Justus Sheffield: Prospect Profile for Cleveland Indians' No. 31 Overall Pick

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Justus Sheffield: Prospect Profile for Cleveland Indians' No. 31 Overall Pick
Graphic created by Bleacher Report

Player: Justus Sheffield

Drafted by: Cleveland Indians

Position: LHP

DOB: 05/13/1996 (Age: 18)

Height/Weight: 6’2”, 195 pounds

Bats/Throws: L/L

School: Tullahoma High School (Tenn.)

College Commitment: Vanderbilt



Baseball bloodlines run deep for left-hander Justus Sheffield, as he’s the nephew of former All-Star Gary Sheffield and younger brother to right-hander Jordan Sheffield, who missed most of last spring after undergoing Tommy John surgery and then turned down well above-slot money from the Red Sox as a 13th-rounder in favor of honoring his commitment to Vanderbilt.

While he’s not a hard thrower like Jordan, Justus has emerged as one of the more well-rounded and polished prep left-handers in this year’s class, showcasing advanced pitchability as well as a unique feel for his craft. Serving as Tullahoma’s ace this season, he won 10 games and posted a stellar 0.34 ERA with 131 strikeouts in 61.2 innings.

While he lacks physical projection, his mature, four-pitch mix leaves plenty of room for improvement and eventually should help him carve out a role in the middle of a major league rotation. Yet, with a strong commitment to join his brother next season at Vanderbilt, any team that is willing to take a flier on Sheffield in the early rounds must believe that he’s signable.


Full Scouting Report

Note: Numerical scores are on the conventional 20-80 scouting scale, with the current score first and projected score second.


6’2”, 195-pound left-hander is an above-average athlete; mature build requires little physical projection; delivery involves some effort with a decently sized leg kick and usually efficient mechanics; doesn’t always stay on line with the plate; arm action is loose and repeatable from three-quarters slot, though he does struggle to find a consistent release point at times in a given outing.

Courtesy of Perfect Game


Fastball: 50/55

Fastball isn’t overpowering but consistently registers at 88-92 mph and at times touches 93-94; doesn’t project to add velocity with physical growth; present feel for pounding zone and getting ahead with pitch; generates good arm-side run.

Curveball: 45/55

Good feel for a true curveball that he throws with consistent pace in the high 70s; pitch features hard, 1-to-7 break; present feel for locating it within the zone; tends to telegraph pitch when trying to locate pitch to arm side of the plate.


Slider: 45/60

Slider is the better of his two breaking balls; registers in the low 80s with good depth and tight spin; swing-and-miss potential when thrown off well-located fastball; future plus offering at maturity.

Courtesy of Big League Futures

Changeup: 50/60

Thrown in the low 80s with some fading action; sells the pitch with fastball-like arm speed and follow-through; highly effective offering when around the zone with his fastball; adept at spotting pitch to arm-side corner of the plate; tends to play up due to his advanced feel. 

Control: 45/55

Plus pitchability of an advanced, four-pitch mix; consistently around zone with full arsenal thanks to simple, repeatable delivery and fluid arm action; consistent strike-thrower.

Command: 45/55

Present ability to command pitches to arm side but doesn’t show same feel when attacking other side of the plate; clean delivery and athleticism suggest he has the potential for plus command at maturity.


MLB Player Comparison: Hyun-jin Ryu

Sheffield compares to Ryu for his advanced feel of a four-pitch mix and ability to change speeds without sacrificing control, as well as his potential to pitch in the middle of a big league rotation.


Projection: No. 3 starting pitcher


Major Leagues ETA: Late 2016


Chances of Signing: 50 percent

Sheffield, like his brother in 2013, is perceived to have a strong commitment to Vanderbilt, which means he’ll either need to come off the board early or receive a lucrative above-slot bonus to begin his professional career.

Follow Cleveland Indians from B/R on Facebook

Follow Cleveland Indians from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

Cleveland Indians

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.