Yankees All-Time All Star Team

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Yankees All-Time All Star Team

The Yankees have had some great players on their teams, and today I sift through to find the best.

This is part of a new series where I hope to eventually pick all stars for every team.

But today, we stick to the Yankees.  Here is the Yankee all-star team:

(Players are as good as their best year on the team, and are judged by their career and best year combined.)

Line Up:

SS:  Derek Jeter:  No questions here at short.

LF:  Don Mattingly:  I knew coming in Lou Gehrig would be at 1st, so I looked to see where else Matts could play, and saw LF, so he barely beat out Reggie Jackson for this spot.

2B:  Alofonso Soriano:  A had to look at stats carefully between him and Willie Randolf, but he came out with a higher batting average and about four times the home runs a year.

DH:  Ruth:  No space in the OF for him, so I stuck him here.

CF:  Micky Mantle:  One of the best CFrs ever, he deserves this spot.

3B:  A-rod:  Between him and Nettles, I had to choose A-rod.

1B:  Gehrig:  A tough selection over Mattingly, but a choice that had to be made. 

RF:  Joe DiMaggio:  Another great Yankees outfielder, he had a short career, but is still one of the best ever.

C:  Berra:  No question, as Posada was next closest.

Why the heck isn't he here:  Reggie Jackson?  While he's great, he couldn'e beat out Ruth, Mantle, DiMaggio, or even Mattingly, so he'll be on the bench along with Scooter, Maris, and Posada.


SP: Whitey Ford-It was hard to find starters, so I mostly went by wins.  Ford is in the HOF, and was a no question for me.

SP:  Andy Pettitte-Can't argue 185 Yankee wins, and 220 career wins.
SP: Mike Mussina-270 career wins, could have had 300.

SP: David Wells-Threw a no-no, and a good pitcher.
SP: David Cone-Another no-no, he had a pretty long Yankee career.
RP:  Rich (Goose) Gossage-In the HOF. 

RP: John Wetteland-Had 3 great years with the Yankees, and left after his fourth.
CL:  Mariano Rivera-Number two in career saves.

Why the heck isn't he here:  C.C. Sabathia?  Because he didn't have enough time on the Yankees.  But, watch out David Cone!

That's it.  Look for other teams shortly.

Follow New York Yankees from B/R on Facebook

Follow New York Yankees from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

New York Yankees

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.