Money Ball? They're Not Gonna Take It!

Jon PoirierContributor IJuly 6, 2008

Red Sox, Yankees, Mets… Good teams with a lot of talent.  The salary almost undoubtedly will also cross your mind, as over the past half-decade or so, these teams have had a whatever it takes finacial mentality.  As it stands, there are ten teams in Major League Baseball who each will be paying their players a grand total of $100 million or more and one, the most well known spenders of all, the New York Yankees, who broke the $200 million mark.  The list of these teams is as follows:


New York Yankees

New York Mets

Detroit Tigers

Boston Red Sox

Chicago White Sox

Los Angeles Angels

Los Angeles Dodgers                                          

Chicago Cubs                                         

Seattle Mariners

Atlanta Braves


Am I the only one that winces a little bit when I see some of the teams that are on this list?  Five of these teams don't have winning records and only three of them, the Angels, Cubs, and White Sox, lead their respective divisions.  The White Sox, hold only a half game lead over the surging Minnesota Twins, who have won 19 of their past 24 games, despite paying 64 million dollars less than Chicago.  Baseball is shedding its former skin as a league where rich, big market teams would flex their muscle in the free agent market each off season and grab up all the big name players and dominate the season for it.  It just doesn't always work out.


After he won a ring in 2004, the Mets signed pitcher, Pedro Martinez, who had been plagued by shoulder injuries over the last few years of his career, to a four year $53 million contract before the 2005 season.  So what did the Mets received for this investment?  The answer is one good season and three poor ones.  He has only made 66 starts in those four injury-plagued seasons.  Throwing around money foolishly has never worked, and very rarely does an organization throw together a championship team all in one off-season, although many keep trying and failing miserably. 


If you want another example, you might ask Todd Helton about all the wasted years in Colorado, while they paid out the lengthy contracts to injured players such as Denny Neagle, who received $31.5 million between 2004 and 2006, despite not playing a single game.


Today's game is beginning to be governed by a system of brains over financial brawn and the teams that haven't adjusted yet are being left behind, some far worse than others.  A prime example of a team left behind is the Seattle Mariners, paying 117 million dollars this season to its players despite being 17.5 games out of first in American League West, only in early July. 


Another team not getting their money's worth:  the 2008 Detroit Tigers.  A team with so much hype during the off-season, you could taste the championship in February.  A few games before the All Star break, they are just trying to be over .500 halfway through the year.  The daunting offense that they were supposed to possess, having signed heavy hitting third baseman, Miguel Cabrera, and solid hitting shortstop, Edgar Renteria before the season, has in fact showed itself to be merely okay.  Meanwhile, the pitching staff should have been bolstered by the arrival of Dontrelle Willis, a star in Miami.  The Tigers already possessed several superstars in the rotation and bullpen, yet have faltered so far this season, posting a 4.49 ERA, good enough for seventh worst in the Majors.  As for Willis, he's in Triple A, working out some control issues, after pitching horribly to open the season with 21 walks to 5 strikeouts in 11.1 innings, while posting an ERA greater than 10.


But it's not just the failure of the high paying teams that inspires me.  It's the success of the smaller market teams.  No team is a better example this season than the Tampa Bay Rays.  Playing in a stacked division that hosts the Yankees and Red Sox, they have never won the division since they were instated in 1998.  They have never so much as had a winning record.  But all those seasons they were building a franchise to endure.  This team has taken a commanding 4.5 game lead in the American League East over the defending World Champion Red Sox.  They, however, have a payroll that ranks second lowest and roughly $90 million less than Boston.  They have proven with solid play on both sides of the ball that they are no fluke and that they are sticking around, at least for a while.  And the key to their success has been waiting for young players to mature and bond into a solid team with great chemistry.


Over the past few years another good example is the other Florida team, the Marlins.  This team has endured losing great players every off-season, unable or unwilling to sign them at the money amounts that compete with teams like Boston, New York and Detroit, to name a few.  However, every season they hang in for most of the season giving big money teams like the Mets and the Braves a run for their (excuse the pun) money.  They do it every year with a low payroll.  This year they have the lowest at $21 million, nearly half of the second least, the Rays.  As of tonight they stand 3 games out of first in their division.


The key is this:  today's baseball is more than ever about development of the farm system and about wisely spending money.  Having money doesn't hurt, but it doesn't help either if it's spent unwisely just to make a splash.  Good managers and even better general managers are more a commodity now than ever.  I think I speak for baseball fans everywhere when I say it's refreshing.