Cincinnati Reds: Their Ideal Everyday Lineup

Michael HammonsCorrespondent IJune 18, 2011

Cincinnati Reds: Their Ideal Everyday Lineup

0 of 8

    CINCINNATI, OH - JUNE 17:  Manager Dusty Baker #12 of the Cincinnati Reds watches his team during the game against the Toronto Blue Jays on June 17, 2011 at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati, Ohio.  The Toronto Blue Jays defeated the Cincinnati Reds
    John Grieshop/Getty Images

    With a bad team, arranging the batting lineup is akin to rearranging deck chairs on the titanic, but on a contending team like the Reds, I believe there are a few adjustments that could be made that will help the team as a whole.

    Without further ado, with numbers to back up my thoughts, I present what would look like a good everyday starting lineup for the Cincinnati Reds.

First: Drew Stubbs

1 of 8

    CINCINNATI, OH - JUNE 17:  Drew Stubbs #6 of the Cincinnati Reds hits an inside the park home run during the game against the Toronto Blue Jays on June 17, 2011 at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati, Ohio.  The Toronto Blue Jays defeated the Cincinnat
    John Grieshop/Getty Images

    Currently: bats leadoff

     

    Heading into the season, there was a fair amount of criticism pointed at Dusty Baker for his decision to bat Drew Stubbs in the leadoff spot.

    Though he continues to strike out at a frightening pace, he has settled into the role, batting a somewhat respectable .268 with a .344 OBP out of the spot (heading into action on Saturday).

    You don't want those strikeouts, but you will take the speed and the home run power, and with no one else on this team suited to bat leadoff, Stubbs is doing reasonably well at this spot.

    Plus, look around at some of the other leadoff hitters in the league. There aren't too many Rickey Henderson's out there anymore.

Second: Chris Heisey

2 of 8

    LOS ANGELES, CA - JUNE 13:  Chris Heisey #28 of the Cincinnati Reds rounds third base after hitting a home run in the sixth inning against pitcher Hiroki Kuroda #18 of the Los Angeles Dodgers (not in photo) during the MLB game at Dodger Stadium on June 13
    Victor Decolongon/Getty Images

    Currently: bats, but has neither consistent playing time, or a consistent spot in the lineup when he receives playing time.

     

    This is two fold, as not only should Chris Heisey be getting more playing time, but in my opinion, would be an excellent No. 2 hitter in the lineup.

    The sample size is small, as he only has eight at bats at this spot.

    With as much bellyaching as myself and others do for Heisey to get more playing time, his average as a starter is significantly lower than his average as a pinch hitter.

    With Votto batting behind him, he's very likely get some good pitches to hit.

Third: Joey Votto

3 of 8

    SAN FRANCISCO, CA - JUNE 09:  Joey Votto #19 of the Cincinnati Reds hits a double in the eighth inning against the San Francisco Giants at AT&T Park on June 9, 2011 in San Francisco, California. Votto scored later in the inning on a pass ball.  (Photo by
    Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

    Currently: bats third

     

    Not much to say here with Votto, as he has batted third all season and should continue in that role.

    The lack of power this season is a bit surprising, but that should pick back up sooner or later.

Fourth: Brandon Phillips

4 of 8

    CINCINNATI, OH - JUNE 17:  Brandon Phillips #4 of the Cincinnati Reds hits a double to right center field during against the Toronto Blue Jays on June 17, 2011 at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati, Ohio.  The Toronto Blue Jays defeated the Cincinnati
    John Grieshop/Getty Images

    Currently: has no consistent spot

     

    This team has been searching for a cleanup hitter all season, as they have tried different guys.

    Scott Rolen is ill suited for the role, as he had batted .196 out of the spot. Love his effort and heart, but you just can't have a 36-year-old with declining skills batting cleanup.

    Jay Bruce is only batting .224 out that spot, as he was batting fifth during his hot streak in May.

    That leaves Brandon Phillips, who was once a fairly decent power threat out of the second base position, but that's not really the case anymore.

    At the very least, he bats .291 out of the fourth spot, in 103 at bats, so I give the slight nod to him.

Fifth: Jay Bruce

5 of 8

    SAN FRANCISCO, CA - JUNE 11: Jay Bruce #32 of the Cincinnati Reds returns to the dugout after scoring and get a high five from teammate Travis Wood #30 against the San Francisco Giants during a MLB baseball game June 11, 2011 at AT&T Park in San Francisco
    Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images

    Currently: bats mostly fifth, but has been moved around the order some

     

    The thinking here is, if you have Votto-Phillips-Bruce, you give the opposing pitcher the lefty-righty-lefty matchup, without having two same-sided hitters back-to-back.

    Plus, out of Bruce's 17 home runs, 10 have been while batting fifth.

    Dusty Baker seems to have recognized that Scott Rolen shouldn't be batting cleanup, but Bruce's recent slump and his move to fourth probably isn't coincidental.

    Put him back to fifth, where he belongs.

Sixth: Scott Rolen

6 of 8

    CINCINNATI, OH - JUNE 17:  Scott Rolen #27 of the Cincinnati Reds hits a solo home run during the game against the Toronto Blue Jays on June 17, 2011 at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati, Ohio.  The Toronto Blue Jays defeated the Cincinnati Reds 3-2.
    John Grieshop/Getty Images

    Currently: has been hitting cleanup most of the season, but is being moved around.

     

    Scott Rolen shouldn't be a cleanup hitter on a team with hopes to win another division title, as I have touched on these points on prior slides.

    Plus, the sample size isn't very large, but in 32 at bats in the sixth spot, he has a .375 average. Perhaps something to build off of.

Seventh: Ramon Hernandez/Ryan Hanigan

7 of 8

    ATLANTA, GA - MAY 27:  Ramon Hernandez #55 of the Cincinnati Reds against the Atlanta Braves at Turner Field on May 27, 2011 in Atlanta, Georgia.  (Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)
    Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

    Currently: both players usually bat here in the seventh spot

    Ramon Hernandez is an excellent hitter as far as bottom of the lineup guys go. Seventy-six of his at bats have come in the seventh spot, and he's proven to be a clutch hitter who gets on base.

    Ryan Hanigan isn't the hitter Hernandez is, but he can grind out at bats. There's always been a bit of chatter about batting him second, as he does get on base, but I never liked the idea of a slow player who doesn't hit for power batting so high up in the lineup.

Eighth: Paul Janish

8 of 8

    SAN FRANCISCO, CA - JUNE 11: Bill Hall #29 of the San Francisco Giants breaks up the double play sliding in hard to Paul Janish #7 of the Cincinnati Reds in the fifth inning during a MLB baseball game June 11, 2011 at AT&T Park in San Francisco, Californi
    Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images

    Currently: bats mostly in the 8-hole

     

    This is where Paul Janish belongs. Simply put, he cannot hit, and this is where hitters who can't hit belong.

    Also, he's the only one I've chosen a photo of playing the field, as that is who is he at the core.

    Inexplicably, he has had 20 at bats in the two-hole, and his backup, Edgar Renteria, has had 54 of his 108 at bats in that spot as well.

    You see their batting averages, and their on base percentages.  That experiment simply has to stop