IDP Wednesday: Week 12

Justin CurryContributor INovember 24, 2009

HOUSTON - OCTOBER 04:  Linebacker Brian Cushing #56 of the Houston Texans delivers a hard hit to tight-end Zach Miller #80 of the Oakland Raiders at Reliant Stadium on October 4, 2009 in Houston, Texas.  (Photo by Bob Levey/Getty Images)
Bob Levey/Getty Images

By: Justin Curry (11/25/2009)

***Quick Note Before We Begin - This week, the Fantasy Football Librarian is having her First Annual FFLibrarian Readers' Choice poll.  One of the questions asks what your favorite IDP resource is.  If you like my articles each week, I would appreciate it immensely if you would take the poll and vote for my site - Numbers and Guts.  I'm going up against some real big dogs in the industry, so I need all the help I can get.  The poll is really quick as it only takes about two minutes to complete.  Any help is truly appreciated.  The poll can be taken by clicking here

So, with that being said, lets get back to some IDP!!!

IDP Wednesday is dedicated to the stepchildren of the Fantasy Football world - The Individual Defensive Players. It's broken up into the following six parts:

1. Bye-Week Fillers - This section is dedicated to the players who may not be great, but should have a solid, if not spectacular week because of the situation they're in this week.
2. Go and Get 'Em - This section is dedicated to players you should think about for the rest of the way.
3. The Favorable & Formidable Fives - This section lists the five best and worst teams allowing points to the DL, LB and DB positions this year.
4. IDP Opportunity - The average NFL game has 126 plays (average for one team is 63 offensive plays and 63 defensive plays). This section illustrates the top and bottom five teams that are above and below that average for both offense and defense showing you which IDP players are getting more opportunities to pad their stats.
5. Playoff Considerations - This section is devoted to what you need to be thinking about with the playoffs coming up.
6. IDP Injury Considerations - This section is devoted to who's out and who you should get as a replacement.

Hope you enjoy and please keep in mind that for the purposes of this article, I am excluding the top 20 linebackers, top 15 defensive backs and top 10 defensive linemen as I'm assuming that they are already on someone's team.

Bye-Week Fillers (Good for This Week)

Thus far this year, if you take out the bye-week recommendations that were benched after my original Wednesday posting (3 players) and players that were injured in the first half and didn't return (2 players), here are my averages for each position so far:

Using My Preferred IDP Scoring System


Avg. Return for Bye-Week Filler Positions I've Recommended

PositionPoint Total That Week

Week 10 Recommendations


1. Cliff Avril (Detroit Lions - DE) - The last time Avril played Green Bay, he put up his best numbers of the year with six solo tackles, one assist, and one sack. Though he's been relatively quiet lately, I think he gets a little kick this week and becomes productive again.

2. Shaun Ellis (New York Jets - DE) - Carolina comes to town and they love helping DEs pad stats. Since Ellis is the best on the Jets at that position in my opinion, I believe he will be the primary beneficiary this week.


1. Jerod Mayo (New England Patriots - ILB) - Through 11 weeks, there is no better team for an ILB to play than the New Orleans Saints. Mayo should turn an alright season into a very nice day this week and it should be close to this year's best for him.

2. Andra Davis (Denver Broncos - ILB) - The New York Giants are second to only the Saints in awarding ILBs points this year. Over the last two games, Davis has been productive and should continue this trend.

3. DeMeco Ryans (Houston Texans - MLB) - If you have Ryans on your team and are afraid to use him because of his up and down season, thus far, this is the week you must put him in. The Colts have been good to him over his career and this week should be no different.


1. Bryan Scott (Buffalo Bills - DB/LB) - The match-up is only alright this week, but you have to ride this wave until it stops. If you have him, he's a must play every week until he proves otherwise.

2. Darcel McBath (Denver Broncos - FS) - With Brian Dawkins out because of injury this week and the pass-happy New York Giants coming to town, the stage is set for McBath to have one of those monster games that "comes out of nowhere."

3. Nick Harper (Tennessee Titans - CB) - Harper seems to have his best statistical games when he plays a team with a big name receiver. In comes Arizona who has two of them. I expect very solid numbers from Harper this week.

Go and Get 'Em (Worth Considering Over the Long Term)


Previous Recommendations I Still Like:

John Abraham/Chris Kelsay Best Match-Up, Andre Carter, Elvis Dumervil, James Hall, Anthony Hargrove, Robaire Smith, Jason Taylor, "Stylez G" White, Jimmy Wilkerson

This Week:

1. David Bowens (Cleveland Browns - LB/DE) - If Bowens is eligible to be a DL in your league, you need to jump on this one right now. Over the last two weeks, Bowens is averaging six solo tackles, two assists, two sacks and has a forced fumble. Couple that with a very good fantasy playoff schedule and he could be very good the rest of the way for you.


