Rochester Americans: This is What Two Million Dollars in Scouting Gets You

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Rochester Americans: This is What Two Million Dollars in Scouting Gets You

So, the Rochester Americans lost to the Toronto Marlies tonight at Blue Cross Arena by the final score of 5-2, in front of one of the smallest crowds that anyone could remember.

After the teams were done warming up, I was able to count just over 200 people in seats around the arena.  On my way to spend money on concessions I asked a few ushers as well as some old timers if they had ever seen the arena like this. Everyone either shook their head in disbelief, and a couple said, “At least not in the new building.”

I feel sorry for all of the players.  While a few of them have made bad mistakes, I’m not going to blame them for this season.  During the post-game show, Stefan Meyer made a comment about the coaching staff being terrific, and said if they all continue to work hard like they have been, eventually something has to happen.

The players had been giving a solid effort, trying really hard and doing their best—until last night.  Against the Marlies they just could not seem to get it all together.  The Marlies are a team that isn’t doing too well either, so last night the game should have been different.

Talking to players, many of them say they’ve never been through anything like this in their lives.

During the post game show Stefan Meyer also said, “This is affecting everybody. Away from the rink it’s starting to affect our everyday lives.”  He’s not the only player to make comments like that.

Meyer also commented about hearing a fan yell about hating all of them.

As I stated recently, the players only have themselves to blame.

But you have fans sitting in the balcony heckling our own players.  You could hear boos after the Marlies scored, but I’m not quite sure if that was aimed at them, or our own team for screwing up.

Only one out of the three local news stations had video highlights of the game on broadcasts at 11 last night.

Lewis Staats has said that it’s up to the fans to support this team.  What he should have said was that they’re working hard to improve the team, so fans will want to watch.

The Amerks are tied for dead last with the San Antonio Rampage in the AHL.  Each team has five points, and each team has only won two games.

Is it a coincidence that the Panthers used to be a sole affiliate of the Rampage?

And this is only 17 games into the season.

 

All of this led to me introducing myself to the director of player personnel for the Florida Panthers, Jack Birch.  He is the guy who brought us our team from Florida.

Here is his short bio on the Panthers site:

Since joining the organization in 2004, Birch has served the club in several capacities that included both pro scout (2007-08) and director of hockey operations (2004-07). Prior to joining the Panthers organization, he served as president of J.B. Scouting Service. His worldwide scouting service specialized in the evaluation and rankings of players at the professional and amateur levels throughout North America and Europe.

The Peterborough, Ontario native began his career in the National Hockey League when he served as an assistant coach with the New York Rangers from 1985-87. Birch joined the NHL Central Scouting Bureau in 1989 as a scouting consultant to the director of CSB and several NHL teams, and developed a computerized scouting program for the selection of professional hockey players. He spent three years with the CSB before joining the Canucks organization.

I walked up during the second intermission tonight to introduce myself and ask what’s being done to improve the team.  I approached expecting to hear the company line about “trying,” but instead spoke to someone who appeared annoyed, defensive, and almost argumentative.  Which I could understand, sort of.

There’s a number of possibilities going on here, all of which I’m speculating upon.

Jack Birch is simply the guy taking the heat.  It could be that his hands are tied by Jacques Martin (Panthers GM) and Alan Cohen (Panthers owner).

He is clueless.

I’ll admit, I’m not the smartest person, especially in memorizing tons of hockey players names.  I asked him why no one has been brought in to try and improve this team.  He asked me to name some players, I wasn’t able to, to which he replied I have no right running a web site writing about a hockey team because of “bad comments that can’t be backed up.”

I’m not a professional journalist.  Maybe someday I will be.  I read the news as players get released, or are available, and then signed within 24 hours by another team.  I’m passionate about the Amerks.  I guess I should have had names ready and able to rattle off the top of my head, and I apologized for not being ready.  But I’m not a scout—he is.

Jack Birch said that he does the same thing, looking for players, and no one has been available—which leads me to believe that players and agents have no desire to work with the Florida Panthers organization.

I took a moment to explain to him how dedicated we are as fans to not only the Amerks, but also taken to supporting the Panthers.  I told him to come read our web site and we’re not just some “bloggers” trashing the team making up hogwash.

I approached again with another Amerks fan who was able to name a number of players, Alyssa also brought him a list of players names.

The response back was, “we spend two million a year on scouting.”

How do you reply to a comment like that when your team has only won two games and is on the verge of losing its 14th game in regulation?

We then proceeded to throw names back and forth of Amerks who probably aren’t at the AHL level, none of which I’ll name because it’s not fair to them.  Jack Birch defended them saying, either they’ve only played in X amount of games, or it’s their first season.

The point is, we have a team of young players and rookies that have talent—but not enough to compete and win games.

Over the summer we were told by a previous owner, current owners, and Jack Birch that they’d be active in free agency in building a competitive team.  We were also told that if that didn’t turn out to be the case, changes would be made.

One change that has been made was signing Riley Emmerson (which was a good one) to help keep our team from getting pushed around like they did last year.  We havn’t been pushed around one game.

Another change was swapping David Shantz for Tyler Plante.

Maybe it’s not fair to single out Jack Birch.  Maybe he’s in a horrible position, just as the players are to fans taking the heat.  I’m not sure.

I expected to have a nice discussion where someone would say thanks for being here, thanks for supporting, we’re doing everything we can, but we just can’t agree to terms with anyone that can possibly fill any voids.  Instead I got the complete opposite, and it almost made me want to leave.  Less than 1,000 people in the building, people are asking the person responsible for providing a competitive team, and he more or less says to get lost.

People think attendance is bad now. I can’t wait until a Wednesday-night game over the winter, when a snow storm is predicted and it’s 10 degrees out.

It’s going to get worse before it gets any better.

All it would take is for someone in Amerks’ or Panthers’ management to acknowledge what is going on, and tell people they are working together to try and figure something out.

That hasn’t happened.

I’m an Amerks fan, and I always will be.  But this team is being driven into the ground and no one seems to be doing anything about it.

Jody Gage, you’ve been an Amerk for basically your whole life.  You know the pride and tradition that goes along with this team and it’s disappearing.  Doesn’t that break your heart?

 

Load More Stories

Out of Bounds