To start Carragher in such an important game when he has made mistake after mistake is kamikaze management from Kenny Dalglish.
If Liverpool wants to win the FA Cup, Dalglish cannot start Carragher.
If you disagree, here are Carragher's seven worst moments this season.
Jamie Carragher didn’t make any mistakes (as he did in previous weeks), but he was dragged all over the place by Emmanuel Adebayor.
In the post-match interview, Adebayor said: "We know that if we run in behind Carragher and Agger, we give them a lot of trouble."
When Carragher decided to charge out to Adebayor, the Togolese forward would play an incisive pass, attacking the vacant space behind Carragher.
Adebayor made four passes that were turned into shots.
Jamie Carragher allowed Martin Petrov to cut in from the left and whilst the Liverpool defender made a successful tackle, it rebounded to Ivan Klasnić for a late consolation goal.
The issue at hand isn’t whether or not the penalty was justified, it was Jamie Carragher failing to keep up with Jonathan Walters after being caught out by a simple ball over the top.
Jamie Carragher was beaten to the corner by Danny Welbeck, whose header enabled Chicharito to poach the equalising goal.
Shaun Derry out-jumped Jamie Carragher to head in QPR’s first goal, which precipitated Liverpool’s downfall.
Robin van Persie was alert whilst Jamie Carragher was switched off. That is why he failed to get in front of van Persie for Arsenal's first goal.