Fantasy Baseball 2012: Grading the Top 15 Third Basemen

Scott BarzillaContributor IIINovember 1, 2011

Evan Longoria could be the preseason MVP in 2012.
Evan Longoria could be the preseason MVP in 2012.J. Meric/Getty Images

We continue our look at the top 15 fantasy players at each position with third base. In the case of third base, we are including a couple of designated hitters that are also eligible at the position. In this case, it makes the position a lot stronger and more interesting on draft day. There will be at least one prominent name left out.

Like with the second basemen, we will see real offensive value (ROV), runs created (RC) and batting average on balls in play (BABIP). Rankings were made based on a combination of ROV and RC. BABIP was included to give people a sneak preview of which hitters may surge next season and which ones will fall back. A low BABIP is a good thing for future performance while a higher BABIP is a warning sign.


15. Chase  Headley, San Diego Padres

ROV: .283

RC: 61

BABIP: .368

Headley is a nice little player and if fantasy baseball ever made adjustments for ballpark effects, he would be a lot better. Sadly, they do not. He is stuck in Petco Park where his average power looks meager. Yet, he will give you some steals and he will play regularly. Watch for the batting average to drop, though.


14. Ryan Zimmerman, Washington Nationals

ROV: .276

Zimmerman would be good if he can stay healthy.
Zimmerman would be good if he can stay healthy.Hunter Martin/Getty Images

RC: 60

BABIP: .326

Zimmerman is a tease. He looks like he should be a top five third baseman, but something always seems to get in the way. He has had only one full season over the last several. He should be healthy next year, but they have been saying that in Washington for the last five years.


13. Edwin Encarnacion, Toronto Blue Jays

ROV: .278

RC: 70

BABIP: .292

They picked up his option in Toronto, so they must have plans for him. It likely won't involve a lot of third base. Brett Lawrie has that position nailed down, but depending on what happens this winter, there could be an opening at either first base or DH. He'll go up a few spots if he had a guarantee of 500 plate appearances.


12. Chipper Jones, Atlanta Braves

ROV: .292

RC: 73

BABIP: .295

Young is due for a major hangover next year.
Young is due for a major hangover next year.Rob Carr/Getty Images

The ageless wonder will retire one of these days. It says here that he gives it one more go. He thought about retiring until he tore his ACL a couple of years ago. Clearly, he doesn't want to go out with a bad taste in his mouth. Aftertastes don't get much worse than this past September.


11. Ryan Roberts, Arizona Diamondbacks

ROV: .292

RC: 73

BABIP: .275

Roberts had a very good season off the radar in Arizona. He won't be off the radar this season. On the one hand, he should have the job from day one, so he will get more plate appearances. On the other hand, everyone has a book on him now, so he might have a tougher go of it.


10. Michael Young, Texas Rangers, Buyer Beware

ROV= .278

RC= 112

BABIP= .367

Every once in awhile, that little voice in your head starts going nuts. Right now, it is shouting, "Career Year! Career Year! Career Year!" Listen to that voice. That BABIP is way too high to sustain and unlike many of these guys, Young relies more on batting average for his value. He does have some versatility, but please don't over-slot him.

Is David Wright on the move?
Is David Wright on the move?Patrick McDermott/Getty Images


9. Alex Rodriguez, New York Yankees

ROV: .294

RC: 62

BABIP: .311

A-Rod had an impressive streak of 100 RBI seasons end last season. All good things must come to an end and his run as a top-flight fantasy third baseman is probably done as well. Yet, all great players usually have one bounce back year in them before they finally begin the ride downhill.


8. David Wright, New York Mets

ROV: .294

RC: 62

BABIP: .302

Wright is one of those players rumored to be on the move. Of course, rumors are plentiful this time of year. The Mets are moving in the fences and making them shorter, so all hitters should benefit, but none more than Wright. It has been tragic what that ballpark has done to his career in the past three seasons.


7. Aramis Ramirez, Free Agent

ROV: .293

Lawrie could be the best fantasy third baseman next season.
Lawrie could be the best fantasy third baseman next season.Brad White/Getty Images

RC: 104

BABIP: .308

Nothing makes me more nervous than a player that has a big season during his walk year. Someone will overpay Ramirez and his production will likely decline. If he goes to a contender, he still might be good for some cheap RBI.


6. Brett Lawrie, Toronto Blue Jays, Sleeper

ROV: .363

RC: 35

BABIP: .318

We have to keep our wits about us before we completely lose control, but this guy looks like a stud. He's a great fielder and he hit the big leagues slugging. We can expect a hangover, but if it is minor enough, he still might be the best fantasy baseball third baseman.


5. Adrian Beltre, Texas Rangers

ROV: .306

RC: 87

BABIP: .273

Beltre showed a lot last season. He showed that he is a very good offensive player when you put him in a neutral or pro hitter park. He got a bad rap in Safeco all those years, but he can rake. He drove in 100 runs despite missing six weeks. Texas is just in a different stratosphere offensively.

Injuries kept Yuk from reaching 100 runs created.
Injuries kept Yuk from reaching 100 runs created.Jim Rogash/Getty Images


4. Pablo Sandoval, San Francisco Giants

ROV: .312

RC: 79

BABIP: .320

Kung Fu Panda dropped a few pounds and found his stroke. He missed some time, but was very productive. If the Giants get some more offense this offseason, you will see his run production soar.


3. Mark Reynolds, Baltimore Orioles

ROV: .314

RC: 85

BABIP: .266

No, I'm not high right now. First thing, he had a very low BABIP last season, so his average should easily increase 30 to 40 points. Secondly, most leagues are now incorporating OBP, so he won't be such a drag. His power is impressive and if they get him out of third base (DH?) he could possible soar.


2. Kevin Youkilis, Boston Red Sox

ROV: .313

RC: 77

BABIP: .296

Youk is essentially Mark Reynolds with a good batting average. He missed more than a month due to injury, so he easily could have created over 100 runs this past season. The so-called Greek God of Walks hasn't been that at the big league level, but he is quite patient and matches that with power.


1. Evan Longoria, Tampa Bay Rays

ROV: .331

RC: 88

BABIP: .239

Evan Longoria was arguably the MVP of the second half. Imagine if he puts two halves together. That isn't that hard to imagine when you look at his BABIP. Another 60 points on batting average and he is an absolute stud and likely the actual MVP.


    Sale (Hip Bruise) Expects to Start Opening Day

    MLB logo

    Sale (Hip Bruise) Expects to Start Opening Day

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report

    A's Charging Giants Fans Extra for Parking 😏

    MLB logo

    A's Charging Giants Fans Extra for Parking 😏

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report

    Report: Rangers Release Colon, Hope to Sign to Triple A

    MLB logo

    Report: Rangers Release Colon, Hope to Sign to Triple A

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report

    Phillies Cut K-Rod

    MLB logo

    Phillies Cut K-Rod

    Alec Nathan
    via Bleacher Report