Top 100 Pro Running Backs of All Time: Nos. 76-100

Mike Anderson by Correspondent Written on October 24, 2009

Slide 1 of 27

Display_image

Rest assured, I wrote this article after extensive research. The list was compiled after looking at about 175 candidates. Some of the stats that I focused on in coming up with the list were rushing yards, yards per game, rushing touchdowns, yards per carry, receptions, receiving yards, and receiving touchdowns.

After placing all the candidates in order based on stats, I weighed each stat appropriately: for example I feel that rushing yards were more important than receiving touchdowns, therefore it was weighed heavier in my rankings.

After compiling the list based solely on stats I took other factors into account such as career length, whether injuries played a part, and also when they played.

Finally, I injected my own opinion into the list since, after all, it is my list.

The list will consist of fullbacks, tailbacks, halfbacks and anyone else you might consider a running back.

It should be noted that this list is about players who handled the ball so you won't see great fullbacks that were strictly blockers on the list.

The stats for current players are up through week 6 of the current NFL season.

I know that there will be many differing opinions about this list, but I hope you enjoy it regardless.

100. Ollie Matson

Display_image

Chicago Cardinals: 1952-1958
Los Angeles Rams: 1959-1962
Detroit Lions: 1963
Philadelphia Eagles: 1964-1966

Rushing Yards: 5173
YDS/ATT: 4.4
Rush TD: 40

1952 Rookie of the Year
6x Pro Bowler
5x All Pro

Ollie was one of the fastest players around. He actually won a bronze medal in the 400 meter in the 1952 Olympics. Matson was a member of the 1950's all decade team. He was also one of the best returners in league history as well. Two times during his career he lead the league in all purpose yards.

99. Bo Jackson

13 JAN 1991:  LOS ANGELES RAIDERS RUNNING BACK BO JACKSON CARRIES THE FOOTBALL DURING THE RAIDERS 20-10 WIN OVER THE CINCINNATI BENGALS AT THE MEMORIAL COLISEUM IN LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA.  MANDATORY CREDIT:  MIKE POWELL/ALLSPORT

Los Angeles Raiders: 1987-1990

Rushing Yards: 2782
YDS/ATT: 5.4
Rush TD: 16

1x Pro Bowler

If I made this list based just on career stats, Bo probably wouldn't have made it, but anyone that watched this guy play knows how talented he was. Hip surgery forced him out of football and took away one of the most talented runners the league has ever seen. He is the first player ever to be named to the All Star team in 2 different major sports. He holds the record for rushing yards in a Monday Night Football game with 221. His 5.4 yards an attempt is 9th all time.

98. Natrone Means

19 Sep 1999:  Natrone Means #20 of the San Diego Chargers moves with the ball during the game against the Cincinnati Bengals at Cinergy Field in Cincinnati, Ohio. The Chargers defeated the Bengals 34-7. Mandatory Credit: Matthew Stockman  /Allsport

San Diego Chargers: 1993-1995, 1998-1999
Jacksonville Jaguars: 1996-1997
Carolina Panthers: 2000

Rushing Yards: 5215
YDS/ATT: 3.7
Rush TD: 45

1x Pro Bowler

Means had a short career, but for a time he was one of the most powerful backs in the league. He was the offensive star for the surprising Super Bowl run of the Chargers in the 94 season.

97. Ron A. Johnson

Display_image

Cleveland Browns: 1969
New York Giants: 1970-1975

Rushing Yards: 4308
Rush TD: 40
Receptions: 213

2x Pro Bowler
1x All Pro

Johnson was a versatile back with a short career. He ran for the Giants first two 1,000 yard seasons in franchise history. He led the league in rushing attempts twice, touchdowns once, and yards from scrimmage once.

96. Duce Staley

IRVING, TX - OCTOBER 12:  Running back Duce Staley #22 of the Philadelphia Eagles carries the ball against the Dallas Cowboys during the NFL game at Texas Stadium on October 12, 2003 in Irving, Texas. The Cowboys defeated the Eagles 23-21.  (Photo by Rona

Philadelphia Eagles: 1997-2003
Pittsburgh Steelers: 2004-2006

Rushing Yards: 5785
YDS/ATT: 4.0
Rush TD: 24

1x Super Bowl Champion

When Staley played, he was considered one of the best pass catching running backs in the game. His finest season came in 1999 when he was in the top ten in rushing attempts, rushing yards, rushing yards a game, and yards from scrimmage.

