Manny Pacquiao: The Truth Behind The Criticisms!!

Oliver SuarezContributor IIDecember 1, 2009

LAS VEGAS - NOVEMBER 14:  Manny Pacquiao celebrates his 12 round TKO victory against Miguel Cotto during their WBO welterweight title fight at the MGM Grand Garden Arena on November 14, 2009 in Las Vegas, Nevada.  (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)
Ethan Miller/Getty Images

Despite not having Mayweather’s pedigree and proper resources at his disposal at the beginning of his career, Pacquiao has become arguably the best boxer of our generation.  But, a number of boxing fans and so called boxing “experts” continue to deny him all the credit that he deserves.

His total body of work is second to none when compared to other great boxers of our time.  He’s only one of a handful of fighters in history that has surpassed his potential and expectations.  This rare accomplishment alone should be appreciated by boxing fans and analysts.

Still, his wins and accomplishments are too often downgraded and attributed to his opponents’ shortcomings instead of his ability to find a way to win.  Many of his critics ignored his win versus Oscar De La Hoya because the Golden Boy was supposedly past his prime and weight drained. Yet the very same critics were aware of those circumstances beforehand and still picked against Pacquiao because of their doubt in his talent and boxing ability. 

But to the surprise of his doubters, Pacquiao not only beat Oscar but did it in a dominating fashion.  Then he followed that up with a performance for the ages against Hatton.  Once again, more attention was given to the assumption that Hatton was washed up and no longer an elite fighter.  The fact is that no one had beaten Hatton at 140 pounds and was still in his prime the night of the time.

Pacquiao’s record in the lower weight classes had also been put into question.  Some accuse him of ducking Tim Austin and Rafael Marquez by skipping the Bantamweight Division.  Pacquiao would have fought those fighters in a heart beat if given the chance.  What some boxing fans fail to realize is that Filipino fighters, despite their talent and accomplishments, have had a difficult time obtaining a fight in the U.S. 

Many promoters did not feel that there was a market for Phillipino boxers.  The only visible Filipino fighter in the U.S during the 90's was Luisito Espinosa.  Pacquiao was a champion at flyweight and had a solid record, yet only Freddie Roach and Murach Muhammad were willing to take a chance on him. 

Nonito Donaire validated this issue in an interview at Eastside Boxing when he said " Early in my career I could not get a fight, I was the one that was chosen on two days notice. I never had the choice to make things happen. When I tried to sign with managers in the past I was told that Filipinos were not marketable. I was told that Filipino fighters couldn’t break an egg…but Manny has helped change all of that and we are thankful for everything he has done for the Filipino boxing world."

There is no doubt Pacquiao would have accepted a fight with either Austin or Marquez since a fight with either fighter would have given him his highest payday and the recognition that he had been seeking.  The same reason that he took a fight with a respectable champion in Lehlohonolo Ledwaba on two weeks’ notice.

Another criticism that has been thrown at Pacquiao is the issue of catchweights.  But many fighters including Leonard, Chavez, Hearns, and Hopkins have all had catchweight fights.  Yet, no one has taken more heat than the current Pound for Pound King.  He’s only had one catchweight fight, which was against Miguel Cotto, who is one of the better welterweights around and it was at a fair weight of 145.  Sure, he could have stayed at 140 and cleaned out the division, but he chose to take on a greater challenge as he always does.

His thirst for the best of challenges is the main reason that he’s now considered by most as the best Pound for Pound fighter today.  The impressive win against Cotto further enhanced his legacy and no matter what happens from now on—his place among the greats will remain secured.  Even his most ardent critics are finding it more difficult not to give him the respect that he deserves.

But why did it take so long for fans and analysts to fully appreciate Pacquiao?  It’s because it’s something different and unexpected.  Who would have thought that a Filipino would be considered not only the best boxer, but arguably the most bankable superstar in a sport usually dominated by Americans and Latinos? 

Remember when the U.S. basketball team started to lose in the Olympics?  We had a difficult time accepting that other nations were catching up with us in terms of basketball skills.  Just imagine if the Americans started dominating the sport of soccer.  Soccer fans from Latin and European nations no doubt would find excuses to downplay the accomplishment of the U.S soccer team.

It’s just human nature to find it difficult to accept something different. Some have even brought up the issue that Pacquiao supposedly has not face any black fighters.  But when confronted with the facts that he fought Agapito Sanchez and Ledwaba; those critics modified their criticism to how Pacquiao has not fought any African Americans.  The fact is when Pacquiao was at the lower weight classes he fought the best and the top fighters just happened to be Asians and Latinos. 

It’s also a generational issue; some people just cannot accept the fact that an athlete from today has reached the same level as their sport heroes from the past.  It’s impossible to compare fighters from different eras because there is no way to prove who was better.  It’s also been proven in history that just as records are made to be broken, another athlete is bound to arise to set new standard in his/her respective sport.  We saw this with Tiger Woods in golf and Michael Jordan in basketball.

It’s time to appreciate Manny Pacquiao as he personifies our ideal athlete; one with an undying desire to continually improve and provide the best performance to the fans.   He’s earned every bit of the success and accolades that he has garnered.  For a non-American who barely spoke English to become one of the most popular athletes in the world only shows the significance of his accomplishments. 

However, it should be noted that Pacquiao’s success is not only attributed to his work ethic but by the choices he’s made.  While others chose the path of money, Pacquiao chose the path to greatness.  He may not be the most technically skilled fighter, but the most gifted and talented don’t always become the best.  It’s about maximizing your potential and meeting all the expectations that you set for yourself.  Manny Pacquiao has achieved that and it’s the reason that he’s secured in his legacy and is in a “win-win” situation no matter what he does from here on out.

This article is also featured in SportzHype Boxing

My Recent Bleacher Report articles:

Manny Pacquiao: The Catchweight King?

Don't Underestimate Pacquiao's Ring IQ

Shane Mosley Vs Pacquiao: The Most Exciting Fight In Boxing

Manny Pacquiao Warns Floyd Mayweather Sr.