Why Tottenham Signing Willian in January Transfer Window Doesn't Make Sense

Allan JiangTransfers CorrespondentDecember 5, 2012

Why Tottenham Signing Willian in January Transfer Window Doesn't Make Sense

0 of 3

    Shakhtar Donetsk’s 24-year-old Brazilian, Willian, is a January transfer target for Tottenham Hotspur, according to talkSPORT.

    Willian’s teammate, Eduardo, the former Arsenal forward, opined on the transfer situation (via Sky Sports):

    Willian is a complete player now. He is ready to play for a big club and become a really big player. There are three clubs who are big enough and good enough for Willian—Arsenal, Man United and Chelsea. He asks me about England and the English game and I tell him little things. We always talk and watch Premier League games together.

    This article will tell you why signing Willian in the January transfer window doesn’t make sense for Spurs. 

Shakhtar Donetsk's Love for Brazilians

1 of 3

    Willian, Brazilian Left Attacking Midfielder, 5'8" (1.74 m), 159 lbs (72 kg), Age: 24

    Willian is one of the many Brazilians Shakhtar Donetsk have signed since the club made a concerted effort to scout players from the Brasileirão. Names include Alan Patrick, Alex Teixeira, Dentinho, Douglas Costa, Elano, Fernandinho, Ilsinho, Jádson, Luiz Adriano and more.

    Tottenham Hotspur are one for three when it comes to signing Brazilians in the Premier League era. Heurelho Gomes was the Titus Bramble of goalkeepers. while Gilberto was André Santos before André Santos. 

    Former Internacional player Sandro was the only one of these three that was signed directly from the Brasileirão. He's since become one of the best defensive midfielders in the Premier League. 

    Speaking of the EPL—Elano and Costa are names that should jump out at you. Elano had some memorable moments with Manchester Citylike smashing a free kick past then-Newcastle United goalkeeper Shay Given. 

    Touted as the new Ronaldinho, Costa would have been a Manchester United player if Grêmio didn't keep jacking up his transfer value.

    The background to the story was that Grêmio didn't want to be short-changed again.

    They sold Ronaldinho to Paris Saint-Germain for €5 million. The Parisian club then sold him to Barcelona for €30 million

    Anderson went from Grêmio to Porto for €7 million before becoming a United player for €30 million

    Costa's career hasn't taken off as expected, and United may have dodged another dodgy Brazilian. 

    Before this article explains why Spurs signing Willian in January is out of the question, you need to understand what type of player he is. 

    WhoScored co-founder and Chief Operating Officer Cristiano Acconci made an insightful observation.


    Watched Willian live tonight. He looks like a strong version of Coutinho.

    — Cristiano Acconci (@MrAcconci) November 7, 2012


    When Coutinho was on loan at Espanyol, he jinked his way past multiple defenders time after time. Willian has the same ability, averaging three dribbles per UEFA Champions League game, which is 1.2 dribbles higher than Lionel Messi in the UCL. 

    Like Messi, Willian isn't constrained to one set zone in that the Brazilian roams like Barça's No. 10. Look at Willian's heat map in the 3-2 loss to Chelsea compared to Alex Teixeira, who spent the large majority of the game on the right (via ESPN FC). 

    Up against a Chelsea team that deferred their marking assignments to one another—a classic example of social loafing—Willian's movement was the key reason why he scored both goals unmarked. 

    This shows high football IQ, great positional awareness and why he's the type of player that can play across midfield. Left, right, centre—as long as he is given the green light to stray from his set position on paper (left attacking midfielder in Mircea Lucescu's starting XI) Willian will continue to thrive. 

    In the midst of his goals, assists and skill, Willian's defensive prowess is ignored. He averages 1.4 tackles and two interceptions per UCL game. In the same competition, Manchester City's defensive midfielder Javi García makes 1.4 tackles and 1.2 interceptions per game. 

    Let's now look into the reasons why Tottenham signing Willian in the January transfer window isn't feasible. 

Shakhtar Donetsk Hold All the Cards

2 of 3

    Shakhtar Donetsk are into the UEFA Champions League knockout rounds with a game to spare. Those two legs will be held in February and March; therefore, selling Willian isn't on Rinat Akhmetov's agenda. 

    Forbes estimates that Akhmetov's worth is $16 billion, meaning he has more cash than Roman Abramovich and Daniel Levy combined. 

    Willian recently said (via David Hytner at The Guardian): "I would like to move from Shakhtar, my work here is complete. I would like to play in a big team in a big tournament, like the Premier League or Serie A."

    Unfortunately for Willian, Shakhtar won't sell in the January transfer window because they don't need to sell. This is where Sepp Blatter is jumping up and down, yelling: "Aha! I told you so. This is the modern slavery I'm talking about."

    If Willian wants to leave ASAP, he will need to take drastic steps like Matuzalém, who embroiled Real Zaragoza in a legal mess because the fallen star left Shakhtar on his own terms for the Spanish club. 

    Tottenham Hotspur signing Willian in January is a pipe dream. Does he fit into André Villas-Boas' immediate plans? Read the next slide. 

Where Would Willian Fit into André Villas-Boas' Team?

3 of 3

    Gareth Bale's productivity, six league goals and explosiveness guarantees him a starting role. Aaron Lennon's speed opens up defences, so he'll keep his place. 

    Meanwhile, Clint Dempsey and Gylfi Sigurðsson are fighting for the position to play behind Jermain Defoe. 

    Where does Willian fit into André Villas-Boas' team? He is a talented player, but this isn't FIFA manager mode where you stockpile your squad with the best players. 


    Please read Updated Odds on Teams Most Likely to Land Becks

    Statistics courtesy of WhoScored.com

    Follow @allanjiangLIVE

    Connect with