95. Ted Brown

Display_image

Minnesota Vikings: 1979-1986

Rushing Yards: 4546
Rush TD: 40
Receptions: 339

Brown was a fullback more than anything but he was a valuable fullback not only running the ball but catching it as well. His 83 receptions in 1981 was good for the third highest in the NFL and proved that even the big boys can catch the ball.

94. Joe Cribbs

1988:  Running back Joe Cribbs of the Miami Dolphins runs with the ball. Mandatory Credit: Allen Steele  /Allsport

Buffalo Bills: 1980-1985
San Francisco 49ers: 1986-1987
Miami Dolphins: 1988
Indianapolis Colts: 1988

Rushing Yards: 5356
Rush TD: 27
RushYDS/GM: 52.5

3x Pro Bowler

Cribbs busted onto the scene in his first year in the NFL as he was the only rookie chosen to start in the Pro Bowl. His career was short but he made the most of it and in 1982 he led the NFL in rushing yards a game with 90.4.

93. Greg Pruitt

Display_image

Cleveland Browns: 1973-1981
Los Angeles Raiders: 1982-1984

Rushing Yards: 5672
Rush TD: 27
YDS/ATT: 4.7

1x Super Bowl Champion
5x Pro Bowler

For a while Pruitt was one of the best runners in the NFL. In 3 consecutive seasons, he ran for over 1000 yards and in one of those seasons he didn't start a game. He was also a good return man, and in 1983 he led the NFL in Yards per touch with 12.3

92. Hugh McElhenny

Display_image

San Francisco 49ers: 1952-1960
Minnesota Vikings: 1961-1962
New York Giants: 1963
Detroit Lions: 1964

Rushing Yards: 5281
YDS/ATT: 4.7
RUSH TD: 38

6x Pro Bowler
2x First Team All Pro

"The King" was a dominant rusher when the league was small. Seasons were only 12 games when Hugh played but during that time he dominated the field. He ended in the top ten in rushing yards and rushing touchdown in 4 different seasons.

91. Travis Henry

ORCHARD PARK, NY - NOVEMBER 3:  Running Back Travis Henry #20 of the Buffalo Bills rushes during the NFL game against the New England Patriots at Ralph Wilson Stadium on November 3, 2002 in Orchard Park, New York. The Patriots defeated the Bills 38-7.(Pho

Buffalo Bills: 2001-2004
Tennessee Titans: 2005-2006
Denver Broncos: 2007

Rushing Yards: 6086
YDS/GM 68.4
Rush TD: 38

1x Pro Bowler

Henry had a short but productive career. He is Buffalo's 4th all time rusher. Three times during his career, he was in the top ten in yards per game. Twice he was in the top ten in rushing yards and rushing touchdowns.

90. Rick Casares

Display_image

Chicago Bears: 1955-1964
Washington Redskins: 1965
Miami Dolphins: 1966

Rushing Yards: 5797
Rush TD: 49
YDS/ATT: 4.1

1x NFL Champion
5x Pro Bowler
1x First Team All Pro

Casares was one of the first hard nosed rushers around and in 1956 he proved this by running for 1126 yards, which at the time was the second most ever in a season. Casares was the Bears all time leader in rushing for years until Walter Payton broke his records.

89. Sam Cunningham

Display_image

New England Patriots: 1973-1982

Rushing Yards: 5453
Rush TD: 43
YDS/GM: 51.0

1x Pro Bowler

Better Known as being Randall's older brother, Sam was a very effective running fullback for the Patriots in his career. He twice was in the top ten in rushing yards and touchdowns and three times he was in the top ten in rushing yards a game. He also had the longest run of the season in 1974 with a 75 yard run.

88. James Stewart

3 Oct 1999: James Stewart #33 of the Jacksonville Jaguars carries the ball during the game against the Pittsburgh Steelers at the Three Rivers Stadium in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The Jaguars defeated the Steelers 17-3. Mandatory Credit: Jamie Squire  /Al

Jacksonville Jaguars: 1995-1999
Detroit Lions: 2000-2002

Rushing Yards: 5841
Rush TD: 48
YDS/ATT: 4.0

Stewart wasn't flashy but was a guy who got the job done when his team needed him. He was best known for having a nose for the end zone which was evident by being in the top ten in rushing touchdowns in 4 different seasons in his short career.

