Toronto Maple Leafs: Thoughts and Predictions for the Leafs' Line-Up in November

Curtis NgContributor IIIOctober 10, 2011

TORONTO, CANADA - OCTOBER 8: Phil Kessel #81 and John-Michael Liles #24 of the Toronto Maple Leafs celebrate Joffrey Lupul #19 goal against the Ottawa Senators during NHL action at the Air Canada Centre October 8, 2011 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (Photo by Abelimages/Getty Images)
Abelimages/Getty Images

Something's gotta give.

Due to the Leafs' depth at the defense position, new acquisition Cody Franson has had to watch the first two Leaf games of this season from the press box.

Scratches, demotions, and/or trades will have to occur when Tim Connolly and Nazem Kadri return from injury, because of the number of players who currently deserve roster spots.

Clarke MacArthur's two-game suspension is done, so a change will immediately have to be made.

There are a couple players who I think will be traded this year, but I won't speculate about possible destinations or return in this article because this isn't meant to be a rumour article.

Here is my projected line-up for the Leafs in roughly a few weeks' time:



Joffrey Lupul - Tim Connolly - Phil Kessel

Nikolai Kulemin - Mikhail Grabovski - Clarke MacArthur

Matthew Lombardi - Tyler Bozak - Colby Armstrong

Philippe Dupuis - David Steckel - Mike Brown

Colton Orr

TORONTO, CANADA - DECEMBER 2: Nazem Kadri #43 of the Toronto Maple Leafs breaks his stick after missing a shot during game action against the Edmonton Oilers at the Air Canada Centre December 2, 2010 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (Photo by Abelimages / Get
Abelimages/Getty Images


Jay Rosehill

Matt Frattin (to AHL)

Nazem Kadri (to AHL)



Dion Phaneuf - John-Michael Liles 

Luke Schenn - Cody Franson

Jake Gardiner - Mike Komisarek

Carl Gunnarsson (traded)

Matt Lashoff (call-up)



James Reimer

Jonas Gustavsson

BUFFALO, NY - SEPTEMBER 24: Patrick Kaleta #36 of the Buffalo Sabres collides with Matt Frattin #39 of the Toronto Maple Leafs at First Niagara Center on September 24, 2011 in Buffalo, New York.  (Photo by Rick Stewart/Getty Images)
Rick Stewart/Getty Images



Part of the reason I chose to predict the Leafs' line-up for November is because that's roughly when Kadri is expected to return.

It was mostly an arbitrary choice, though; I could have picked December or January and the article would largely remain the same.

Now unfortunately for Kadri, his preseason performance wasn't that great. He didn't show that he was clearly better than Frattin, who he was competing with for the third-line winger position. Then he got injured.

To make matters even worse for Kadri, Frattin put in two solid, if somewhat unremarkable, regular-season performances on the Leafs' current top line alongside Grabovski and Kulemin.

Let's talk about Frattin for a minute.

So far, including the preseason and the two regular season games that he has played, Frattin has not looked out of place at all. He has played on different lines with a variety of linemates and has looked good with all of them.

Based on his recent play, it would be a shame for Frattin to get sent down to the Marlies.

Based on who we've got in the line-up, however, it looks like he will have to spend some time with the Marlies this year.

UNIONDALE, NY - MARCH 08:  Carl Gunnarsson #36 of the Toronto Maple Leafs skates against the New York Islanders at the Nassau Coliseum on March 8, 2011 in Uniondale, New York. The Islanders defeated the Leafs 4-3 in overtime.  (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Gett
Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

If Frattin's getting sent down, so is Kadri.

Taking a look at my projected bottom-six group, you can see a couple really annoying lines to play against.

The third line of Lombardi, Bozak, and Armstrong is a mix of speed and grit. Each of those guys can contribute a good amount of supplementary offense as well, which is something the Leafs did not have last season.

The fourth line of Dupuis, Steckel, and Brown, I like very much. Who needs tough guys when you have tough players who can actually play in a number of situations as needed? All three of those guys are excellent penalty killers and hard hitters.

