Orlando Hudson: Would He Really Improve Washington Nationals' Middle Infield?

Dave NicholsSenior Analyst IFebruary 2, 2010

LOS ANGELES, CA - OCTOBER 04:  Orlando Hudson #13 of the Los Angeles Dodgers throws out a runner against the Colorado Rockies on October 4, 2009 at Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles, California.  The Dodgers won 5-3.  (Photo by Stephen Dunn/Getty Images)
Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

Orlando Hudson is a four-time Gold Glove winner, including last season, when, during the stretch drive, he was usurped at Dodgers's second base by ex-Nat Ronnie Belliard. 

While I'm not going to debate Joe Torre's decision-making there, I would like to offer some points to consider for everyone clamoring for Mike Rizzo to sign Orlando Hudson to play second base for the Nationals next season, with the idea of improving the middle infield defense.
For the purposes of this debate, I'm leaving the offense out of the equation because the stated goal here, remember, is to upgrade the middle infield defense.
Hudson's UZR/150 last season was -3.7 which placed him 13th among 20 qualifiers in the majors.
UZR is the number of runs above or below average a fielder is in both range runs, outfield arm runs, double play runs, and error runs combined.  UZR/150 is the number of runs above or below average a fielder is, per 150 defensive games.
However, UZR does not measure an infielder's arm, nor does it value an infielder's ability to catch fly balls or line drives—it only measures a player's proficiency at turning ground balls into outs, so it's not a perfect gauge.
Now as we read above, the components for infielders UZR are: range, double plays, and errors.
Hudson was recorded with only eight errors last season, which put him in the top third of second basemen. His range factor was 4.7, which put him in the middle of the pack.  Where Hudson's UZR number took a real hit was in double plays. He participated in 68 DPs, which was 17th out of 20 qualifiers.
Here's another strange thing regarding Hudson's defensive season last year. He was second among qualifiers at putouts:
Chase Utley, PHI—354
Orlando Hudson, LAD—325
Robinson Cano, NYY—308
But Hudson was only 14th in assists.  It's difficult to reconcile the fact that his range was average, but his assists total was in the lower third. He's just not making all the plays he used to be able to, relative to everyone else playing second base in the majors last season.
Judging by the UZR/150 number, it's easy to say "Hudson's slipping as a fielder." And he probably is. He is 32, after all.
To put it another way so that it's relative to Nationals fans, Hudson's UZR/150 was -3.7 last season. Cristian Guzman's UZR/150 at short was -2.6. So, relative to position and competition last season, statistically Guzman was a marginally better shortstop than Hudson was a second baseman.
Back to Ronnie Belliard for a moment. His UZR/150 was a robust 6.6, meaning he was a better than average defensive second baseman last season, compared to -3.7 below average for Hudson.
Maybe Joe Torre knew what he was doing.
For what it's worth, Adam Kennedy, another name that's been kicked around, was -14.8 last season.
Consider all this as you contemplate upgrading the middle infield defense.
Rizzo likes to say that he uses statistics to back up what his eyes see. In his pursuit of Hudson, at least as a defensive upgrade, he must be trusting his eyes.