On Heels of Recession, the Case for an Annual College Football Mercy Bowl

Mike Jones by Correspondent Written on December 30, 2008
Mercy_bowl_feature

Sports writers and commentators have been trying to make the point that 2008 was one of the greatest years in modern sports history.

Whether it was Michael Phelps' record eight gold medals, David Tyree's improbable catch to eventually shatter the Patriots' run for perfection or the marathon Federer-Nadal final at Wimbledon, the sports just seemed to be a little more dramatic, a little more historic and a little more magnificent than years past.

However, this notion doesn't seem to be much comfort to Americans as they are losing their jobs, their homes and their faith in a society built on the idealistic notion that fairness and justice will always overcome greed and derision.

What's beautiful about our sports culture as that it has the unique ability to redeem our faith in what's good about this country. Whether that's the "Miracle on Ice," Jesse Owens' triumph under Hitler's glare, or the simple joy of watching a baseball game as a tattered flag pulled from the wreckage of a fallen set of towers hovers over both home and opponent, always reminding us that while we compete, we are always one.

I thought about this as I was watching my beloved Wisconsin Badgers get their lunch handed to them by a superior Florida State Seminoles team in the Champs Sports Bowl. Watching the debacle on the couch, I figured I'd browse the web or get on this website to vent my frustration.

Instead, I came across this beautiful story by the AP's Ben Walker. It's the long-forgotten story about the 1960 Cal-Poly football team's tragic plane crash which killed 22 people, including 16 players, a manager, and a booster.

The next year, Fresno State and Bowling Green (the team that had just beat Cal-Poly before the crash) played what was called the "Mercy Bowl," a charity game where all proceeds benefited the victims' families. The game, through ticket sales and private donations, raised $278,000. It was a beautiful gesture of sportsmanship and charity...

...one that would only be repeated once in 1971, when three Cal-Fullerton coaches and a pilot met a similar tragedy.

According to Walker, of the 34 bowl games currently in Division I, not one is a 100 percent charity game. Granted, universities, conferences, and the host cities should benefit from the bowl games. Bowl games help fund academic and athletic scholarships, better facilities and aids local businesses and charities with the out-of-town patronage.

But, by and large, non-BCS bowl games are considered more exhibition than competition nowadays, thanks to the growing dichotomy of importance between the BCS games and the rest.

So wouldn't it be excellent to have a bowl game where two teams from places hit by tragedy, whether natural (like a hurricane) or man-made (take your pick) could play for a cause greater than mere rankings or booster pride? Sadly, there's never a shortage of tragedy, even in college football towns.

Virginia Tech, Northern Illinois, and Arizona have all recently felt the pain of campus classroom shootings. LSU, Miami, Tulane, and the other gulf coast schools are still in a region reeling from Katrina and other hurricanes over the years.

Single Page
Vote Now! - Author Poll

Would you watch a Mercy Bowl?

  • Yes, I'd do anything for charity
  • No, make the teams donate the $$$ without creating another bowl game
  • Maybe, depending on the teams
  • No, but I'd contribute no matter what
vote to see results
Results - Author Poll

Would you watch a Mercy Bowl?

  • Yes, I'd do anything for charity

    100.0%
  • No, make the teams donate the $$$ without creating another bowl game

    0.0%
  • Maybe, depending on the teams

    0.0%
  • No, but I'd contribute no matter what

    0.0%
  • Total votes: 1
(0)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

5 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

130
reads

5
comments

written on December 30, 2008 Opinion

The best newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.