Previous Recommendations I Still Like:

Nick Barnett, David Bowens, Keith Brooking, Keith Bulluck, Channing Crowder, Brian Cushing, Andra Davis, Justin Durant, Larry Foote, David Hawthorne, LeRoy Hill, Hunter Hillenmeyer, Thomas Howard, Kaluka Maiava, Calvin Pace, Mike Peterson, Paul Posluszney, Stephen Tulloch, Will Witherspoon

This Week:

1. Michael Boley (New York Giants - OLB) - Though the remainder of his schedule this year is rather tough, you still need to consider picking him up for the rest of the way. Over the last two games, he's averaging nine solo tackles, one assist, has one sack, and has one pass deflection. To make things even better, Antonio Pierce looks like he's going to be out for awhile, so he has no one to really compete with him for tackles.

2. Kevin Burnett (San Diego Chargers - ILB) - Since returning from injury, Burnett has averaged seven solo tackles, two assists, one sack, and has one pass deflection. If you're hurting and LB, you might want to ride this until it slows down.

3. Channing Crowder (Miami Dolphins - ILB) - Over the past two weeks, Crowder is averaging seven solo tackles and has one sack. Though this week should be another slow for him, weeks 13 - 16 should be very good with him playing New England, Jacksonville, Tennessee and Houston.


Previous Recommendations I Still Like:

Jordan Babineaux, Atari Bigby, Tyvon Branch, Mike Brown, Melvin Bullitt, Erik Coleman, Thomas DeCoud, Louis Delmas, Reed Doughty, Abram Elam, Deshon Goldson, Chris Harris, LaRon Landry, Michael Lewis, Brandon McGowan, Chinedum Ndukwe, Bernard Pollard, Gerald Sensabaugh, Donte Whitner/George Wilson, Antoine Winfield

This Week:

1. Bryan Scott (Buffalo Bills - DB/LB) - Couple his DB eligibility with Keith Ellison being put on I.R. late last week and Scott or Poz should finish off the year in very productive fashion. Over the last two games that he's been moved to WLB, he is averaging nine solo tackles, one assist, has one sack, one forced fumble, and one pass deflection. If he's available, get him immediately

2. Nick Harper (Tennessee Titans - CB) - Back from injury last week, Harper continued the very productive pace he was on before his injury with six solo tackles, one assist and one pass deflection. If you take out the games he's missed this year, Harper is averaging six solo tackles, two assists and about one pass deflection a game this year.

3. Antoine Winfield (Minnesota Vikings - CB) - Last chance to jump on-board this train before it leaves the station. It looks like this is the week he comes back into the lineup. Winfield is a Top 10 DB when healthy.

Favorable & Formidable Fives

As one looks at the Favorable portion below, you will notice that you want your DL players to play Green Bay and your LB and DB players to play New Orleans.

As for the Formidable portion, DLs haven't been successful against Dallas' o-line, linebackers aren't productive against Philadelphia and you already knew to stay away from Oakland with your DBs.

Favorable (Ordered w/ Best Team to Play First & Weekly Opponent)


Formidable (Ordered w/ Worst Team to Play First & Weekly Opponent)


IDP Opportunity

As mentioned at the beginning of this post, these four charts are to illustrate which players are actually getting more opportunities to fill up their stat sheet just because they are on a certain team.

Offensively, what can be gained from these first two charts along with the 'Favorable & Formidable Fives' section is that you want your safeties and linebackers to go up against New England and New Orleans. If you have a DB going up against Oakland, bench him.

As far as the defensive play portion (bottom two charts), I've added a new column that shows you over the course of the year what these averages translate to. For example, the average total of defensive plays per team is 628. As you can see from the two defensive charts below, right now, Buffalo is 67 more plays ahead of that average, meaning they have had 67 more plays this year on defense than the average team in the NFL to make tackles, etc. Conversely, the New York Giants are 68 plays below the average in the NFL for total number of defensive plays, meaning they have had 68 fewer opportunities to make tackles, etc. Through ten games for every NFL team, the difference between the total number of defensive plays for Buffalo and the total number of defensive plays for the New York Giants is 135 total defensive plays. This total is equivalent to more than two extra games for the average NFL defensive player.

