UFC 125: 4 Reasons Why Frank Mir Should Fight Roy Nelson

Will AndersonCorrespondent IOctober 29, 2010

UFC 125: 4 Reasons Why Frank Mir Should Fight Roy Nelson

0 of 5

    NEW YORK - MARCH 24:  Frank Mir of Las Vegas, Nevada speaks at a press conference for UFC 111 at Radio City Music Hall on March 24, 2010 in New York City.  Mir will face Shane Carwin of Denver, Colorado in the INterim heavyweight title bout.  (Photo by Je
    Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images

    Now that Shane Carwin has bowed out of his UFC 125 contest against Ultimate Fighter Season 10 winner Roy Nelson due to a scheduled back surgery, matchmaker Joe Silva is now scrambling to find a replacement. 

    Might I make suitable suggestion in former UFC Heavyweight Champion, Frank Mir? Not sure if this would make sense? Well, let me give you 4 concrete reasons why. 

It Makes Perfect Sense

1 of 5

    UNCASVILLE, CT - MAY 16:  Roy Nelson (White Trunks) of the Lions Den celebrates after beating Brad Imes MilesTech Fighting System during their bout presented by the International Fighting League at the Mohegan Sun Arena May 16, 2008 in Uncasville, Connect
    Al Bello/Getty Images

    Frank Mir is currently one of the only top tier heavyweights that are eligible to get a training camp together in time for the New Years Day match up. 

    With newly crowned champ Cain Velasquez set to take on Junior Dos Santos on a most likely March or April card and Brock Lesnar on a mandatory 180 day medical suspension, Mir would seem like the best choice since he just completed his snooze fest of a fight with Mirko Cro Cop in September. 

A Great Battle: Standing Or On The Ground

2 of 5

    A match up between these two would be pretty entertaining in both areas of the battle.


    From the stand up , both have respectable power and ability. 

    In addition, from the looks of things, Nelson can take a punch. We saw a perfect example of this when Nelson took on Junior Dos Santos at UFC 117 in a 3 round slobber-knocker. 

    However, I can't say the same thing for Frank Mir. In his past bouts with power punchers he tends to buckle and turtle up. 


    Lets say Mir does get trapped on the losing end of a stand up affair; his best bet  would  be to take it to the ground ASAP where he might stand a better chance. Both men have a high level of Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, and have met before at the widely known grappling tournament, Grappler's Quest in 2003. 

    Nelson managed to get the victory over Mir, but as you can see from the video it was a highly competitive match. 

What This Fight Would Mean For Either Fighter : Nelson

3 of 5

    LAS VEGAS - FEBRUARY 29:  Roy Nelson white trunks of Lion's Den celebrates his victory over Fabiano Scherner red trunks of Team Quest during their Heavyweight title bout at The Orleans Arena on February 29, 2008 in Las Vegas, Nevada.  (Photo by Ethan Mill
    Ethan Miller/Getty Images

    For Roy Nelson, this fight would actually have a serious impact over which direction he goes in the UFC Heavyweight ladder. 

    A Loss

    If he losses against Mir, it would put him down with two strikes, and as it usually goes in the UFC - 3 strikes and you're out.

    UFC President, Dana White has already had an issue with Nelson since he competed on season 10 of The Ultimate Fighter due what he felt was a lack of dedication to his conditioning. 

    A loss puts him further away from where he needs to be to get to a title shot. 

    A Win 

    A decisive victory over Frank Mir places Nelson on the following path towards a title shot:

    1 - Brock Lesnar: Which would be a nice match up for Brock to try to get back on the road to a title shot. 

    2- The winner of the Velasquez - Dos Santos fight which most likely will take place some time in the late winter or early spring. 

What This Fight Would Mean For Either Fighter: Mir

4 of 5

    NEWARK, NJ - MARCH 26:  UFC fighter Frank Mir (pictured) weighs in for his fight against UFC fighter Shane Carwin for their Interim Championship Heavyweight fight at UFC 111: St-Pierre vs. Hardy Weigh-In on March 26, 2010 in Newark, New Jersey.  (Photo by
    Jon Kopaloff/Getty Images

    In Frank Mir's case, this fight allows him to continue his quest back to a title shot. However, he would need to be careful here. 

    A Loss

    If he losses against Nelson, he would pretty much be relegated to nothing more than a permanent gatekeeper. 

    While the Las Vegas native would probably never get bounced from the UFC, his plans to get back on top would be highly unlikely. 

    A Win 

    A decisive victory - and I must emphasize the word decisive in Mir's case - would put him on a continuous pace back to a potential title shot.

    Here are the following options where Mir could go in after a win :

    1 - Brock Lesnar: This would be an excellent way to end the triology. If Mir can somehow beat Lesnar, it will finally allow him to conquer the demons he's been facing in his own mind after suffering a vicious loss to the former champ at UFC 100.  

    2- The loser of the Velasquez - Dos Santos fight some time in the late winter or early spring. If he's able to take that opponent down, then he would be in perfect line for a title shot.  

Follow Will Anderson On Twitter

5 of 5

    Will Anderson is growing into a juggernaut on the MMA media scene. While his articles are both thought provoking and entertaining, it's his drive to share his passion of the sport with others by creating a platform for other aspiring writers to display their work. 

    Will is a Featured MMA Columnist on Bleacher Report and The Lead MMA Columnist for Real Sports Net.com; in addition, he has also made guest appearances on The Sprawl N Brawl internet radio show http://www.blogtalkradio.com/sprawlnbrawl ), as well as creating the fast growing facebook group: The MMA Writer's Block. 

    On top of all that, he still finds time to study Brazilian Jiu Jitsu under Eduardo Santos of Lotus Club. 

    To keep up with this rising star, follow him on Twitter: