With the MLB playoff picture beginning to take its final shape, it’s time to start looking at each of the teams still in the race and see how they stack up against each other.
For the next week, I’ll be breaking down all the teams on a position-by-position basis. Today, we look at the guys calling the games, which really is a case of the haves and have-nots.
1. Joe Mauer, Twins
This guy might not only be the best catcher in the playoffs this year, but he might be the best player in the AL.
Mauer has had an unbelievable season for the Twinkies, and has kept it up even after the injury to Justin Morneau. If Minnesota is going to make the playoffs, they need Mauer to rise to the occasion in the next three days and lead them past the Tigers.
2. Brian McCann, Braves
It’s ironic that the teams with the two best players at this position are currently the two teams that are on the outside looking in.
McCann is the heart and soul of the red hot Atlanta Braves, and exactly what you look for in a catcher. Very sound defensively, some power in his bat, and widely recognized in the Braves' clubhouse as a team leader.
The Bravos seem to go as McCann does, and lately he’s been hot. With games left against the Marlins and Nationals, there’s a chance we’ll get to see McCann in the national spotlight during the playoffs.
3. Yadier Molina, Cardinals
One of the Molina catching trio, but certainly the best of that group and one of the best in the Majors.
Molina enjoys quite a few comforts in the lineup, batting behind Albert Pujols and Matt Holliday. But even before Holliday came to St. Louis, he was one of the better offensive catchers in the game.
Defensively, he is often regarded as one of the best, and catching for guys like Chris Carpenter and Adam Wainwright hasn’t hurt him too much, either.
4. Jason Varitek/Victor Martinez, Red Sox
Had the Boston Red Sox not made the deal for Victor Martinez at the trade deadline, it’s hard to say where exactly they would have ended up.
V-Mart has increased the stability of the catcher position in Boston, and Varitek has responded with improved play in the second half. Having both of them in the lineup is also a plus, as Martinez has really taken advantage of hitting in Fenway Park.
They are both very good game managers, as well, which is going to be important when they take on the Angels in the Divisional Series (barring a complete and utter collapse and the Rangers winning out.)
5. Russell Martin, Dodgers
Martin hasn’t had the offensive impact for the Dodgers that many were expecting him to have, but he remains an important piece of the puzzle for Los Angeles behind the plate.
He has a .994 fielding percentage this year and has thrown out 31 percent of all base runners this season, which is important against teams that seem to always get more aggressive in the playoffs.
6. Jorge Posada, Yankees
Posada has the most playoff experience out of all of the catchers on this list and he would be much higher on here, but recent injuries have got to be a major concern for the Yankees and their aging catcher.
If New York deems that Posada can only DH for them, that means that they have to plug in Jose Molina or Francisco Cervelli into the lineup for every game during the playoffs and possibly bench someone like Hideki Matsui, which is a big blow to the vaunted Yankee offense.
7. Mike Napoli, Angels
It’s not that I don’t think highly of Mike Napoli, it’s just that the overall impact that he has on his team isn’t nearly as big as the players ahead of him on this list.
He is more than a serviceable player behind the plate, and has come up with some big hits for Los Angeles of Anaheim of California, et cetera, this season, but he just isn’t a huge part of the Angels’ master plan to win their first World Series since ‘02.
8. Gerald Laird, Tigers
Most people don’t even realize that Gerald Laird is the Tigers’ starting catcher—especially since Brandon Inge is still widely listed as a catcher—and that’s because Laird hasn’t really had to do much this season, working with one of the better pitching staffs in the Majors, while being nicely protected in the bottom third of Detroit’s lineup.
Much like Napoli, he isn’t really a huge part of the Tigers as a team.
9. Chris Iannetta/Yorvit Torrealba, Rockies
I really don’t know what to make of these guys, or most of the Rockies, for that matter.
I don’t think that they're really all that good on offense or defense, but they do what they can for Colorado. They benefit from playing in Coors Field, but that’s just about all you can say about them.
10. Paul Bako/Carlos Ruiz, Phillies
It’s not good when you have Carlos Ruiz as your Opening Day catcher. It’s worse when you have to platoon him with journeyman Paul Bako because of the fact that they are both liabilities on the field for the defending champion Phillies.
This is a position where the Phils are going to have to make a decision during the offseason. They have some decent talent in the minors, but they might want to go out and look at a short-term fix, such as Paul Lo Duca or Johnny Estrada to buy themselves more time.