the comment mate.

  3. i hope to god i can watch him some time. this was the best laugh i've had all wekk.

    wicked mate.

    1. Mike, you have no idea mate. It's unreal. Absolutly hilarious. Check out those links, brilliant.

      Cheers for the comment mike.

  4. I love Eamon Dunphy because he is simply controversial for the hell of it,

    For his scraps with Brady, the Viera & Keane debate when the latter was retiring, brilliant!

    He loves a bit of conforntation and his views are always more passionate and less sparing than the English ones. His views on Ronaldo are genious!!! That all English commentators lick the ground he plays on and ignores his faults, like diving and cheating.

    I love Dunphy!

    1. Actually just watched the debate again when Keane was leaving United, easily one of the most heated arguements on television Ive seen. Dunphy was basically roaring at Bill.

      Gotta love the man.

write a new comment


Edit this Article Article History

FREE SPORTS TEXT ALERTS

  • Get team scores and news sent to your cell phone during and after each game.
  • We do not charge for these services, but standard messaging rates or other charges apply.
  • Cancel anytime by replying STOP to any message.

Step 1: Choose a team

League:

Step 2: Enter your phone number

( ) -
Standard Messaging Rates or other charges apply. To Opt-out text STOP to 4INFO (44636). For more information text HELP to 4INFO (44636). Contact your carrier for more details.

Want to write for Bleacher Report

We are a community of fans who write about sports. And we're growing.

Learn More and Sign Up »