I'm not going to attempt to select the best under-rated player in the league in this article. Mainly because I think it's an impossible feat and secondly because the minute I list the player he's no longer under-rated. Is he? Take for the example the player pictured in this article. Any mention with Steve Larmer is in regards to his longevity in his playing career with the Blackhawks and later on the New York Rangers. It's sure merited as he played 11 full NHL season without missing a game. However no one ever mentions that he never scored less than 70 points in any one of those 11 seasons. The fact that it's missed almost exclusively causes me to always suggest Larmer as the all-time most under-rated player in the NHL. I bet as soon as you finish reading this paragraph you will have a player in mind that you think is more deserving of the title, maybe Ron Francis or Phil Housley.
Therein lies why I have decided to write this article. As hockey fans we have all read sportspaper pullouts ranking players and teams in all kinds of different categories. Many of the categories require a ton of research and discussion before they can be finalized. The category for most under-rated is one where I think the "experts" get a free ride.
Select any 2nd or 3rd team leading scorer with a decent plus/minus rating that doesn't get injured often. If any of the players ahead of him in team scoring are NHL superstars that makes the nomination for most under-rated player that much easier. Another great thing about making this selection is that most fans won't argue with the selection because it's a player that's under the radar. So fans will simply say "I haven't really noticed him. That makes sense".
Another point where I think we err when labelling a player under-rated is that we do it in the bubble that is our sports world. I may believe Brian Rolston is one of hte most under-rated players in the league, but I can bet you that thought is not shared with Minnesota's fan base (now NJ).
The criteria used to select this player I believe is flawed. Using total points, or goals, plus/minus and durability in my opinion instantly move that player from under-rated to under-achiever. I'll give you an example. For a few years while centering Markus Naslund and Todd Bertuzzi as one of the top lines in the NHL Brendan Morrison was always mentioned in passing and thus given credit for being "maybe the most under-rated player in the league". Well how can the 1st line centre on a team be under-rated? Wouldn't his inferior point totals to other 1st line centres around the league mean he is an inadequate top centremen, especially when you factor in that at the time he was playing with two of the best wingers you could ask for.
In my opinion the most under-rated players should be judged firstly by their teammates if we wanted to truly measure who is the best under-rated player. But seeing as not everyone has access to one-on-one interviews with every player, we the hockey "expert" must make assumptions and deductions using team success, points and other stats to support our argument. There's no way around it. I simply believe to truly select the best under-rated player in the league we should use the most under-rated stats in hockey as well.
5 comments Last one added 10 months ago — Leave a Comment
Andrew Mason 10 months ago
What about Robert Lang? Ok hes not exactly underrated as he will make 4 mill this year but come on this guy has not had a sub 50 point year in ten years and no one says a word about him.
Edit Comment Cancel
Andrew Mason 10 months ago
but very nice article too i enjoyed it 5 stars!
Edit Comment Cancel
Nelson Santos 10 months ago
I'm not sure I would consider Lang under-rated. In his career he has played with some very talented players and good teams.
But again my point was not to pick the most/best under-rated player. It was more about trying to appropriate judge the value of an under-rated player.
A great example is Antoine Vermette of Ottawa. Not sure how much of this guy you have seen, but he is constantly shuffled around the Sens line up and puts out the same performance each night. RJ Umberger was very similar in Philly as well.
Edit Comment Cancel
G P 10 months ago
David Legwand, Dustin Brown and (I know he was an All-Star but only a replacement) probably the most over looked set up man in the league... Marc Savard.
He proved it wasn't just playing on a line with Kovalchuk the last two years in Boston. Especially last year.
Edit Comment Cancel
Nelson Santos 10 months ago
G, Dustin Brown is no under-rated, he is yet to be noticed as he finally had his breakout season last year. You'll be hearing lots about him. Legwand I would argue is OVER-RATED...he has does very little of what Nashville hoped. And Marc Savard YES he is indeed under-rated usually over-looked when experts talks about the offensive stars in the league. Have to agree with you there.
Sami Salo is another players who's skills are overlooked. he is more valuable to Vancouver's line up than most realize. But he is overlooked because he is oft injured as well.
Edit Comment Cancel
Leave a Comment
You must register to post a comment.