87. Mike Garrett

Display_image

Kansas City Chiefs: 1966-1970
San Diego Chargers: 1970-1973

Rushing Yards: 5481
Rush TD: 35
YDS/ATT: 4.2

2x AFL Champion
1x Super Bowl Champion
2x Pro Bowler
1x First Team All Pro

Garrett was one of the most dominating runners in the late 60's and early 70's a time of transition for football. During five different seasons he was in the top ten in rushing yards and rushing attempts, three times he was in the top ten in rushing touchdowns. In 1966 his 77 yard run was the longest in the NFL that season.

86. Jamal Anderson

27 Dec 1998: Jamal Anderson #32 of the Atlanta Falcons runs during the game against the Miami Dolphins at the Georgia Dome in Atlanta, Georgia. The Falcons defeated the Dolphins 38-16.

Atlanta Falcons: 1994-2001

Rushing Yards: 5336
YDS/ATT: 4.0
Rush TD: 34

1x Pro Bowler
1x All Pro First Team

Anderson was a punishing running back that could run over anyone. His 1998 season is one of the finest the game has ever seen. He was second in the league in rushing yards with 1846, and his 410 rushing attempts are the second most ever in a season.

85. Frank Gore

PITTSBURGH - SEPTEMBER 23:  Frank Gore #21 of the San Francisco 49ers runs with the ball against the Pittsburgh Steelers on September 23, 2007 During the NFL game at Heinz Field in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The Steelers won 36-17. (Photo by Rick Stewart/G

San Francisco 49ers: 2005-present

Rushing Yards: 4682
YDS/ATT: 4.8
Rush TD: 25

1x Pro Bowler

Gore is one of today's most consistent and talented running backs. He has now had 3 consecutive seasons of 1,000 or more rushing yards. He currently holds the 49ers single season rushing record with 1695 yards rushing in 2006 which was good for third in the NFL that season.

84. Adrian Peterson

MINNEAPOLIS - OCTOBER 18:  Running back Adrian Peterson #28 of the Minnesota Vikings rushes the ball against the Baltimore Ravens during NFL action at Hubert H. Humphrey Metrodome on October 18, 2009 in Minneapolis, Minnesota.  (Photo by Doug Pensinger/Ge

Minnesota Vikings: 2007-present

Rushing Yards: 3725
YDS/GM: 103.5
YDS/ATT: 5.2

2007 Rookie of the Year
2x Pro Bowler
1x First Team All Pro

Peterson may only be in his third year but he has already proven to be one of the most talented runners in the history of the NFL. He already has made some records in his short playing time. He was the only rookie to ever rush for 200+ rushing yards in two different games. He had more rushing yards with 1036 in his first eight games than anyone ever. He also holds the single game record for rushing yards with 296. As long as Peterson doesn't get injured he should easily be considered one of the top ten running backs of all time and possibly the greatest ever.

83. John Henry Johnson

Display_image

San Francisco 49ers: 1954-1956
Detroit Lions: 1957-1959
Pittsburgh Steelers: 1960-1965
Houston Oilers: 1966

Rushing Yards: 6803
YDS/ATT: 4.3
Rush TD: 48

1x NFL Champion
4x Pro Bowler

Johnson is often forgotten about when people talk about the all time greats but during his time he was one of the most consistent runners in the game. When he retired he was fourth all time in career rushing yards. He is currently the Steelers fourth all time rusher. He never led the league in rushing but on 3 different occasions he was either second or third, and on seven different occasions he was in the top ten. His 87 yard run in 1960 was the longest of the season.

82. Abner Haynes

Display_image

Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs: 1960-1964
Denver Broncos: 1965-1966
Miami Dolphins: 1967
New York Jets: 1967

Rushing Yards: 4630
YDS/ATT: 4.5
Rush TD: 46

1x AFL Champion
1960 AFL Rookie of the Year
1960 AFL MVP
3x Pro Bowler
2x First Team All Pro

Haynes might have been the league's most versatile back of the time. In three different seasons, he led the league in rushing touchdowns, he also led the league in rushing yards, rushing attempts, and rushing yards per game once during his career.

