Who Will Bat Lead-off For The 2010 Reds?

Matt David@@mattdavidkyCorrespondent IIMarch 5, 2010

DENVER - SEPTEMBER 07:  Center fielder Drew Stubbs #6 of the Cincinnati Reds takes an at bat against the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field on September 7, 2009 in Denver, Colorado. The Rockies defeated the Reds 4-3.  (Photo by Doug Pensinger/Getty Images)
Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

Point: If history is any guide, Dusty Baker will go with Drew Stubbs as lead-off hitter followed by Orlando Cabrera. This sounds good to me.

Counterpoint: Maybe, but that isn't going to help a run producing lineup. Together, they should punch up an on-base percentage of around .320.

P: I agree that an OBP of .320 isn't good but Stubbs can give the Reds some power at the top of the lineup.

CP: Stubbs was not a power threat in the minor leagues.

P: Yeah, but he was in college and showed big power when he was called up last year.

CP: The other thing he showed was that with the power came a lot of strikeouts.

P: He struck out a lot but he was green. That will surely improve.

CP: Yeah but 49 strikeouts in 180 at bats is a lot.  Reds fans won't like the sound of that.

P: Nobody likes to watch a bunch of strikeouts but I suspect he'll improve.

CP: He seems to have had a nice start but that translates to over 150 strikeouts for a full season.

P: Not exactly what you want in a lead-off hitter.

CP: Isn't putting the guys that are good at getting on base at the top of the order a wise approach?

P: Yes, but last I checked, Pete Rose is gone.

CP: They don't need Rose. They have Chris Dickerson.

P: He seems to be prone to injuries.

CP: Dickerson's injuries weren't his fault. He performed well last year but was never consistently in the lineup.

P: Ok, but where is Dickerson going to play?

CP: He could play center field.

P: Stubbs pretty much has center field to himself. He is not an ideal lead-off man today but he has a higher ceiling than Dickerson. He is an elite fielder that will win gold gloves. Dickerson isn't in the same league as Stubbs defensively.

CP: I think you don't give Dickerson's defense the credit he deserves. He is as fast as Stubbs and is not much different in center field.

P: You are crazy if you think they are equal defensively. Dickerson misplayed a lot of balls last year.

CP: He misplayed a couple.

P: More than a couple and he strikes out just as much as Stubbs. Stubbs and Dickerson have that in common.

CP: Strikeouts aren't that big of a problem for either. The fans don't like it but they are just another out.

P: Let us not go into the strikeout argument.

CP: We don't have to. Dickerson has the .370 OBP that is unmatched on this team by guys not named Joey Votto.

P: I'm expecting Stubbs to improve in all areas. His OBP will not be .323 again.

CP: Perhaps but we know what Dickerson can do. He plays good defense and gets on base. He also bats left handed. The Reds need another lefty bat in the lineup.

P: I don't mind Dickerson in left field so much although typically you want more power from that spot and they have Jonny Gomes now.

CP: The Reds could go with Dickerson in left field and there is your lead-off hitter.

P: I don't mind Dickerson batting lead-off but not at the expense of Stubbs. Stubbs' defense is much better, he's younger, he won't have to be pulled when a lefty is brought in, and is much more durable. Ideally, your center fielder will play every day.

CP: I get it...You and the Reds agree on Stubbs. Dickerson has never gotten a chance, though.

P: For Dickerson to play regularly, he needs to stay healthy and cut down on strikeouts.

CP: I think he will do that.

P: I doubt he gets the chance anyway. Gomes or maybe Wladimir Balentien will get the at-bats in left field which leaves Dickerson on the bench.

CP: They may platoon him in left field or center field.

P: They might do that. Dickerson will get plenty of at-bats filling in for Gomes and Stubbs here and there. When he does, I suspect he won't be at the top of the order but you never know.

CP: Dickerson will be starting in center field if the AAA version of Stubbs shows up. It wouldn't shock anyone if Stubbs has trouble.

P: That won't happen. Stubbs is the real deal.

CP: Dusty Baker places no value in a high OBP. That is Dickerson's main asset so he will continue to be undervalued and frustrated.

P: He has that but he does not hit the ball with authority. For all of his strikeouts, you would think he could mix in some doubles and home runs.

CP: Dickerson may have seen his chance pass by when the Reds foolishly signed Willy Taveras last year.

P: This could be true.

Please go here for more.


    Kris Bryant Held Out of Cubs Lineup

    MLB logo

    Kris Bryant Held Out of Cubs Lineup

    Craig Calcaterra
    via HardballTalk

    Kershaw on 300 Wins: 'Don't See That Happening'

    MLB logo

    Kershaw on 300 Wins: 'Don't See That Happening'

    via Yahoo

    Biggest MLB Surprises and Disappointments in April

    MLB logo

    Biggest MLB Surprises and Disappointments in April

    Zachary D. Rymer
    via Bleacher Report

    Giants Should Consider a Bumgarner Blockbuster

    MLB logo

    Giants Should Consider a Bumgarner Blockbuster

    Buster Olney
    via ESPN.com