Some fighters are overrated. Some fighters are underrated. Fight fans love to argue about which fighters fall into which category. Message boards are built on these types of arguments and barber shops have a history of them. However, there are a few boxers throughout history that have managed to be both simultaneously. Following is a list of the top four fighters that managed to be underrated AND overrated at the same time.
As a side note; this list does not mention fighters in the middle of their careers. I believe that every fighter has a tendency to be both overrated and underrated while they are active.