Point: Yes, Jack Nicklaus has more major championships than Tiger Woods simply because he played longer.
Counterpoint: I say no. Nicklaus played against Hall Of Fame golfers like Gary Player, Tom Watson, and Arnold Palmer. Who can top that today?
P: I hear that all the time. Had Woods not so thoroughly dominated, guys like Vijay Singh, Phil Mickelson, and Ernie Els would have equaled the guys you named.
CP: You aren't seriously arguing that you would take your foursome over mine?
P: All day. Also, tournaments today have much deeper fields to beat.
CP: I'm not sure the 50th best golfer of either generation makes a difference.
P: Of course they do.
CP: I agree that the worst players of Woods' era are better than the worst players of Nicklaus' era. However, the ones that matter are at the top and there is no comparison. Just look at the number of majors won by my foursome compared to yours. It isn't close.
P: Well, the courses are tougher today.
CP: All golfers play on the same course.
P: Yes, but it is much harder to maintain consistency on more difficult courses.
Click here to read the rest of this argument.
Like the new article format? Send us feedback!