Houston Astros: A Modest Proposal

Onan CocaContributor IDecember 2, 2009

CHICAGO - MAY 16: Starting pitcher Roy Oswalt #44 of the Houston Astros delivers the ball against the Chicago Cubs on May 16, 2009 at Wrigley Field in Chicago, Illinois. The Cubs defeated the Astros 5-4.  (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

Recently, I took Richard Justice of the Houston Chronicle up on his offer to "fix the Astros", and what came out of my research and conclusion was that the Astros could feasibly win in 2010 .

I stand by my attempt to make them competitors in the 2010 season, as I believe the team has a solid core and enough money to surround that core with players who can help them win. 

I did, however, have a thought that kept gnawing at the back of my mind; "This will fix them for 2010, but what happens in 2012?" 

With that thought in mind I set about trying not to fix the Astros for 2010, but deciding to rebuild the Astros into a contender for the next decade.

The Astros start with a leg up on about half the league, namely, they can afford $100M plus payroll .  With an eye to the future, we'll save owner Drayton McLane millions in 2010, but fret not, Astros fans, the savings will reap rewards within two seasons. 

How can we build a winner for the future?  It means making cuts (and cuts always hurt), and trading our chips (even the blue chips).

Looking at the Astros' 2010 roster, they have a couple of chips that can be moved for long-term help; Lance Berkman, Carlos Lee, and Roy Oswalt. 

I am loathe to trade Berkman, and I don't think the Houston fanbase would abide a move like that, so let's just say that Berkman stays. 

That leaves Lee and Oswalt, and before we decide what to do with these two, let's consider what their names would mean to the 2009-2010 winter market. 

Lee would become one of the top three offensive players on the market, probably behind Matt Holliday but at least a wash with Jason Bay.  Oswalt would also become one of the top three pitchers on the market, behind John Lackey and Roy Halladay. 

Not only would these two players revolutionize the winter market, but by trading them away the Astros would cut a full third of their $100M payroll from 2009. 

Oswalt is due $15M in 2010 ($16M in '11) and Lee is due $19M per year through 2012.  It just so happens that there are multiple teams looking for a frontline SP and a power hitting LF this winter, let's talk about some of our options.

A few scenarios that could happen to move Carlos Lee:

1. Lee and $9M (over three years) to the Giants for prospects Nick Noonan (2B), Kevin Pucetas (RHP), and Roger Kieschnick (RF). 

2. Lee and $9M (over three years) to the Yankees for Phil Hughes (RHP) and Melky Cabrera (LF/CF). 

3. Lee and $9M (over three years) to the Red Sox for Daniel Bard (RP/CL) and Lars Anderson (1B/OF).

The Mets, Braves, Angels, Rangers, and Cardinals are all in the market for a power hitting OF and I am sure that the Astros could find some nice prospects to ask for from each team.

A few scenarios that could happen to move Roy Oswalt:

1. Oswalt to the Mets for Fernando Martinez (OF) and Eddie Kunz (RHP). 

2. Oswalt to the Red Sox for Michael Bowden (RHP) and Lars Anderson (1B). 

3. Oswalt to the Yankees for Zach McAllister (RHP) and Brett Gardner (OF).

4. Oswalt to the Dodgers for Josh Lindblom (RHP) and Chris Withrow (RHP). 

The Angels, Phillies, St. Louis, and Milwaukee are all in the market for a SP and again, I am sure that the Astros could find some solid pieces to meet their needs.

If the Astros find a way to move Oswalt and Lee for value, their Opening Day roster would look something like this:

Lineup :  CF: Michael Bourn  2B: Kaz Matsui (who is untradeable)  1B: Lance Berkman  RF: Hunter Pence  LF: Brian Bogusevic  3B: Chris Johnson  C: Jason Castro/JR Towles  SS: Tommy Manzella

Rotation :  SP: Wandy Rodriguez  SP: Brian Moehler  SP: Felipe Paulino  SP: Tim Byrdak  SP: Bud Norris

Bullpen :  RP: Jeff Fulchino  RP: Alberto Arias  RP: Chris Sampson  RP: Wesley Wright  RP: Tyler Lumsden  RP: Sam Gervacio  RP: ?                                                                                                       

Bench :  IF: Geoff Blum  IF: Jeff Keppinger  OF: ?  C: Humberto Quintero

I know what you are going to say - "This roster is not strong" - and you would be right.  Don't forget we are inserting some of those players we traded for, and our payroll is now about $43.5M. 

We have two spots open (RP and Bench OF), if the team doesn't feel comfortable filling these slots with the pieces acquired in trading Oswalt and Lee it would be a simple task to sign a Free Agent OF, and I would suggest signing a starting pitcher and moving Brian Moehler into the bullpen.

I like Endy Chavez (OF), and Todd Wellemeyer (SP) for the way we are building this team, I think that these two players would cost the Astros about $5M in salary next year, which would put the Astros at a payroll just under $50M (which is roughly half of what it was in 2009 ).

While this team may not be a winner in 2010, it will help make the Astros competitive over the next few years, it will save Drayton McLane money and it will add some valuable prospects to the Astros farm system. 

Brian Bogusevic, Chris Johnson, Tommy Manzella, Jason Castro, Bud Norris, and Felipe Paulino are all big parts of the Astros future and the playing time they would get in 2010 would be invaluable to their development. 

I think the Astros have some great pieces for the future and the time to move in that direction may just be the 2010 season...no one likes to rebuild but what if it assured that your team would be competitive for the next decade?


    Yankees Bats Silenced in 2-0 Loss to Astros

    Houston Astros logo
    Houston Astros

    Yankees Bats Silenced in 2-0 Loss to Astros

    via SNY

    Lance McCullers Shines on Hometown Mound

    Houston Astros logo
    Houston Astros

    Lance McCullers Shines on Hometown Mound

    Houston Chronicle
    via Houston Chronicle

    Report: Astros, Altuve Agree to $151M Extension

    MLB logo

    Report: Astros, Altuve Agree to $151M Extension

    Scott Polacek
    via Bleacher Report

    Impact Trade Astros Should Be Thinking About

    Houston Astros logo
    Houston Astros

    Impact Trade Astros Should Be Thinking About

    Jacob Shafer
    via Bleacher Report