NHL Power Rankings (Oct. 24): Month of The Shootout

Mark Jones by Analyst Written on October 24, 2009
PHILADELPHIA - OCTOBER 22:  Ray Emery #29 of the Philadelphia Flyers makes a shootout save against Blake Wheeler #26 of the Boston Bruins on October 22, 2009 at Wachovia Center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The Flyers won the game 4-3 after a shootout.  (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images) (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)

There have been plenty of big stories already to start the 2009-2010 NHL season.

Up-and-coming surprise teams such as the Avs, Oilers, Sabres, and Coyotes are all sitting unexpectedly among the top of the league standings, while other perennial powerhouses like the Bruins, Red Wings, Canucks, Ducks, and Hurricanes are all struggling through a slow first month.

But the perhaps the biggest story? The shootout.

The controversial breakaway competition used to finish games after overtime has been seeing a lot of usage recently, and its been bringing complaints to the fullest about this unusual way to determine who wins a game.

Anyway, the power rankings are going into overtime as well, because with these jumbled-up standings, its impossible to determine anything at first glance!

Well, almost anything. I think we know where the Penguins are...

So, for those of you who like everything straightforward and proportional, here's the power rankings formula that I use, slightly modified from last week:

  • 30% Projected Results
  • 60% Success this season (so far)
  • 10% intangibles/miscellaneous (a.k.a. Marc Savard and Milan Lucic)

 

1. Pittsburgh Penguins

No question here. The defending Stanley Cup champs are arguably looking even better than last year, and they are undefeated in their last seven as well as the 5-0 road record.

 

2. Calgary Flames

They haven't been getting a lot of attention, but the Flames have won two back-to-back games and are second in the West standings right now.

 

3. Washington Capitals

At first they were hot, then they got cold, and now the Caps are hot again with three straight wins. The team may be hard to figure out, but that top line sure isn't.

 

4. Buffalo Sabres

Even with just seven games played, the Sabres have only lost once in regulation (5-1-1) and Ryan Miller is looking very sharp. The Sabres may finally have pulled it together after a disappointing season last year.

 

5. New York Rangers

The perfect start has faded a bit, but they are still 7-3. However, this is a team that looked poised to be hard struck by injuries.

 

6. Edmonton Oilers

The Oilers have started well after a successful offseason and are also winners of three straight. Khahibulin is apparently getting the job done and the offense is really picking up, too.

 

7. Chicago Blackhawks

The 'Hawks have dropped back-to-back contests, but the preseason Western Conference champion favorite has looked pretty good so far this year. Patrick Sharp has had a tremendous October as well.

 

8. Philadelphia Flyers

Just a mediocre four wins in seven games played, but the Flyers have looked solid and their main question to begin the season, Ray Emery, has been quite fine so far.

 

9. Colorado Avalanche

We all expect the Avs to fall back down to earth soon, but Colorado just keeps on winning. They have managed to put together quite a group of top nine forwards, and the special teams play is clicking as well. However, I still have trouble believing they are really as good as their record sounds.

 

10. Ottawa Senators

The Sens have looked good on the scoresheet so far, fitting nicely into the vision I had of them when I called them asmy preseason 'Eastern Conference dark horse'. The main key to their 5-2-1 record: for once, Ottawa is winning close games.

 

11. New Jersey Devils

I had a feeling the Devils could be a real bust this season, but so far they've looked decent. However, they haven't looked that good at home (just 1-3), and that's not a trait that will carry you far into the postseason.

 

12. Columbus Blue Jackets

The Jackets have cooled off a bit since last week, but the top line is just too good for these Jackets not to finish as a top-six seed. Add in another sensational year from a more-experienced Steve Mason, and Columbus could be dangerous.

 

13. Detroit Red Wings

They've begun to come together after a very forgettable first two weeks, but the Red Wings still have lots of work to do if they want to have a chance at revenging their game seven Cup defeat.

