In fact, it was so disappointing that the Belgian midfielder might not get a second.
Fellaini is a Manchester United player, it does not depend on us, but it depends on them.
He is a great player, but he is at another team. It appears he is waiting for Van Gaal. We will have to wait.
Is he the right player? We have players that work very well, whilst it also depends on who leaves. It is not easy to name names.
What features in a midfielder am I after? Players who have the mindset to win every game, then we can start to talk about the technical quality.
With our same mentality, but with a little more quality.
You can argue that Fellaini's United career was doomed from the start.
David Moyes encouraged links with a number of top-class midfielders last summer, but he ended up overpaying for Fellaini on deadline day.
It didn't help that he came from Everton. It did little to shake the belief many United fans had that Moyes was a better fit at Goodison Park than he was at Old Trafford.
Fellaini, too, did little during the season to suggest he had the ability to be a United player. His cause wasn't helped by wrist and back injuries.
Fellaini did well in games against Crystal Palace, West Brom and West Ham in the second half of the season, but United players earn their money in far bigger games.
During his time at Everton, Fellaini often got the better of United. The opening game of the 2012-13 season is just one example.
But that was usually when he was pushed further forward, behind a lone striker. It was from that position that he scored for Belgium against Algeria at the World Cup.
Deployed deeper in midfield by Moyes last season, Fellaini's touch and technique fell short when it really mattered.
Even with Napoli's interest, he might yet win a reprieve at United if Van Gaal can't find a replacement before the transfer deadline.
But if he does stay, he's got a lot to do before he proves his move from Everton wasn't doomed to fail from the start.
Like the new article format? Send us feedback!