On a side note, Mike Brown is probably one of my favourite Leafs right now, despite the fact he recently shaved his moustache. Nobody on the team plays harder than he does; he brings it every single shift.

Anyway, onto the D-corps.

Prior to the season opener, I had Gunnarsson penciled in as the sixth or seventh D-man. I was absolutely shocked when I heard he would be playing on the top pairing with Phaneuf.

I've got nothing against Gunnarsson, but I don't think he belongs there. That leads me to believe he's being dangled for visiting scouts.

Let's be honest: has he really played so well as to deserve a spot on the top pairing?

TORONTO, CANADA - OCTOBER 6:  Jake Gardiner #51 of the Toronto Maple Leafs tries to check Erik Cole #72 of the Montreal Canadiens in a game on October 6, 2011 at the Air Canada Centre in Toronto, Canada. The Leafs defeated the Canadiens 2-0. (Photo by Cla
Claus Andersen/Getty Images

He's been reliable, but not awesome.

I think he and Bozak are the ones most likely to be traded this season, though I think Bozak will last longer than Gunnarsson.

I paired Liles and Phaneuf because that pairing creates options. Both like to shoot the puck, so it's not going to be like last year, where you knew Phaneuf was going to be the shooter every time.

Schenn and Franson, two big guys: one can hit and the other can shoot.

Gardiner and Komisarek because they seem to be complementing each other right now. Gardiner can use a big, physical veteran like Komisarek to back him up, while Komisarek can use a mobile puck-moving defenseman like Gardiner to pass to.

Lashoff gets the call-up so Aulie can continue playing with the Marlies, which definitely beats watching the Leafs from the press box.

There is the possibility that Gardiner will start making some rookie mistakes and be benched or demoted as a result.

He has played somewhat well to date, but it would not hurt at all for him to play some big minutes down in the AHL.

His departure would open up a spot for Franson, who I think should be allowed to play ASAP.

I like that Aulie is in the AHL right now because he looked shaky during camp, and I wouldn't mind seeing Gardiner down there, at least for a little while.

I don't think I would mind seeing Kadri down there for a while either, but one person who I think should stick with the big club all year is Matt Frattin.

He skates well, he has a decent shot, and hits hard. He's a smart player who can play on any line for the Leafs. To me, there's nothing left for him to learn at the AHL level.

Frattin is actually only about three months younger than Phil Kessel, so it's not like he's a rookie straight out of junior.

He would look great playing on the wing beside Lombardi and Armstrong.

Bozak was the young guy with some skill who could take a few face-offs and kill penalties. Now the Leafs have Steckel to take face-offs and Frattin, the young guy with skill.

I like Bozak, but as many people will point out, he's somewhat easily replaceable.

I think he'll eventually be traded this season, but I think he'll stay on the third line for now. To me, Gunnarsson will go sooner rather than later, because there's only so long a bottom-pairing guy can stay on the top pairing.

All this is idle speculation, of course.

I have no doubt that, in a few weeks time, I will look back on this article and shake my head at how not thought-out this was.

However, this is how I see it right now, and I would welcome any thoughts you might have on the matter.


    Sounds like Auston Matthews will finally return for Leafs

    Toronto Maple Leafs logo
    Toronto Maple Leafs

    Sounds like Auston Matthews will finally return for Leafs

    James O'Brien
    via ProHockeyTalk

    NHL Board of Governors: Now you can blame Toronto for goalie interference reviews too

    Toronto Maple Leafs logo
    Toronto Maple Leafs

    NHL Board of Governors: Now you can blame Toronto for goalie interference reviews too

    Pension Plan Puppets
    via Pension Plan Puppets

    When Will the Leafs Run Out of Jersey Numbers?

    Toronto Maple Leafs logo
    Toronto Maple Leafs

    When Will the Leafs Run Out of Jersey Numbers?

    Will McMillan
    via TheLeafsNation

    Maple Leafs’ Recent Swaps With the Stars

    Toronto Maple Leafs logo
    Toronto Maple Leafs

    Maple Leafs’ Recent Swaps With the Stars

    Andrew Forbes
    via The Hockey Writers