New York Mets' Roundtable: the May Awards Show

Dan SiegelSenior Analyst IJune 1, 2008

May was a month of ups and downs for the New York Mets.

The Mets took two out of three in Arizona, but came back home with a 3-3 record on their mini West coast trip.

They followed that up with taking two of three from struggling Cincinnati, only to lose the following series to the lowly Washington Nationals.

Things seemed on the up-and-up after a two-game sweep of the Yankees, but then things took a turn for the worst, dropping seven of eight to Atlanta, Colorado, and Florida (not to mention that whole mess with Willie Randolph).

The Mets did end up winning the last two against the Marlins, and then took four out of five against the Marlins and Dodgers to close out the month.

Anyhow, I'm joined here by John Fennelly, David Marine, and Andrew Phillips to pick May's Most Valuable Player, Cy Young, and Least Valuable player for the New York Mets.

Ryan Church, our April MVP, looked like an early candidate to repeat in May, but his May 20 concussion unfortunately limited his contributions for the last third of the month. Still, Church hit six homers during limited action in May, bringing his 2008 total to nine, and hit .299 for the month.

Fennelly is having a hard time coming up with an MVP candidate.

Of Jose Reyes, he says, "Reyes hit .310 in May, but had 20 Ks...too many for a leadoff man."  He goes on to note that Jose committed four errors this month, and only helped the infield turn 14 double plays.

Of Carlos Beltran, he says, "...Beltran looks like he might be turning it around."

Beltran hit .306 for the month of May, but only managed three home runs. Let's see what Marine and Phillips have to say.

Marine starts off by saying, "There wasn't a single player that stood out for the Mets in May, but the bench and reserve players were the key to basically any big win the Mets had in May."

Okay, David, go on.

"There's Nick Evans['s] debut against Colorado, Fernando Tatis's double[s] against the Marlins [and] Dodgers."

Don't forget about the game winning single Tatis had Saturday against the Dodgers as well.

Anything else, David?

"Claudio Vargas joined the rotation and pitched admirably. Chavez has played well in the field, and Castro has hit well of the bench. Without the 'super subs' the Mets would easily be at least five games under .500."

How about Mr. Phillips? What does he have to say?

Much like Fennelly, Phillips says, "I'm guessing it's hard to actually find an MVP for this putrid month..."

Well said, sir. Continue, please.

"MVP. The Mets bench. The reserves. Without them, this team would be in even more shambles. Tatis, Cassanova, Easley, etc. have provided a legitimate spark in the month of May."

Hmm. Two compelling arguments for the bench. 

My vote was going to be for David Wright, being the glue that has held this Mets team together and hitting a respectable .287 in the month of May while blasting seven homers and driving in 17. 

However, the bench's votes have won me over so the New York Mets' bench can come on down and accept the May MVP award.

Now on to the Cy Young.

The first name that one would say when one hears "New York Mets" and "Cy Young" is Johan Santana.

Indeed, Mr. Phillips is thinking along those lines, stating, "Would have to be Santana for finally starting to show what kind of pitcher the Mets were expecting him to be."

Well, the three wins Santana picked up this month were nice; however, some may see the 3.74 ERA in May to be less than Cy-Young worthy.

Fennelly also points out that, "Mike Pelfrey and Johan Santana [pitched] the exact [same] amount of innings (33-2/3)" in May.

Despite the blown save that Bill Wagner recorded, a.k.a. "...the Friday night back-breaker in Colorado," Fennelly believes that Wagner is the only individual on the team worthy of any positive accolades.

Marine reminds us that, "Sure, he blew one save in May, but that's it. ONE blown save. The guy has been lights out and his slider is just filthy of late."

Billy Wagner, please proudly accept the May Cy Young award to add to your April Cy Young award.

And last and certainly least is the Least Valuable Player award.

Last month's winner was Carlos Delgado, and he is certainly in the running for May.

Marine asks, "Have you ever seen a player decline faster than Carlos Delgado?”

Maybe, go on.

"Delgado is the worst hitter in the lineup, and has Mets fans dreaming of Mark Teixeira as a free agent."

While Teixeira would be a great free agent pickup, Delgado has not been the worst hitter for the Mets in May, scraping together a .258 average while hitting five homers and driving in 13.

Fennelly reminds us that, "After a quick start, [Brian] Schneider only batted .215 in May."

Fennelly's vote for LVP goes to Aaron Heilman.

"It's time for the Mets to send him packing," says Fennelly.

Phillips is in agreement, stating, "Heilman. Heilman. Heilman. To think what the Mets could have traded him for a few short years ago. What a shame."

Aaron Heilman, your 8.25 ERA in the month of May has won you the prestigious Least Valuable Player award.

See that, Willie.  It says "Least Valuable."  That means:



    Projecting MLB's Top 20 OFs of the Future

    New York Mets logo
    New York Mets

    Projecting MLB's Top 20 OFs of the Future

    Joel Reuter
    via Bleacher Report

    Bundy Fans 14, Tosses 2-Hitter to Lead O's Past Chisox

    MLB logo

    Bundy Fans 14, Tosses 2-Hitter to Lead O's Past Chisox

    It’s Time To Let Steven Matz Sink or Swim

    New York Mets logo
    New York Mets

    It’s Time To Let Steven Matz Sink or Swim

    David Cassilo
    via Metsmerizedonline

    Red Sox Activating Dustin Pedroia Friday

    MLB logo

    Red Sox Activating Dustin Pedroia Friday

    Joseph Zucker
    via Bleacher Report