What Does Oregon's Loss to Boise State Mean Today?

Caleb M. by Scribe Written on October 18, 2009
BOISE, ID - SEPTEMBER 3: Joey Paul #41 of the Boise State Broncos taunts Oregon Duck players after LaGarrette Blount #9 (not in photo) of the Oregon Ducks punched a Boise State Broncos player after the Boise State defeated Oregon 19-8 on September 3, 2009 at Bronco Stadium in Boise, Idaho. (Photo by Steve Dykes/Getty Images) (Photo by Steve Dykes/Getty Images)

So we all remember the day. Sept. 3, 2009. It's burned into every honest Oregon fan's mind. 

In addition to the idiocracy of LeGarrette Blount and the shame he's brought to the university, we have the whole rest of the game. Quite frankly, Oregon was the laughingstock of the NCAA.

Since then, what have the two teams been up to? Was the game a fluke? What was Oregon's problem that fateful night? Is the loss as significant as at was in September?

Well, since Sept. 3 the Ducks have skyrocketed. Losing Blount provided us with the gem LaMichael James. Masoli has stepped up as a leader, and Ed Dickson is a big bad touchdown-scoring machine.

Oregon has come off victorious against Purdue in a nail biter, and finished off non-conference play against ranked Utah, winning by a touchdown.

The Ducks have won conference games against then ranked number six Cal, and Washington State in impressive wins. The combined scores are 94-9. Ouch. 

Ed Dickson began to really step up in Cal's win, followed by an impressive three touchdowns in the slaughter of the Cougars. 

Last Saturday, the Ducks traveled to the Rose Bowl in Pasadena to take on UCLA. Despite injury to Masoli, Thurmond, Ward, and Blount being suspended, Oregon walked away with a 24-10 victory under "newbie" Quarterback Nate Costa.

Oregon is now 3-0 in conference play, and looks unstoppable in the Pac-10. USC might have something to say about that...but as of right now, we're 3-0 and leading the conference.

Boise State, however, is somewhat of a different story. Nothing has come close to living up to the Ducks mockery on Sept. 3. 

Allowing Fresno three time to get touchdown runs of 60 yards or more, and 34 points? That turned some heads. Then we look at the UC Davis game. A FCS team, not even a top FCS team, almost took it away from BSU. Sure, Boise State fans pitch a fit when everyone "picks on them", but seriously.

UC Davis was right in it, and nearly won it. It honestly was a really good game, until the second half when the Broncos pulled away. Then Boise played Tulsa.

And wow, what a game.

Tulsa was really close, and looked really good with that fumble recovery during the third quarter. Boise was a mess, and the Golden Hurricane looked...golden. Boise only just squeaked it out 28-21. 

Here's what CBS's impartial thoughts are. Now, while it praises BSU, it brings out two important things. One, this isn't helping their poll votes. It'll disappoint in the BCS poll for sure, and they might just drop a few spots.

Two is the fact that turnovers are a cause for concern. They made silly mistakes against Tulsa, fumbles that Tulsa really didn't cause. Same with UC Davis and FSU—bad, thought provoking mistakes and turnovers that nearly cost them the game.

Was that the case with Oregon? Hardly.

The consensus? While Oregon has improved 10 fold since losing that fateful night, Boise has gotten worse in a way.

So what does all this mean?

In two ways, our loss makes Oregon look good. 

 

1. Oregon's loss looks much better now that BSU is a top-five team.

And it's true. While I, along with half the nation think they don't deserve the top five, they are there. Even if they were only one ahead of the Ducks, it makes Oregon look that much better.

Obviously you can put two and two together. As Boise St. improves, logically it comes as less and less of a surprise that Oregon lost. After all, the Broncos are a top five team right? 

They might just stay up there considering the utter failure of the top 25 this week. That also looks even better for Oregon. Having a bye, we might move up two or three spots, starting to make people think the Boise game was a fluke. 

 

2. Oregon has possibly made the best comeback in years.

Now before you go all calling me the arrogant Duck fan, face facts. It's true. It's a marvelous comeback. As any Duck fan knows, it simply incredible everything Oregon has put up with and overcome.

First, you have Chip Kelly. He's brand new at this coaching thing. Sure, he did offense for a while. But taking over the spot of (in my opinion) the best coach in Ducks history?

That's a big step. And he has quite possibly the worst offensive coordinator out there—Mark Helfrich.

I mean really, what on earth on this guy's resume would make you hire him? He's a train wreck and most of the reason the beginning of Oregon's season was so rough. Helfrich was terrible in Colorado, destroyed their offense.

Single Page
Vote Now! - Author Poll

Was the Boise St-Oregon game a fluke?

  • Yes, the Ducks could win if they played tomorrow.
  • No, BSU is a high quality team not to be messed with
  • Doesn't matter, neither have a shot at a BCS bowl.
vote to see results
Results - Author Poll

Was the Boise St-Oregon game a fluke?

  • Yes, the Ducks could win if they played tomorrow.

    84.7%
  • No, BSU is a high quality team not to be messed with

    13.1%
  • Doesn't matter, neither have a shot at a BCS bowl.

    2.2%
  • Total votes: 450
(2)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

21 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

1,988
reads

21
comments

written on October 18, 2009 Opinion

The best Oregon newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.