One could say that the entire Jets roster was overrated in 2011, a sentiment I would agree with.
The New York Jets finished the 2011 regular season with an 8-8 record. Rex Ryan's antics and attitude backfired as the team suffered losses against every single team they played with a winning record (0-4 against teams with 9 wins or more, 2-7 against teams with 8 wins or more).
Fans tend to blame one or two people in particular for the Jets' lackluster results—Brian Schottenheimer and Mark Sanchez in this case—but football is a game with 11 players on offense and the same number of players on defense.
Though the New York Jets were disappointing as a team, six players in particular were the most disappointing and should be considered the most overrated on the roster.