Buckeye Commentary Blog Poll: College Football Week 10

Buckeye CommentarySenior Analyst INovember 10, 2009

TUSCALOOSA, AL - NOVEMBER 07:  Quarterback Greg McElroy #12 of the Alabama Crimson Tide rushes upfield against Lavar Edwards #89 of the Louisiana State University Tigers at Bryant-Denny Stadium on November 7, 2009 in Tuscaloosa, Alabama.  (Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)
Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images
1.Alabama9-0125at Mississippi State
2.Texas9-0252at Baylor
3.Florida9-0342at South Carolina
4.Georgia Tech9-1512at Duke
5.TCU9-0947v. (20) Utah
6.Cincinnati9-0767v. West Virginia
7.LSU7-2817v. Louisiana Tech
8.Oregon7-246v. Arizona State
9.USC7-2117v. (24) Stanford
10.Miami7-21811at North Carolina
11.Ohio State8-21946v. (13) Iowa
12.Boise State9-01382v. Idaho
13.Iowa9-1639at (11) Ohio State
14.Arizona6-21416at California
15.Pittsburgh8-11570v. Notre Dame
16.Houston8-11694at Central Florida
17.Oklahoma State7-22068v. Texas Tech
18.Penn State8-21272v. Indiana
19.Tennessee5-42532at Ole Miss
20.Utah8-12499at (5) TCU
21.Wisconsin7-22244v. Michigan
22.Virginia Tech6-3214at Maryland
23.Clemson6-3NR23at N.C. State
24.Stanford6-3NR15at (9) USC
25.Oregon State6-3NR9v. Washington


Let’s Start at the End(zone): The bottom half of this thing is regoddamndiculous.

Once you get past Pittsburgh, it is essentially arbitrary selection.  

As soon as you hit the mid-teens all teams look the same: hideously inconsistent, burdened with multiple defeats (one inexplicable), and aiming for a season that will ultiamtely be crowned by a post season appearance sponsored by company that you would not work for.

Am I being too hard on Virginia Tech?  Almost certainly, as two of their losses are to my No. 1 and  No. 4 teams, respectively.  

Oh yeah, they lost in Chapel Hill along the way.  


Meanwhile, a team they throttled resides at No. 10.

I know.  I am an idot.

Seriously, Tennessee at #19?  They are only 2-3 in the SEC and played the worst really close game in recent memory against Alabama. How can they even be ranked?

While we are in the neighborhood, should Penn State even be ranked?  What is their best win? Temple?  Northwestern? Could they really beat Wisconsin?

Thank God for 1-3: Eventually, this triumvirate will have to change.  Or, maybe not.

These are the best three teams around, easily.  Could GT really rush for their customary quarter mile against the top dogs?  Will you on TCU, Cincinnati, or Boise State against the Tide or Gators or Longhorns?

The Best of the (2-loss) Rest: The Tigers have lost close games against Florida and Alabama, a distinction they share with Tennessee.  That does not necessarily make them the best 2-loss team, just the least offensive.

And, yes, Boise State is #12.  Does that defense look any good to you?  Not me.  They need to be nuking their competition and, to the contrary, they are struggling for large parts of their games.  

I don’t want to hear about the Oregon game from 2 months ago.  One game does not make a ranking.