College Football Heisman Race: Week Nine

Eric Samulski by Correspondent Written on November 01, 2009
NEW YORK - DECEMBER 5:  The original cast of the 1935 Heisman trophy is displayed December 5, 2005 in New York City. The plaster cast sculpture for what became the Heisman trophy is estimated to sell for $200,000 to $300,000 at auction December 10.  (Photo by Michael Nagle/Getty Images) Michael Nagle/Getty Images

Each week, I'll break down who I think are the top 10 contenders for the Heisman and let you know who may have fallen out of contention.

I base my rankings on what the Heisman Committee tends to value when honoring its winner, so I'll be ranking based on what I think the committee is considering. (Previous rankings are in parentheses).

 

1. (3) Tim Tebow—QB, Florida

Here we go again. Now, anybody who's read my articles over the course of the season knows that I don't rank Tebow here strictly because of his stats. The Heisman Trophy winning circle has been dominated by QBs recently.

The Heisman celebration has also started to reward reputation over stats; big name players over big seasons.

With that in mind, I truly believe the committee is dying for Tebow to start putting together some solid performances. He is, after all, the most recognizable face in college football.

Going 15-for-21 for 164 yards through the air and two TDs, plus an additional 85 yards and two TDs on the ground, is just what the committee is waiting for. Even if Georgia is clearly not the team it's been in recent years.

 

2. (1) Mark Ingram—RB, Alabama

I still think Ingram deserves the award based purely on performance, but truly believe that he falls behind Tebow right now for the above reasons. Alabama was off this week, so he wasn't able to add to his statistical total, but 1,004 yards on the season is still impressive.

That number makes him fifth in the nation in rushing and he gains yards at 6.6 per carry. It might very well come done to the conference championship games.

 

3. (2) Jimmy Clausen—QB, Notre Dame

Notre Dame certainly didn't do any favors to its strength of schedule this week, but you can't fault Clausen. Where some players from heavy favorites tend to fall into a bit of a lull against weak teams (Ricky Stanzi's five INTs this week), Clausen ups his performance every week.

He went 22-for-27 for 268 yards and three TDs in leading the Fighting Irish to another win. Notre Dame needs to keep winning for him to have a shot, but he's there if the season ended now.

 

4. (4) Colt McCoy—QB, Texas

Texas dominated an underrated Oklahoma State team, but don't get so excited about what that does for Colt's chances. The game was won mostly by Texas' defense and the field position battle.

McCoy only threw five incomplete passes, but he didn't throw much during the game, going 16-for-21 for 171 yards and one single TD. The win was good, but the numbers won't help his cause.

 

5. (8) Kellen Moore—QB, Boise State

Boise State may be getting pushed by TCU for the title of BCS Buster, but not many people are pushing Moore for any recognition this season. The lefty had another stellar performance this week against a solid San Jose State University defense.

He threw more incomplete passes than usual, but still went 21-for-33 for 278 yards and three TDs. He's only 30th in the nation with 1,905 yards, but he has a 67 percent completion percentage and is second to only Case Keenum with 24 TDs on the season.

 

6. (10) Case Keenum—QB, Houston

Man, Houston's defense is doing everything it can to kill its QB's shot at being invited to NYC. That defense might not be able to stop a high school offense, but the 6'1" Keenum just keeps pushing the Cougars to victories.

He completed 44 of 54 passes for a ridiculous 559 yards and five TDs, including one on a late fourth quarter, game-winning drive. He's thrown for a nation-leading 3,293 yards and 25 TDs and could very well seal himself an invite if Houston can avoid that second loss.

 

7. (7) Dion Lewis—RB, Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh was another team with an off-week this past Saturday, so hopefully Lewis is resting up for the final push. Virginia Tech's loss drops Ryan Williams from the list, leaving Lewis as the only freshman on the list.

Without question, it's a serious uphill climb and Pitt may need to win out to even give him a chance, but his stats don't hurt. On the season, he is fourth in the nation in rushing with 1,029 yards, averaging 5.6 yards per carry, and has crossed the goal line 11 times.

 

8. (5) Tony Pike—QB, Cincinnati

Pike is still on this list based on Cincinnati's record and his potential. Before the injury to his non-throwing arm, Pike was a front-runner for the award, throwing for 1,633 yards and 15 TDs in six games.

In his absence Cinncy has continued to roll behind Collaros, but Pike will be back, and if he continues that level of play and the Bearcats keep winning, his name is going to resurface again.

 

Single Page
(1)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

16 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

727
reads

16
comments

written on November 01, 2009 Opinion

The best newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.