81. Antowain Smith

ORCHARD PARK, NY - NOVEMBER 3:  Running back Antowain Smith #32 of the New England Patriots rushes for 111 yards and three touchdowns during the NFL game against the Buffalo Bills at Ralph Wilson Stadium on November 3, 2002 in Orchard Park, New York.  The

Buffalo Bills: 1997-2000
New England Patriots: 2001-2003
Tennessee Titans: 2004
New Orleans Saints: 2005

Rushing Yards: 6881
Rush TD: 54
YDS/GM: 52.5

2x Super Bowl Champion

During his career he was never considered one of the best backs in the game but he was often pivotal in his teams success. He was a vital part of two of the Patriots Super Bowl wins. Never flashy but always reliable, Smith was one of the most overlooked players around.

80. Mike Alstott

Tampa Bay Buccaneers fullback Mike Alstott rushes upfield   at Raymond James Stadium  in a preseason game August 28, 2004 against the Miami Dolphins.  (Photo by Al Messerschmidt/Getty Images)

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: 1996-2006

Rushing Yards: 5088
TOTAL TD: 71
YDS/ATT: 3.7

1x Super Bowl Champion
6x Pro Bowler
3x First Team All Pro

Alstott is arguably the greatest running fullback the game has ever seen. He is the Buccaneers all-time touchdown leader with 76 total TDs. He was known for knocking people over when he ran but he was a good receiver as well. His 58 rushing touchdowns in good for 40th all-time.

79. Pete Johnson

Display_image

Cincinnati Bengals: 1977-1983
San Diego Chargers: 1984
Miami Dolphins: 1984

Rushing Yards: 5626
Rush TD: 76
YDS/GM: 51.1

1x Pro Bowler

Pete led the Bengals in rushing all 7 seasons that he played for the franchise. His 76 career rushing touchdowns is good for 21st all time. Five times during his career he was in the top ten in rushing touchdowns. When he left Cincinnati, he was their all time leading rusher. And, he also helped them to their first ever playoff win and first ever Super Bowl appearance.

78. Don Perkins

Display_image

Dallas Cowboys: 1961-1968

Rushing Yards: 6217
Rush TD: 42
YDS/ATT: 4.1

1961 Rookie of the Year
6x Pro Bowler
1x First Team All Pro

He was the first Cowboys player to ever run for over 100 yards in a game and was often a leader in rushing as he placed in the top 10 on eight different occasions. In 1962, he became the first Cowboy to ever make the All NFL team. He is the Cowboys third all time rusher.

77. Willis McGahee

BALTIMORE - SEPTEMBER 27:  Willis McGahee #23 of the Baltimore Ravens runs the ball in for the winning touchdown against the Cleveland Browns at M&T Bank Stadium on September 27, 2009 in Baltimore, Maryland. The Ravens defeated the Browns 34-3. (Photo by

Buffalo Bills: 2004-2006
Baltimore Ravens: 2007-present

Rushing Yards: 5445
YDS/ATT: 4.0
Rush TD: 43

1x Pro Bowler

McGahee has dealt with injuries throughout his career but there is no doubting his ability. He runs hard and fast and at times looks like one of the best backs in the game. He is currently 9th among active running backs with his 43 career rushing touchdowns.

76. Greg Bell

ANAHEIM, CA - NOVEMBER 12: Running back Greg Bell #42 of the Los Angeles Rams finds room to run with the ball against the New York Giants at Anaheim Stadium on November 12, 1989 in Anaheim, California. The Rams won 31-10. (Photo by George Rose/Getty Image

Buffalo Bills: 1984-1987
Los Angeles Rams: 1987-1989
Los Angeles Raiders: 1990

Rushing Yards: 4959
Rush TD: 51
YDS/GM: 62.0

1x Pro Bowler
1988 Comeback Player of the Year

Bell dealt with injuries that shortened his career but when healthy was one of the most productive runners of the 80's. He led the NFL in rushing touchdowns on two separate occasions. In those two seasons, he was also in the top ten in rushing yards. His 85 yard run in a 1984 game was the longest of the season.

(0)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

2 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

1,117
reads

2
comments

written on October 24, 2009 Rankings/List

The best Lions newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.