Prince Fielder: Should Washington Nationals Go All-In on 1B?

Ryan C. SmithContributor IIINovember 28, 2011

PHOENIX, AZ - OCTOBER 05:  Prince Fielder #28 of the Milwaukee Brewers hits a double in the fifth inning of Game Four of the National League Divison Series against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Chase Field on October 5, 2011 in Phoenix, Arizona.  (Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)
Christian Petersen/Getty Images

According to Fox Sports' Ken Rosenthal, the Nationals are making Prince Fielder their top offensive target, despite previous denial of interest in the services of the 27-year-old. If the Nationals were to add Fielder to the payroll, they'll need to address a few questions and move a number of pieces in the process. 

Acquiring Fielder creates an even bigger logjam at 1B than the one they currently have. Three different players started at 1B for the Nationals in '11 for an extended period of time. Adam LaRoche signed a two-year deal with the club last offseason and had surgery to repair a torn labrum in his shoulder in June. Breakout player Michael Morse and rookie Chris Marrero saw significant time at the position as well, both having success there. 

It is assumed that Morse will return to the OF regardless, meaning that LaRoche would return to starting at 1B, sending Marrero to spend more time at Triple-A Syracuse until injury or trade changes his situation. Add Fielder to the fold, and that leaves the Nationals with four potential 1B, who all are capable of adequate or better play at the position. 

Assuming the Nationals do not add Fielder and Marrero heads to Triple-A, the team's opening day lineup would likely look like this:

CF: TBD (Crisp, Upton, Span, Bernadina, whoever)

SS: Desmond

3B: Zimmerman

LF: Morse

ST. PETERSBURG, FL - SEPTEMBER 07:  Outfielder B. J. Upton #2 of the Tampa Bay Rays celebrates after outfielder Desmond Jennings #8 of the Rays hits a 10th-inning, game-winning home run against the Texas Rangers September 7, 2011 at Tropicana Field in St.
Al Messerschmidt/Getty Images


RF: Werth

1B: LaRoche

C: Ramos

2B: Espinosa

P: Zimmermann/Strasburg/FA









That offense could actually see great improvement assuming Ramos, Espinosa and Desmond continue to develop and improve, and the addition of a healthy LaRoche and bounce-back year for Werth. The Nationals will also likely get close to a full year of Zimmerman as well.

PHILADELPHIA, PA - SEPTEMBER 22: Michael Morse #38 and Ryan Zimmerman #11 of the Washington Nationals high five the bat boy after Morse hit a three run home run in the eighth inning against the Philadelphia Phillies at Citizens Bank Park on September 22,
Drew Hallowell/Getty Images

Now, assume the Nationals were to sign Fielder and move LaRoche, a starter like Lannan and a position player like Desmond, along with a prospect or two to acquire a top-flight starter and a CF/lead-off hitter. Here is an example of what it all could look like: 

CF: Upton

2B: Lombardozzi

3B: Zimmerman

1B: Fielder


LF: Morse

RF: Werth

C: Ramos

SS: Espinosa

P: Shields







Detwiler/Milone/Peacock, etc.


I know that the Rays wouldn't likely be interested in someone like Lannan with their SP depth, but they could go on to trade a Niemann or Davis and add a veteran LHP, or potentially move Lannan to the bullpen and work him as a specialist. It may not be the best example, but I could see the Nationals getting it done for a package like this:


Nats acquire:

SP James Shields

CF B.J. Upton


Rays acquire:

1B Chris Marrero

C Derek Norris

SP: John Lannan

RP: Ryan Mattheus 

SS: Ian Desmond


PTBNL (likely another reliever, or a low-level lead-off hitter type OF)

The Rays have been linked to Desmond before, and his returning home to Florida and Upton to Virginia/DC may be the best situation for both players.

The Rays would get a top-flight catching prospect in Norris and a former first-round pick to fill their 1B void for the long term in Marrero. Lannan is a quality No. 4 or 5 starter, and a southpaw at that. Mattheus has solid upside out of the 'pen and would strength the Rays' staff on the cheap. The Nats, of course, would get the true No. 1 starter they've been after for the past two offseasons. 

Fielder is the key to all this because without him, the Nationals need Marrero's depth at 1B in case of injury or a LaRoche trade. The Rays may think my trade proposal is a joke, or the Nationals could just as easily balk at the idea thinking they lose too much, especially if Shields is unwilling to sign long-term. But for the sake of the argument, if this were to happen, one question would still remain: What will it take to sign Prince Fielder?

If this question could be answered in terms of a deal that would be more than five years, I'd believe the Nationals would be making a mistake. I don't think Fielder will sign for less than six, unless he can get close to $30 million per year on a four- or five-year deal.

If the Nationals could sign him for five years at $130 million to $140 million, I'd say pull the trigger and make sure to front load the deal if possible. You could pay him roughly $30 million for the first three years and have it lowered into the low to mid 20s in the final two.

The only question is, would Fielder and his agent, the master of the deal, Scott Boras, go for it?