The National Football League Hall of Fame; A fraternity reserved for the most idolized, respected, and legendary athletes to play in the National Football League. Names include Johnny Unitas, Jim Otto, Lou Groza, Troy Aikman, Barry Sanders, Dick Butkus, and Reggie White.
The best of the best, all of the inducted players showed exemplary intelligence, skill, and discipline both on and off the field (mostly…<cough>… Michael Irvin…<sniff>).
The 2008 Hall of Fame inductees are DE Fred Dean, CB Darrell Green, WR Art Monk, CB Emmitt Thomas, LB Andre Tippett, and T Gary Zimmerman. As expected, the election committee once again filled the Hall with some of the greatest names to pass through the league.
However, I feel, and not to take away from the illustrious careers of the aforementioned, that one stand out player is being continuously over looked. He is LB Clay Matthews.
Matthews played 19 seasons with the Cleveland Browns and Atlanta Falcons organizations, 16 of which with the prior. Being amongst the leaders of the seasons played category of Cleveland’s history books, he was second to Lou “The Toe” Groza’s 17 seasons with the franchise. Astoundingly, he played two hundred seventy eight games in the NFL ranking him twelfth all-time.
The All-American USC prospect was the first linebacker drafted in 1978 as the No. 12 overall pick. A versatile young OLB, though listed as a ROLB, could play both sides of the field, and he immediately found himself within the defensive rotation. Clay proved that he was prepared for the pro game and was willing to contribute.
In his first four seasons (1978 – 1981) he played in 61 games, starting in over three quarters of them, and in the process put up impressive stats. Over that span, he had 348 tackles, five fumble recoveries, and five interceptions. He also solidified himself as a leader and cornerstone of Cleveland’s defense for seasons to come.
In week one of the 1982 season, Clay went down with a fractured ankle in a 21-7 win in Seattle against the Seahawks, with mere seconds left in the game. He would not play the rest of the season and would be replaced by future Browns' assistant coach and eventual nemesis, Bill Cowher. I believe, with his break-out season coming in 1981, missing this season to injury has negatively affected his HOF status, statistically speaking.
As the seasons progressed, Matthews established himself as a premier linebacker in the NFL. Opposing teams respected his ability to rally teammates, consistent tackling, and his stellar pass rushing. His play would earn him four Pro Bowl appearances in 1985, 1987, 1988, and 1989.
Although statistically these were great seasons, they certainly were not his best. Cleveland’s play overall had improved under coach Marty Schottenheimer and they had made the playoffs in all of those years, thus receiving more attention.
11 comments Last one added 5 months ago — Leave a Comment
joshua chandler 11 months ago
He should already be in the Hall. When he is inducted I will be there to cheer him on. The Matthew brothers were what football players should be, hard working, dedicated and selfless.
Edit Comment Cancel
Josh Prope 11 months ago
excelent article. it is sad that clay matthews hasnt been inducted yet, but there are also many players just like him that deserve that spot in the hall. i guess it is all just a waiting game with the nfl
Edit Comment Cancel
Jeff Saylor 11 months ago
Clay needs to be in the HOF. I think the problem is he wasn't very flashy. He was,and I am sure still is a class act. He impressed me so much as a young father I named my son after him. (My son Clay has just returned from Iraq serving in the Marine Corps) How can we petition the league?
Edit Comment Cancel
Dustin Haley 11 months ago
Semper Fi. As a former Marine, I have the utmost respect for those serving overseas.
I've wondered how to petition the league myself. I suppose this is my way of trying to get the idea out there. I'll look into the HOF and see if there is anything we as fans can do.
Thanks for the read!
Edit Comment Cancel
PG Wolfe 11 months ago
Obviously never playing in the Super Bowl hurt him and so many other Cleveland Browns players being considered for the HOF.
My question is... how do these stats:
1,561 tackles,
16 interceptions,
27 forced fumbles,
14 fumble recoveries, and two defensive touchdowns
...compare to other linebackers already in the HOF?
Edit Comment Cancel
Dustin Haley 11 months ago
Barry Sanders never won a Super Bowl... ok ok, thats a bad comparison, but a Super Bowl win is not a prerequisite to HOF selection.
Lawrence Taylor and Mike Singletary are both HOF LB's from the same era Matthews played in. I'll compare him to LT because they both played the outside. I couldn't find the exact number of tackles LT had that the NFL reconizes, but he did average 5.9 a game (compared to Matthews 5.6). Take that with his 184 games and your in the 1085 area. He had 9 INT's, 2 forced fumbles , and also had 2 defensive TD's. But we all know LT was a great sack artist. He recorded 132.5 official sacks, and that ability is what made him such a great player.
Matthews was a good pass rusher, but he was good in coverage and run defense also. His consistency at such a high level of play for such a long period of time is why I think he should be in the hall.
Edit Comment Cancel
Jeff Smirnoff 11 months ago
Clay definitely should be in but with the backlog of great players still waiting for induction it may be a while. Look at how long it took Art Monk. I think he will get it we just need to be patient.
Great breakdown of his career, my man.
Edit Comment Cancel
David-S Serdinak 9 months ago
Absolutely, Clay belongs in. His stats are deserving on their own merit but he was also a class-act who led by example. It's difficult for anyone who hasn't followed the Browns to appreciate his impact on an excellent team. He'll get there, but not as soon as it should have been.
Edit Comment Cancel
David-S Serdinak 9 months ago
By the way, Dustin, we finally agree! (film at 11:00)
Edit Comment Cancel
Donovon Stiltner 9 months ago
In terms of over all value to a team and the intangables yes Clay is a deserving HOF candidate. Looking at his statistics over a very long career Clay never stood out as a premier linebacker. I have been a life long Brown fan and would not say that he deserves the HOF.
Edit Comment Cancel
Stan Levenstein 5 months ago
Donovan,
Many of the LB's in the Hall were only good at one aspect of the game. Singletary stopping the run, and not very good at covering a back out of the backfield and he is in. Clay Matthews was probably the best all around LB in the NFL. He wasn't flashy but made plays. As a Falcon's fan I had the privledge of watching #57 lead the falcons in sacks at age 40! You don't play in the NFL for 19 years if you are average especially at the LB position. This man should have been in years ago!!!!!!!!
Edit Comment Cancel
Leave a Comment
You must register to post a comment.