Here are some of his best moments from his tenure in the Garden State, which lasted from 1991 to 2004, and included a host of records along with three Stanley Cup championships.
Niedermayer knotted Game 2 of the 1995 Stanley Cup Finals in Detroit, going coast-to-coast and burying his own rebound off the end boards past Mike Vernon to tie the contest at 2-2.
New Jersey native Jim Dowd then won it with just over a minute remaining in regulation, and the Devils took a 2-0 series lead en route to a sweep and their first NHL title.
Niedermayer again gave the Devils a boost in the Finals in 2000, skating end-to-end and flipping the puck past Ed Belfour in Game 6 in Dallas. Jason Arnott later won it in double-OT, and the Devils had their second Stanley Cup.
He had to beat his brother, Rob, to do it, but Niedermayer helped the Devils win their third Cup in 2003. He assisted on the Devils' first two goals in their 3-0 win over the Mighty Ducks of Anaheim in Game 7 at the Meadowlands.
Four years later, the Niedermayers would celebrate a Cup championship together in California, after the Ducks ousted Ottawa in five games.
On Feb. 5, 2003, with an assist against Washington, Niedermayer became the all-time leading regular-season scorer among defensemen in Devils history.
He left New Jersey a year later with 476 total points, which currently puts him fourth among all Devils' skaters. He is also tied for second overall in club annals with 364 assists, and 51 of his 112 total goals as a Devil came on the power play.
Niedermayer also collected 17 goals and 47 assists for 64 points in 146 playoff contests with New Jersey. And he is one of only five players to have been a part of each of the Devils' three Cup crowns.
Niedermayer's last hurrah as a Devil was winning the Norris Trophy as the NHL's best defenseman in 2003-04. He also served as team captain that year when Scott Stevens was sidelined by injury.
Niedermayer is also the first and only player to have won a Memorial Cup, a World Junior Championship, a World Championship, an Olympic gold medal, the Stanley Cup and a World Cup in his hockey career.
On Dec. 16, he followed both Stevens and Ken Daneyko as the third player in Devils' team history to have his jersey number retired by the club.