2010 Canadian Olympic Hockey Team: Who Shouldn't Make the Cut

Mike TaylorContributor INovember 24, 2009

TORONTO - SEPTEMBER 14:  Shane Doan #9 and Martin Brodeur #30 of Team Canada stand for the National Anthem before the 2004 World Cup of Hockey Championship game against Finland on September 14, 2004 at the Air Canada Centre in Toronto, Canada.  Canada defeated Finland 3-2.  (Photo By Dave Sandford/Getty Images)
Dave Sandford/Getty Images

If you’re a hockey fan, you’ve probably read a story or two about the upcoming Olympic Games and the NHL players expected to compete for their respective countries. 

If you’re a Canadian hockey fan, you’ve probably read ten times that amount.


Over the last year, countless stories have been written about who should lace ‘em up for Canada at the 2010 Winter Games in Vancouver this coming February.  


Instead of rehashing this same discussion, I’m going to go in another direction and highlight a few of the potential Team Canada candidates (outside of the obvious players who have sustained noteworthy injuries early on in the season) who I think shouldn’t make the team and why they should be left off the roster.


So hold onto your helmets sports fans…here we go!


Martin Brodeur (New Jersey Devils)—I know what you’re saying to yourself “Is this guy crazy?" Well, I certainly have my fair share of idiosyncrasies, but this choice is based solely on logic. 

Although Brodeur is the NHL's all-time leader in regular season wins, he’s also 37 and a half years old and missed the majority of last years season with an elbow injury.  And while he’s bounced back this year, I honestly think Team Canada needs to go in another direction and give the next generation of masked men their shot at bringing home the gold. 

Guys like Fleury, Luongo, and Price all have the pedigree to be named to the team and should be given a shot.

Mike Green (Washington Capitals)—He’s exciting, talented, and a top-notch blueliner, but he’s also in the crosshairs of players who I think Team Canada Executive Director Steve Yzerman should pass over. 


While Green would certainly bring a high-degree of offense to the team, guys like Bouwmeester, Boyle and Weber bring a similar skill set and in my opinion aren’t as much of liability on the back-end.  What’s more, I’m not a fan of Green’s nonchalant attitude and casual approach to the game. To play for Team Canada, you have to have passion and bleed Red and White, something I have yet to see from Green in his brief NHL career.


People might not like Crosby (I’m not one of them by the way), but even his detractors have to admit the guy is driven and oozes passion. Players with this type of drive are the ones who are going to be the difference makers for Canada when the score is tied and the game is on the line. For these reasons, I think selecting Green would be a mistake.


Shane Doan (Phoenix Coyotes)—Rounding out the list is the hard-nosed and very likeable Doan, who has enjoyed some success on the international and World Cup stages.

Often heralded as the textbook “team guy," the two-way winger should be a walk on given his past Team Canada achievements and consistent performance with the NHL’s desert dogs, right?  Not so fast.  Remember, Doan was a member of the country’s 2006 Winter Olympic team that finished a distant seventh in Turin. If he’s such a regarded leader, why wasn’t he able to help pull that team together and make them a more successful unit?

Also, this year’s squad should be full of leaders (Crosby, Iginla, Niedermayer, Pronger, etc.), so I don’t see this as a quality that really sets him apart. 

Lastly, is Doan really as good as some people say he his?  He may stand out on the lowly Coyotes, where he has spent his entire NHL career, but how would he perform on a contender like the Sharks or Penguins.  Would he blend into the background?  Who knows.  But for me, this guy lacks the star power and numbers to be named to the 2010 Canadian squad.

So, love ‘em or hate ‘em, these are my picks of the players who I think should be watching the 2010 Games at home just like the rest of us. 

You may or may not agree, but let the debate begin!