The Most Grossly Overpaid Athletes of 2011

Eric NewmanCorrespondent IIIDecember 5, 2011

The Most Grossly Overpaid Athletes of 2011

0 of 16

    Athletes earn big money because they generate big money. In many cases, the ginormous salaries are justified—pro athletes are the best in the world at what they do, and every week millions of people watch them and buy their jerseys and trading cards, their personal brands and the products they endorse.

    But all too often, things go awry. Athletes get injured and can't deliver their talent. They underperform. Or they just sucked in the first place and their potential was overestimated.

    Click on to see who got shackled with the golden handcuffs in 2011.

    Important Note: This is about how much athletes got paid THIS YEAR and THIS YEAR ALONE. This is not about how much they get paid over the life of a contract.

Honorable Mention: Peyton Manning, Indianapolis Colts

1 of 16

    2011 Salary: $23 Million

    OK, Manning has proved that he is worth every penny as a QB since the team can't win a game without him. But $23 million for sitting on a bench for a few hours each Sunday? Couldn't the guy at least carry a pom-pom?

15. Vernon Wells, Los Angeles Angels

2 of 16

    2011 Salary: $23 million

    Not worth it because: (a) He batted a meager .218 in the regular season, and (b) even he admits he's overpaid

    Perhaps if Wells worries more about getting his batting mojo back and less about what to name left field in Angel Stadium, he won't make this list next year.

14. Mark Sanchez, New York Jets

3 of 16

    2011 Salary: $17.25 million

    Not worth it because: Sanchez is getting paid like the big boys, but his stats aren't big-boy stats. 

    Check out this well-argued piece from Forbes writer Tom Van Riper: "Sanchez tops list of NFL's most overpaid." Sanchez's stats have only gotten worse since that article was written back at the start of the season.

13. Alex Rodriguez, New York Yankees

4 of 16

    2011 Salary: $32 million

    Not worth it because: (a) Sure, he's still a decent hitter, but his production value has gone way down. (b) Just 428 plate appearances in 99 games this year. (c) He's 36 years old.

12. Michael Vick, Philadelphia Eagles

5 of 16

    2011 Salary: $13 million (base) + $1.4 million (signing bonus) = $14.4 million

    Not worth it because: (1) He is literally the very definition of overpaid in at least one "dictionary." (2) He ranks 20th in passing yards. (3) He's thrown just as many interceptions as he has touchdowns so far this season. (4) He's just too damn injury prone.

11. Joe Mauer, Minnesota Twins

6 of 16

    2011 Salary: $23 million

    Not worth it because: The guy can't stay healthy; he played just 82 games this year. That means he was paid over a quarter million dollars PER GAME.

10. Ville Leino, Buffalo Sabres

7 of 16

    2011 Salary: $4.5 million

    Not worth it because: In his first 20 games as the new center for the Sabres, Ville Leino got just two goals and three assists. He's already whining about wanting to return to his old position of left wing. About the only good thing you can say about him is that he isn't as much of a waste as Tim Connolly was. Which brings us to... (see next slide).

9. Tim Connolly, Toronto Maple Leafs

8 of 16

    2011 Salary: $4.75 million

    Not worth it because: Another guy who is always hurt. He only played nine games out of the first 20. Has just two goals and five assists. 

8. Rashard Lewis, Washington Wizards

9 of 16

    2010-2011 Salary: $18.9 million

    Not worth it because: Averaged just 11.7 points and 5.1 rebounds per game in 57 games last season.

    During the lockout, Lewis was often singled out as a prime example of an overpaid player.

7. Fernando Alonso, Formula One

10 of 16

    2011 Salary: $42 million

    Not worth it because: (1) Sebastian Vettel, the reigning world champion, only makes a little more than a quarter of what Alonso makes. (2) He hasn't been ranked No. 1 since 2006.

6. Sam Bradford, St. Louis Rams

11 of 16

    2011 Salary: Wait for it, wait for it...$18.4 million

    Rant: OK, so the guy is in his second season, and there wasn't much choice to paying Bradford what he got paid. Still, you know the system is effed up when a guy who does stuff like this, and who has only put up two wins, makes more than Tom Brady.

5. Barry Zito, San Francisco Giants

12 of 16

    2010-2011 Salary: $18.5 million

    Not worth it because: In the simple yet profound words of Grant Bisbee, editor at Baseball Nation: "Uninspiring mediocrity is something fans will tolerate from an overpaid player. Abject suck is not."

    Perhaps if Captain Quirk spends less time crooning and more time improving his game, he won't be on this list next year.

4. Tiger Woods, PGA

13 of 16

    2011 earnings: $62 million

    Not worth it because: (a) He went two years without a win (just snapped). (b) Even he admitted he's been playing sucky lately. (c) Current world ranking (as of Nov. 22): 51st.

    Sure, most of that money is coming from endorsements and not a salary, but when a company pays you big bucks to make its product look like a winner, don't you have to be a winner?

3. Danica Patrick, NASCAR

14 of 16

    2011 Salary: Estimated $12 million

    Overpaid because: She doesn't win. Also, all this racing money is keeping her away from her true calling.

2. Matt Cassel, Kansas City Chiefs

15 of 16

    2011 Salary: $12.455 million (base + bonus)

    Not worth it because: Very lackluster stats and overall far worse than last year.

1. Samuel Eto'o, Anzhi Makhachkala

16 of 16

    2011 Salary: Approximately $546,000

    Not so much, you say. Not that impressive. Oh, well, allow me to finish the sentence:

    Approximately $546,000 PER WEEK.

    Overpaid because: He's playing for a team that no one outside of the North Caucasus can pronounce, in a war-torn republic that no one has heard of. Since when have obscurity and wealth partnered up?