Most Amount of Offensive Plays per Game Avg. (League Avg. is 62.8)

New England70.240.428.4
New York Giants66.633.831.2
Green Bay

Least Amount of Offensive Plays per Game Avg. (League Avg. is 62.8)

San Francisco56.331.122.1
Tampa Bay
San Diego59.432.125.3

Most Amount of Defensive Plays per Game Avg. (League Avg. is 62.8, Average Total Defensive Plays for the Season is 627.78)

TeamPlaysTotal Above AveragePassRush
San Francisco
Kansas City

Least Amount of Defensive Plays per Game Avg. (League Avg. is 62.8, Average Total Defensive Plays for the Season is 627.78)

TeamPlaysTotal Below AveragePassRush
New York Giants56.0-6829.724.1
Green Bay
New England58.0-4831.624.6

Playoff Considerations

If you're at a point where you're wondering what the SoS (Strength of Schedule) is like for the IDPers on your squad, take a look at this great recommendation from the Fantasy Football Librarian :'s SoS Application

Not quite sure the methodology behind it and would like to see it broken out into DE, ILB, OLB, SS, FS & CB, but I have a feeling those will be coming in the future. With that said, seriously, is there a better SoS fantasy football tool on the web?! If there is, I haven't found it yet.

After doing my own analysis for weeks 14 through 16, weighing week 14 slightly more than 15, and week 15 slightly more than 16, here is my SoS for the fantasy playoffs this year:

Most Favorable SoS (Weeks 14 - 16)


Least Favorable SoS (Weeks 14 - 16)


IDP Injury Considerations


PlayerPosReturnYou Want
Richard SeymourDLMight Return This WeekElsewhere
Terrell SuggsDLOut IndefinitelyJarrett Johnson
Antwan OdomDLOut Rest of SeasonMichael Johnson
Kris JenkinsDLOut Rest of SeasonElsewhere


PlayerPosReturnYou Want
Lawrence TimmonsLBReturned Last Week
Justin DurantLBShould Return This Week
Keith RiversLBMight Return This WeekDehani Jones
David ThorntonLBMight Return This WeekElsewhere
Ernie SimsLBOut IndefinitelyDeAndre Levy
Landon JohnsonLBOut IndefinitelyJames Anderson
Akeem JordanLBOut IndefinitelyWill Witherspoon
Brian UrlacherLBOut Rest of SeasonNick Roach
Lofa TatupuLBOut Rest of SeasonDavid Hawthorne
D'Qwell JacksonLBOut Rest of SeasonKaluka Maiava
Omar GaitherLBOut Rest of SeasonWill Witherspoon
Pisa TinoisamaLBOut Rest of SeasonNick Roach
Eric BartonLBOut Rest of SeasonDavid Veikune
Thomas DavisLBOut Rest of SeasonLandon Johnson
Antonio PierceLBOut Rest of SeasonMichael Boley
Keith EllisonLBOut Rest of SeasonBryan Scott


PlayerPosReturnYou Want
Donte WhitnerDBReturned Last Week
Nick HarperDBReturned Last Week
Michael LewisDBReturned Last Week
Al AfalavaDBReturned Last Week
Antoine WinfieldDBShould Return This Week
Jairus ByrdDBShould Return This Week
Troy PolamaluDBOut Until Week 13-15Tyrone Carter
Ko Simpson
DBOut Until Week 13-15Marvin White
Nate ClementsDBOut Until Week 14-16Dashon Goldson
Brian DawkinsDBOut IndefinitelyDarcel McBath
Tracy PorterDBOut IndefinitelyDarren Sharper
Chris Horton
DBOut Rest of Season
Reed Doughty
Jermaine PhillipsDBOut Rest of SeasonSabby Piscitelli
Daniel BullocksDBOut Rest of SeasonLouis Delmas
Kenny PhillipsDBOut Rest of SeasonC.C. Brown
Will AllenDBOut Rest of SeasonElsewhere
Jarrad PageDBOut Rest of SeasonMike Brown
Roy WilliamsDBOut Rest of SeasonChinedum Ndukwe
Al HarrisDBOut Rest of SeasonTramon Williams


Remember to Bookmark or Favorite us and check back every Wednesday around noon for new insightful posts on who to get for your IDP leagues this year. I'll be here all season to answer any of your questions and help your teams any way I can.

-Justin Curry


    Meet the Draft's Most Explosive Back

    Featured logo

    Meet the Draft's Most Explosive Back

    Mike Tanier
    via Bleacher Report

    Every NFL Team's Biggest Draft Bust

    Featured logo

    Every NFL Team's Biggest Draft Bust

    Kristopher Knox
    via Bleacher Report

    NFL Draft Prospect Concerning Teams with...Music?

    Featured logo

    NFL Draft Prospect Concerning Teams with...Music?

    Master Tesfatsion
    via Bleacher Report

    Cavs Clearly 'Still Trying to Figure' It Out

    Featured logo

    Cavs Clearly 'Still Trying to Figure' It Out

    Ken Berger
    via Bleacher Report