 

14. Phoenix Coyotes

It would have been a laughable concept to think that they Coyotes would be have the sixth-best record in the NHL at the end of October, but its no longer a fantasy. The defense has been stellar, but I am still looking for this team to start getting the offense really going, too.

 

15. San Jose Sharks

Its been an average first ten games for the Sharks, but Heatley is fitting in very well and it doesn't take a genius to guess that San Jose will be among the top finishers by March. We've just got to see if they can come together as a team and take that next step.

 

16. Los Angeles Kings

They started hot, imploded, and now they've won two straight again. Weird team to predict..

Anyhow, Ryan Smyth has been great and the Kings have looked really great at home.

 

17. Vancouver Canucks

I thought that this team might have the talent to go really far this season, but, after a such a so-so first month, I'm not so sure anymore. If Luongo can take this team on his back again, they could still make an impact in the Western Conference later in the season.

 

18. Atlanta Thrashers

It seems as if the Thrashers may finally have gotten the chemistry they need to take advantage of their plentiful up-and-coming young stars.

Still, I wouldn't get too excited with this goalie group supporting the back end.

 

19. St. Louis Blues

The best they looked was when they were in Europe to start the season, not much of an accomplishment for a team in America.

Still, they Blues are still at .500 and they have the depth to pull themselves up from a boring October.

 

20. Boston Bruins

The one way to describe October for the Bruins is definitely not boring, but it hasn't been that good, either.

Injuries are really hurting this team, and Tim Thomas needs to improve and help them limp their way until the full roster hopefully returns.

 

21. Dallas Stars

The Stars are getting points from it, but they just don't seem good enough to ever really pull away from their opponent. However, if they can start winning competitive games, Dallas could sneak their way into the playoff picture by the new year.

 

22. Anaheim Ducks

The Ducks have dropped their past two and have won just three of eight so far. This team needs to start converting on places other than the first line if they want to live up to their soaring preseason hype.

 

23. Montreal Canadiens

After 2-5, two back-to-back victories helps, but it still doesn't but the Habs where they want to be.

A big winning run might manage to get some life back in Montreal, though, and they have the support and talent to do it.

 

24. Carolina Hurricanes

So far, the 'Canes have kept up with opponents, but they keep not having quite enough to win the game.

If the powerplay and discipline improves, though, the 'Canes could be right back where they want to be in a month.

 

25. Tampa Bay Lightning

Hedman and Stamkos are doing great, but where is that valuable top line production? Tanguay, Lecavalier, and St. Louis need to turn into a great leadership group and start scoring more goals if Tampa is going to compete with such an experience bottom nine.

 

26. Nashville Predators

Not much to say about the Preds besides the dreary, slow start that was pretty much expected. I'm just not seeing much from Nashville right now.

 

27. Florida Panthers

Vokoun has not been the All-Star goaltender he was expected to be, and nor has the Panthers.

 

28. Minnesota Wild

They were certainly hoping for more than a 2-7-0 record to start the year, but there's still tons of time to turn it around before even the one-third mark. A win against struggling Carolina tonight would be a big boost for the Wild.

 

29. New York Islanders

It is a disgrace to the NHL to have such a bad team as the Islanders not in last place...

 

30. Toronto Maple Leafs

...but, then again, talk about disgraces...

 

Vote Now! - Author Poll

Are the Avs really for real, or will Colorado fall back to Earth soon?

  • They've really for real!
  • No, they're in for a losing streak soon
  • Not sure, it depends on the next couple weeks
vote to see results
Results - Author Poll

Are the Avs really for real, or will Colorado fall back to Earth soon?

  • They've really for real!

    28.6%
  • No, they're in for a losing streak soon

    38.9%
  • Not sure, it depends on the next couple weeks

    32.4%
  • Total votes: 185
(0)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

0 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

2,039
reads

0
comments

written on October 24, 2009 Rankings/List

Top Stories from NHL.com

NHL on B/R | Official Partners

The best Hurricanes newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.