The Detroit Lions Square Peg Brigade: Third Installment in a Series

Michael SuddsCorrespondent IMarch 31, 2011

MIAMI - DECEMBER 26: Quarterback Shaun Hill #14 of the Detroit Lions is sacked by Chris Clemons #30 of the Miami Dolphins at Sun Life Stadium on December 26, 2010 in Miami, Florida.  (Photo by Marc Serota/Getty Images)
Marc Serota/Getty Images

It’s time for the third installment of the “Square Peg Brigade” series. The point of the article is to visit those players added to the Lions roster in 2010 via trade, free agency, or the waiver wire.

These players found themselves as square pegs in new schemes, or were roster cut-down casualties with their former teams.  Some were snatched off the practice squad.

It is a testament to the Lions organization that they have brought so many players who improved the depth, and quality of the roster in one year. Some will go down as stopgaps as the Lions wind down their epic rebuilding program. Some will go on as starters, who will make even greater contributions moving forward.

Some will move on to other teams who view them as the upgrade that the Lions envisioned them to be when they acquired them. In some instances, the Lions will receive compensation, which is a value added proposition.

There were 10 defensive players who had starting roles, but were not on the 2009 roster. Only three offensive players fit the criteria, but their impact has been more than anyone could ask.

So, without further ado, here’s three players who are worthy members of the “Square Peg Brigade.”


QB Shaun Hill

Hill, the much traveled undrafted rookie free agent in 2002, was Lions offensive coordinator Scott Linehan’s protégé in Minnesota where he played two snaps in the “Victory" formation.

In 2006, Hill was traded to the 49ers, where he was the third QB for the entire season.

Hill was pressed into a starting role due to injuries to Trent Dilfer, and Alex Smith in 2007. He did so well, that he was elevated to a backup role in 2008.

Here’s where the thick plottens...Er, the plot thickens. 49ers head coach Mike Nolan hired Mike Martz as offensive coordinator, after a disastrous tenure in Detroit.

Martz launched a smear campaign against Hill, saying that Hill’s arm was weak, and (his crony) J.T. O’Sullivan (remember him?) deserved the starting QB job.

JTO got his shot, and turned in a coach killing performance.

In midseason, Nolan was replaced by Mike Singletary. Singletary’s first act as head coach was to “Frog march” Martz to the door. O’Sullivan packed his bags, while Hill snickered in Martz’s dog house.

Hill came on to go 6-2 in the second half of the season, and looked like a lock as the starter in 2009.

Let’s fast forward to March, 2010, or Hill will make an entire article. The 49ers had David Carr, Alex Smith, Troy Smith, and Hill on the roster. The 49ers were not sold on any of their four QBs as “the franchise.” That’s one QB too many, and the 49ers were determined to lighten the load.

Mayhew sniffed out the opportunity, and offered a 7th round draft pick for Hill. The 49ers bit, and swallowed. Hard.

So, in essence, The Lions copped Hill for a box of Cracker Jacks, and two BART tokens. The 49ers were “Mayhewed.” Hill, like Stefan Logan was a roster numbers casualty. A square peg.

So, how’d that work out for you, San Fran? Now, you are still looking for the franchise, and have three QB’s that you can‘t move.  Clearly, the 49ers traded the wrong QB.

Hill’s 2010 season is well documented, and I won’t bore you with the details. Suffice it to say that Hill went on to become the best backup QB in the league.

Are there any dissenting votes? I thought not.

With Hill, what you see is what you get. I, for one, will take it. He’s earned his spurs, and has become one of my “pet cats.”

Hmm, I wonder what Hill’s value is on the market these days? I would think a second round pick, at least. Not bad for an undrafted rookie, eh?


DT Corey Williams

Corey Williams could be credited with the Blitzkrieg rebuild of the Lions defensive line into an elite unit in one year.  The Domino effect.

Williams, the Packers 6th round draft pick (179th overall) in 2004, became an All Pro selection in Green Bay.  He was dealt to the Cleveland Browns shortly after getting the “franchise” tag laid on him by the Packers in 2008.

Williams had a promising debut in the land of Cleve, but was out of place as a DE in the Browns 3-4 defense. The Browns concurred, and dropped a dime on Martin Mayhew in March, 2010.

Williams, the square peg in the 3-4 Browns defense, was sent to Motown along with a seventh round draft pick for the Lions fifth round pick in 2010.

I don’t know about you, but that looks like pretty good fishing to me.

