The AP Got It Wrong: Top Five in the Wrong Order!

Emily Thompson by Correspondent Written on September 07, 2008
762080830126_youngstown_st_v_os_feature

On Saturday, Sep. 6, this Buckeye was stuck at a 12-hour shift at the ever-failing Steve & Barry's—effectively ruining this glorious day.  So I've decided to give my opinions on the Top Five (AP).  I have to get some football into my system—I'm having withdrawal.

 

1. USC

As a Buckeye, I'm still uninspired, and I felt like a traitor for typing the letters U-S-C, but still.  No game this week.  How they stay No. 1 without proving anything, I don't know.  Sure, they dominated a very down Virginia last week, but other teams dominated both weeks.  I'm not saying they are a bad team—I'm just saying they are a No. 2 team.

 

2. Georgia

After being snubbed via AP/Coaches/any poll in the world last week, the Bulldogs did just fine.  I'm still shocked they are below USC (again with the letters).  In my opinion, they started out No. 1, they played like No. 1, and they deserve to be No. 1.  They have done nothing to even hint that they shouldn't be, yet USC sits perched in their place.

Now let's all grow a pair, stand up to USC and its expected win against a horrible Virginia team, and give Georgia the ranking it deserves.  Hell, just ask Knowshon Moreno.  He likes leaping over people—maybe he should leap over USC too.

 

3. Oklahoma

Good performance all in all against Cincy, but let's get real: Cincinnati's starters are Ohio State's sixth string.  Hell, I even picked OSU over UC—it's just the nature of Ohio.

Now back to Oklahoma.  We finally get to see Ryan Broyles, and what a force this boy turns out to be—breaking records by day, climbing rankings by night.  It's a happy time for the Sooners.

The only negative about the week: They let Cincinnati run back a 97-yard kickoff return.  Now you are saying, "Okay, well that happens quite a bit, and it didn't hurt Florida when Ohio State did it."  Well the reason it's a negative is that the good ol' Bearcats haven't had a kickoff returned for a touchdown in—get this—145 games!

 

4. Florida

(I want to apologize right now for anything said to offend anyone in this whole paragraph.  Being a die-hard Buckeye, the team in orange and blue kinda sits as low as Michigan in the hate factor as of now.)

OK, so I'm downright not impressed.  The Gators played Miami, who they haven't beaten since '85.  Not winning in such and such a time doesn't make the other team good.

1. The win was not spectacular.  Yes, there were some spectacular plays, but not a spectacular game.

2. Florida did not "handle" Miami until the fourth quarter.

3. Ohio State (you know that team that everyone says can't win real games, remember?) beat Miami at its best, in 2002!  Not much to look forward to in Hurricane country since.

4. This "no wins since '85" means nothing to me.  The fact is, in that gap of time they've played six times.  That's like saying Michigan beats Ohio State after six years, and they are suddenly good.  Give me a break.

Given this, I hereby name Miami cupcake game No. 2 for Florida.

Single Page
(0)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

12 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

502
reads

12
comments

written on September 07, 2008 Rankings/List

The best Ohio State newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.