Trade Analysis: Royals Get 1B Mike Jacobs for RHP Leo Nunez

Travis NelsonSenior Analyst IOctober 31, 2008

The Kansas City Royals think they've plugged one of the many holes in their lineup with the acquisition of 1B Mike Jacobs for relief pitcher Leo Nunez, but have they?

Royals firstbasemen had the 4th worst OPS in MLB in 2008, and the three below them (Oakland, SF and Seattle) were all rebuilding teams playing in severe pitchers' parks, so if you adjust for park context, the Royals are probably last, or very close to it.

So almost anythingis an improvement, right? I mean, it's not tough to do better than the likes of Ross Gload and Mark Teahen, you would think.

The trouble, however, is that of the handful of players the Royals have who might be worth keeping, three of them (Billy Butler, Ryan Shealy and Kila Ka'aihue) also play first base. There's always the DH of course, since Royals' Designated Hitters in 2008 were nothing special, either (9th out of 14 AL teams in OPS). Except that's still only two lineup spots for four players. This means one of three things:

1) The Royals will trade one or more of their prospects.

This is possible, as there are probably several teams who would be interested in someone like Billy Butler or Kila Ka'aihue, a young hitter with patience and pop who would be forced to play for the MLB minimum for the next few years.

This would be a smart thing to do, which is why it's probably not in the Royals' plans. Not as smart as, say, not trading for Jacobs in the first place, but smarter than doing nothing, in light of current circumstances.

2) The Royals plan to let those guys get more seasoning at Triple-A Omaha and/or on the bench.

This would be a smart thing to do if either of them had anything left to prove in the minors. But they don't, or at least Butler doesn't. Butler's career minor league line is .336/.416/.561 in almost 400 games.  The man can flat-out hit, even if he can't field, but that's why we have the DH.

Ka'aihue hit approximately .315/.450/.630 combined at Double-A and Triple-A this year, an impressive line, but only 33 of his 771 career minor league games are at Triple-A. (He didn't embarrass himself in 21 MLB at-bats either.) He'll be 25 at the end of March, so the Royals may feel like they have a little time to see if he's the real deal.

For the record, Shealy's got impressive minor league numbers, too, but most of those were put up in hitters' parks in the Colorado farm system, and he's often been old for his leagues. He's going to be 29 next year, so they may not look at him as an everyday starter at first base.

3) The Royals plan to "mix and match", go with the "hot hand" and generally "ruin the careers" of all four players, plus Jose Guillen's, just to be fair.

Now that sounds like the Kansas City Royals we all know and love!

Jacobs hit 32 homers and drove in 92 for the Marlins this year, both career highs, as were his 67 runs scored. Unfortunately, his 119 strikeouts were also a career high, and his .247 batting average and .299 OBP were both career lows.

Jacobs wouldn't be a bad pickup if the Royals didn't already have three decent possibilities at the position he plays, or if they had a lineup full of patient hitters who can be on base in front of an all-or-nothing guy like Jacobs. But the Royals front office can never just cave in a rebuild completely, and Jacobs comes with the "Proven Veteran" tag tattooed on the back of his neck, so, here he is.

Plus, he's about to get expensive, which is why the Marlins were shopping him. After making the MLB minimum for the last three-plus years, Jacobs is eligible for salary arbitration, and will probably draw something like $4 to $6 million. The Royals are, like many of the bottom-feeders in MLB, flush with revenue sharing money, but they don't know how to spend it.

Three years ago they were picking up guys like Scott Elarton and Mark Redman and Reggie Sanders and Mark Grudzielanek, supposedly to help the youngsters develop in a more stable environment.  Though the Royals have improved from 62 to 69 to 75 wins in that span, they still don't seem like they're just a player or two away from being a playoff contender, and it would be difficult to say that Elarton or Redman deserve any credit for the development of Zach Greinke or Joakim Soria. 