With Williams in the pride, and the knowledge that the Lions would draft Ndamakong Suh, the table was set for DE Kyle Vanden Bosch. If KVB had any lingering doubts about going to Detroit, they were dashed when he did the math. “Hm, I’m about to become the leader of an elite unit. “OK, I’m all in.”

I know, I made that up, but the thought process had to be along those lines between the first, and second glass of "hopium" laced wine that head coach Jim Schwartz brought to the midnight party.

Williams has been solid in every respect save one. Those pesky offsides penalties. Twelve, to be exact. This impacted not only on his own performance, but the performance of the defense as a whole.

You know it’s coming. Somebody stop me! I can’t resist it!

C’mon, man?

“Williams, are you a right tackle who’s blind in his left eye?”

Williams has shown little inclination to change his habits, so the Lions should change them for him. An intervention, of sorts.

Williams should be sent to the “Riders of the Lonesome Pine” rehab center. He can watch Sammie Lee Hill win his job, and enter the 12 step program.

Note, that none of those steps shall be taken prior to the snap. Setbacks are inevitable, but with patience, and the gentle counseling, and guidance of defensive line coach Chris Kocurek, and defensive coordinator Gunther Cunningham, Williams will be a contributor on defense for many years.

“C’mon, Gunny! Put down that cattle prod!”


WR Nate Burleson

Burleson, a third round draft pick by the Vikings in 2003, was the go to guy in Scott Linehan’s high powered Vikings offense. He racked up over 1,000 receiving yards in 2004 when teammate Randy Moss suffered a leg injury. More importantly, Burleson set an NFL record with three punt returns of over 90 yards. This record would be shattered by Chicago’s Devin Hester.

In 2006, Burleson signed a seven year, $49 million offer sheet with the Seahawks. Here’s where it gets a little weird. The Offer sheet contained a “poison pill” clause.

The clause stated that if Burleson played 5 games in 2006 in the state of Minnesota, the entire $49 million would be guaranteed. This effectively prevented the Vikings from matching the Seahawks offer.

Poison pill clauses are no longer allowed by the league office. Geez, I wonder why?

Burleson became an unrestricted free agent in 2010. In a Lions staff meeting prior to free agency, Lions offensive coordinator Scott Linehan mentioned that he’d like to have a player like Burleson.

The story goes that head coach Jim Schwartz told Linehan, “You want a guy like Burleson? Get on a plane, and go sign Burleson.”

The smell of burning shoe leather filled the Allen Park Lions HQ as Linehan raced for the airport.

OK, I made that last part up, but you get the picture.

At the same time that Schwartz was drinking wine with DE Kyle Vanden Bosch, Linehan was signing Burleson to a five year, $25 million dollar deal.

Did Burleson qualify as a “Square Peg” in Seattle? He must have, since the Seahawks failed to offer him a contract prior to free agency.

In any event, Burleson, like so many other Seahawks, found a home in Detroit. He’s been an excellent compliment to WR Calvin Johnson.

Burleson played 880 snaps in 2010, where he was targeted 85 times in 14 games. Burleson made 55 catches (64.7 percent avg) for 625 yards (11.4 avg).

Obviously, Burleson’s production will improve twofold if QB Matthew Stafford can stay on the field. Watching Stafford working with Burleson I had the sense that they had a laser-like connection.

One can only hope that the phrase “Stafford to Burleson” becomes a household phrase for many years to come.

Note: The stats for this article were provided by Pro Football Focus, and


Fourth installment preview

In the 4th installment of the “Square Peg Brigade,” we will look at FS John Wendling, LB Bobby Carpenter, and CB Jonathan Wade.

Stay tuned!

Mike Sudds is a Syndicated Feature Columnist for Bleacher Report. Mike is also an analyst and correspondent for


    Patricia Getting Used to Big-Picture Draft

    Detroit Lions logo
    Detroit Lions

    Patricia Getting Used to Big-Picture Draft

    Josh Alper
    via ProFootballTalk

    Cook (Knee) Should Be Ready to Go in Training Camp

    NFL logo

    Cook (Knee) Should Be Ready to Go in Training Camp

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report

    Former NFL Defensive End Dee Hardison Dies at 61

    NFL logo

    Former NFL Defensive End Dee Hardison Dies at 61

    Charean Williams
    via ProFootballTalk

    Report: WR Callaway's Drug Test Came Back Diluted

    NFL logo

    Report: WR Callaway's Drug Test Came Back Diluted

    Alec Nathan
    via Bleacher Report