What do you do with a near-perfect product? You continue to tweak it, of course. Never one to leave well enough alone, the NCAA has instituted some rule changes for 2008, for which every fan needs to prepare.
1) Game clock goes from 25 seconds to 40 seconds
The rule change that everyone will notice first will be the change in the play clock. Gone is the 25-second play clock, replaced by the 40-second play clock used by the NFL. In the past, the 25-second clock didn’t start until the ball was marked ready for play. Now, as in the NFL, the 40-second clock will commence as soon as the previous play ends.
Why? The stated rationale is that the move will speed up the game. This from the folks who brought us rules changes which led to the disastrous 2006 season, when clock management rules changes designed to shorten games cost teams (and their fans) 25-30 plays per game.
What the rule change really does is take out one more human element from the game, and that is a shame.
Ask almost any long-time fan of college football, and they will quickly recall for you a crucial game when, in the waning seconds, the eyes of thousands of fans were riveted upon the white hat of the referee. Some in the stands were hoping for a slow restart as the game clock continued to tick down, the remainder impatiently demanding that the ball be deemed ready for play.
The outcome of the game could well hinge on the subjective judgment of the referee—a tension that was a part of the beauty of the game.
Can you remember such a game?
For fans of the offensive team trying to run out the clock, it was humorous to watch as players slowly gathered themselves up from the pile, as if the mere act of standing was beyond their capabilities. These players were very much encouraged by the fans in their sloth.
It was almost as if everyone hoping for a slow start of play was channeling Burgess Meredith in Rocky ("Stay down! Stay down!").
Meanwhile, on the other sideline, the frantic fans of the defense were imploring their players to get up and onside so that the referee would deem the ball ready for play, starting the 25-second clock.
Ever see a 180-pound safety rush into the pile at the line of scrimmage to assist an opposing 300-pound offensive lineman to his feet? Only in college football would you see such a sight.
Until 2008.
2) Game clock to restart on ready-for-play after the ball is taken out of bounds
Similar to the "speed up the game" rules change above, there will be a second noticeable change in clock management very early in your first game back at the stadium. For decades, when a player with the ball went out of bounds, the clock stopped, with the clock not starting again until the ball was snapped for the next play.
This too, will change in 2008. Under the new rules, the clock will again stop when the ball is taken out of bounds. However, instead of waiting for the snap, the clock will again begin to run when the ball is marked ready for play. Be the first in your section to point this new rule out during the first quarter of your first game, and you’ll be deemed the guru of the section for the remainder of the season!
12 comments Last one added 11 months ago — Leave a Comment
James Doker 12 months ago
Great article about some unfortunate rules changes. I agree with you on all these, especially 1 and 2. Why couldn't they leave well enough alone?
The worst changes of these rules are the ones that make NCAA football more like the NFL. Next thing you know we'll have the two-feet inbounds and down by contact rules.
Thanks for summarizing the changes.
Edit Comment Cancel
Erwin Wu 12 months ago
Thanks buddy! Good 411. :D
Still can't wait for the first kick off!
Edit Comment Cancel
Justin Goar 12 months ago
These came out so early in the year i'd already forgotten about them. i'm pretty sure i'm gonna hate the 40 second play clock.
Great, I wanted to see more kneeling and less action (and the chance for a comeback) at the end of the game!!!!!
Edit Comment Cancel
Tim Pollock 12 months ago
Good stuff. And don't worry; they'll change all the rules again next year anyway.
I thought the 40 yard line start when a kickoff goes out of bounds went into effect last year.
Edit Comment Cancel
Michael Shibley 12 months ago
I have said this since they were talking about "speeding up" the game. If they want the games to not last so long, just tell CBS and ESPN to not cut to commercial every chance they get.
Of course that would cut down on advertising $$$ so you know that will never happen.
Edit Comment Cancel
Matt Gard 12 months ago
Not liking it, for the most part. I especially am not liking the out-of-bounds restart rule.
Edit Comment Cancel
Justin Hokanson 12 months ago
The 40 second play clock rule also takes away the difference in the time it takes a ref to get the ball, spot it, and start the play clock. Some refs are quicker than others at doing this, and sometimes they will speed up late in the game as opposed to doing it the same way the whole game.
So now, the play ends, and the 40 second clock starts at the end of the play and it's not left up to the ref.
I don't like the rule that the clock starts on ready to play after an out of bounds play. Why do they keep messing with this? What's the point? So stupid.
Edit Comment Cancel
Liger 12 months ago
I don't have a problem with the 40 sec rule...that's actually a good one...but the facemask rule could really cause some serious controversy. They're trying to take the subjectivity out of calls??? This will probably introduce more subjectivity. On the other hand, if the refs are consistent and if the goal is to reduce the number of calls, then it might work out. ...this one makes me a little nervous though.
Edit Comment Cancel
Colin Clark 11 months ago
Pourque?!?
Edit Comment Cancel
James Pena 11 months ago
the facemask rule is probably the worst. i understand its probably for safety reasons but it just adds another possible way that big games could be decided by a factor other than how well a team does in-game
Edit Comment Cancel
J. Michael Morris 11 months ago
I can't understand why anyone would complain that the rule changes make the game LESS subjective. For fairness sake, objectivity of referees should always be the goal.
Edit Comment Cancel
covvb0y 11 months ago
the best rule change would be to change the rules of the BCS. Have A Playoff and quit screwing with the game itself you idiots!!!!!!!!
Edit Comment Cancel
Leave a Comment
You must register to post a comment.