Of that group, only Grudz remained in 2008.  His contract is now up and the Royals don't have anyone else qualified to play second base. Alberto Callaspo might be worth a long look, but he'll be hard pressed as an every day player. Shortstop/2B Mike Aviles looks like a late bloomer who may have a few decent years in him, and Alex Gordon should continue to develop.

If they can let Butler DH and if Jacobs continues to be at least mediocre (or better yet, if he flops and Ka'aihue thrives...) the infield and DH spots might be OK.

The trouble is that most of the rest of the lineup is filled with professional Out-Makers. John Buck has been the Royals' regular catcher for almost five years, and has yet to post an adjusted OPS higher than 90 in any season. This year, at age 27, when he should have been having his best season, he hit .224 with nine homers. His back-up, Miguel Olivo, hit 12 in 25 fewer games. The Royals' catching corps ranked 21st in OPS among the 30 MLB teams.

And the outfield is even worse. Mark Teahen got a little of his "power" back, hitting 15 homers, but lost 30 points in batting average, so his slugging percentage was basically unchanged. Jose Guillen, despite the 97 RBIs, had his worst full year in a decade, with an OPS of 91, an OPB of .300 and just 66 runs scored.

David DeJesus was pretty good, but he can't carry a team, especially not one that insists on giving Joey Gathright 300 chances to prove he still can't hit. Overall, Royals outfielders ranked 20th (RF), 23rd (LF) and 29th(CF) in OPS in 2008, and among those, only Teahen has any real chance of improving.  But that's still about half the lineup that's in about the bottom third of the MLB ranks for their positions. 

DeJesus is likely to get a little worse, and Guillen is what he is: An aging, below-average hitter and fielder making $12 million for each of the next two years, whether he improves or not.

And I haven't even gotten into the pitching. Zach Greinke looks like he's back and Gil Meche was solid once again, but it remains to be seen whether Luke Hochevar and/or Kyle Davies will develop, or if Brian Bannister can get back to the form that made him look so promising in 2007.

They've got a decent closer and a couple of worthwhile relief pitchers, but not much else, and little help coming from Triple-A. (Carlos Rosa is the closest thing to a real prospect still down there, and he needs to prove himself at Triple-A a little more.)

Now would be a great time to take a chance and trade Meche, who, after two solid years, looks like a consistent, LAIM-plus, but who probably won't be worth the $35 million they still owe him for the next three years.

The team should be trading away expensive players who won't likely help them toward a championship, instead of acquiring them. Lots of teams could use a guy like Meche, or what they think Meche will be, and the Royals could probably get a pretty good outfielder in return.

Leo Nunez, the pitcher they gave up for Jacobs, was a starter in the minors but his thin frame (6'1", 160) scares scouts. Still, lots of skinny guys have turned out to be pretty good, and he ought to get a chance. It's not that they couldn't afford to give him up, just that there were more pressing needs than an "established veteran" (read: "proven mediocrity") for first base.

All of this is to say that while the Royals have some needs, and could afford to trade away a pitching prospect, they have lots of needs more pressing than yet another first baseman/DH.

If there's an upside to this, it's that Jacobs had an abnormally low BABIP this year, just .260, where the MLB average is around .300 or so. If he comes back to the balls-in-play norm in 2009, he could see a 20-30 point improvement in his batting average, and the Royals will look like geniuses! You heard it here first, folks.


    Braves Release Jose Bautista

    MLB logo

    Braves Release Jose Bautista

    Timothy Rapp
    via Bleacher Report

    James Paxton's Complete Game Lifts Mariners Win Over Tigers

    MLB logo

    James Paxton's Complete Game Lifts Mariners Win Over Tigers

    via thenewstribune

    Howie Kendrick Has Ruptured Achilles, Juan Soto Recalled

    MLB logo

    Howie Kendrick Has Ruptured Achilles, Juan Soto Recalled

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report

    Yankees Power Their Way Past the Royals, 8-3

    Kansas City Royals logo
    Kansas City Royals

    Yankees Power Their Way Past the Royals, 8-3

    Pete Caldera
    via North Jersey