NFLNBANHLMLBWNBASoccerTennis
Featured Video
CAITLIN CLARK GAME-WINNER ๐Ÿ”ฅ

Eric Mangini and Cleveland Browns Ruining Brady Quinn's NFL Career

Erin McLaughlinOct 5, 2009

In all likelihood, this will be my last articleย about the Browns. What's going on in Cleveland just isn't right and I can't root for this team as long as Eric Mangini is the coach.

Yes, I am a Brady Quinn fan, and always will be no matter what he does in the NFL.

I am a college fan first and Quinn was a great quarterback at Notre Dame. Whatever he does in the NFL isย a bonus. I'm okay with him failing as long as he gets a fair chance and the failure is without excuse.

TOP NEWS

Bears Eagles Football

Ranking NFL's Top RB Duos ๐Ÿ“Š

Eagles Vikings Football

Ranking WR Groups After A.J. Trade ๐Ÿ”ข

Rams Football

Ranking 25 Best Offseason Moves ๐Ÿง 

What has happened this year is anything but fair in my opinion. For one, you have to give a guy more thanย two-and-a-half games to develop. When I see a coach pull the plug that quickly,ย it makes me thankful forย the patience of Notre Dame coach Charlie Weis.

Quarterback Jimmy Clausen was awful his freshman year. Two years later, he is a legitimate Heisman candidate.

Quinn, right now, reminds me of Clausenย in hisย freshman year.

He had poor line-play and a lack of playmakers. To me, no quarterback can produce consistently on a team like that. That is whyย JaMarcus Russell has looked awful in Oakland and Matthew Stafford has had his struggles in Detroit.

Therefore, I don't thinkย a couple ofย games is a fair chance.

I've heard a few things about what went on behind the scenes. The more I hear, the more I think that Mangini deliberately set Quinn up to fail.

I know some will shake their heads when they hear this. But to me, there are some things that just aren't adding up.

I also know not to believe everything I hear.ย However, it's a fact that about five players have filed grievances against Mangini. The way he does things does appear to be very questionable.

Where do I begin?

Some have claimed they had inside information that saidย the coaches knew before the first preseason game that Quinn would start the season. This was evidence that Mangini wanted Quinn to succeed.

All itย tells meย is that he knew he would have to give in to public pressure.

Since he didn't really want Quinn out there,ย Mangini would never give him the vote of confidence as "the guy." The team never gravitated toward him because they didn't know who "the guy" was. Quinn had to split reps in training camp and was never able to develop chemistry with his receivers.

Then Weekย 1 comes and Quinn starts, but Mangini tried to keep it a secret. He never publicly said that Quinn isย the guyย the teamย will rally around.ย It created more doubt about whether Quinnย really was going to be the guy all year.

In case you're not buying this, take a look at the games last year.

When it was announced that Quinn would start, former coach Romeo Crennel did give him the vote of confidence and the team did rally around him. The team looked like a well-oiled machine.

Of course, Quinn had his security blanket in Kellen Winslow who Mangini conveniently traded away.

If he wanted Quinn to succeed, why would he do that?

This year, Quinn looked a lot less sure of himself. In all my years watching him, I have never seen him like this.

That tells me that there is probably something going on behind the scenes with him and Mangini that just isn't right.

People are wondering whyย Quinn looks afraid to go downfield with the ball. There are a lot of factors.

For one, Cleveland's pass protection hasn't been great andย the quarterbackย often has to check down due to lack of time.

Also, Jon Gruden saidย Fridayย on Sirius Radio that when watching film, all he sees is covered receivers. Quinn was making the best read he could. Marty Schottenheimer later agreed and said that he would take Quinn, Joe Thomas and Joshua Cribbs.

Proven coaches are going to bat for Quinn while an unproven coach in Mangini has lost confidence in him.

Scratching your head?

Looking at Sunday's game versus Cincinnati, Derek Anderson had a decent game.

That is all I will call it.

Sure, the offense did produce points with him at quarterback. However, he also displayed his weaknesses: inconsistency, turnovers and not producing with the game on the line.

He startedย the game 3-of-11. Then he heated up late in the second quarter and played well in the third despite throwing an interception in the end zone.

In the fourth quarterย and overtime, the offense did nothing.

It was Cleveland's most positive game offensively. Was Anderson the difference?

I don't think so.

The way the entire team played was.

On Wednesday, Mangini namedย Anderson the starter and the team rallied around him becauseย the coachย gave him the vote of confidence that he never gave to Quinn.

After the game, Cribbs said that Mangini gave his most inspirational speech before the game.

Is it coincidental that he waited until Quinn was out of the lineup before he gave that speech?

Another thing that stood out was the extended opportunity andย great performance ofย rookie wideoutย Mohamed Massaquoi.

Why wasn't he playing when Quinn was in?

Finally, Brian Daboll finally started to call some real plays, unlike the conservative crap he was calling when Quinn was in.

Yes, Quinn struggled. But he was set up to fail by his coach.

Whether it was with malicious intent orย simple incompetence, it doesn't matter. There have been reports of questionable actions from Mangini before in New Yorkย and Cleveland.

Roger Goodell should get involved and investigate if foul play was involved.

I am not advocating for Quinn to go back in. These incompetent coaches will never develop him.

I am advocating for Quinn to get out of the town that ESPN's Colin Cowherd calls "Loserville." After seeing fans get excited over an overtime loss to the Bengals, the nickname seems appropriate.

Wherever Quinn goes I will root for him. With the right coaches and team, he can beย very good. I know some are already calling him a bust. And while I respect their opinions as they are entitled to them, I put more value on those ofย Gruden and Schottenheimer.

So this is my goodbye to the Browns section on Bleacher Report.

Daniel and Sam, I love you guys. Eric, I will still see you in the Notre Dame section. Paul and Michael, congratulations on getting your guy in.

Now, enjoy the mediocrity and inconsistency.

CAITLIN CLARK GAME-WINNER ๐Ÿ”ฅ

TOP NEWS

Bears Eagles Football

Ranking NFL's Top RB Duos ๐Ÿ“Š

Eagles Vikings Football

Ranking WR Groups After A.J. Trade ๐Ÿ”ข

Rams Football

Ranking 25 Best Offseason Moves ๐Ÿง 

Eagles Giants Football

A.J. Brown's reported issue with Jalen Hurts

Giants Raiders Football

Re-Drafting the 2025 Draft

Mike Brown Calls Out Refs ๐Ÿ˜ 
Bleacher Reportโ€ข6h

Mike Brown Calls Out Refs ๐Ÿ˜ 

Knicks HC baffled by the foul discrepancy in Game 3 ๐ŸŽฅ

TRENDING ON B/R