Should Bill Smith Be Fired if the Twins Miss the Playoffs?

Josh LevittSenior Analyst IAugust 31, 2009

ARLINGTON, TX - JULY 17:  Catcher Joe Mauer #7 of the Minnesota Twins on July 17, 2009 at Rangers Ballpark in Arlington, Texas.  (Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images)

The 2009 Twins have been disappointing (so far). They are a team with three of the best players at their respective positions (Mauer, Morneau, Nathan), but they simply cannot seem to surround these guys with the proper supporting cast. What a shame.

Should GM Bill Smith get the ax this season if the Twins miss the playoffs? Let's take a look at both sides of the debate:

YES (fire Smith!)

• "Botching" the Johan Santana trade was a huge blunder. Even though it's still too early to tell, the Twins package for Santana does not look impressive at the moment.

In return for one of the best pitchers in baseball, the Twins got a young, struggling outfielder with tools (Carlos Gomez), a solid AAA starter (Kevin Mulvey), a AAAA player (Phil Humber), and a pitcher with a big arm, who has struggled in AA (Deolis Guerra).

Needless to say that package is not looking good.

• When the Twins traded Matt Garza and Jason Bartlett for Delmon Young and Brendan Harris, Smith thought that he was giving the Twins' offense the significant boost it needed.

However, two years after the trade, Young has shown no signs of improvement while Brendan Harris has proven to be nothing more than a utility infielder.

On the other side, Garza has developed into a front line starting pitcher and Jason Bartlett has statistically been one of the top five shortstops in baseball this season.

As a result, Smith has failed to surround Mauer and Morneau, two of the best hitters in baseball, with productive hitters.

• The bullpen has been very shaky this season, outside of Joe Nathan.

• The middle infield has been a disaster

• As much as I love Joe Nathan, giving a closer a four-year, $47 million extension is something that will handicap the Twins payroll flexibility in future years.
NO (Keep Smith)

• Three fifths of the starting rotation (Liriano, Perkins, Slowey) has spent time on the DL.

• He's shown a knack for trying to plug holes. You have to give him credit for not totally falling asleep at the wheel, right?

Smith acquired Ron Mahay and Jon Rauch on Friday, acquired Carl Pavano in early August, and swung a deal for Orlando Cabrera at the trading deadline. So at least we know that Smith is trying, even with his limited resources and funds.

• Extensions given out to Justin Morneau, Jason Kubel and Scott Baker are looking like very efficient, team friendly deals at the moment.

• Smith is only two years into his tenure as GM. For a team with the Twins' payroll and resources, people are going to have to be patient. (I hate this argument).


I think people are rough on Smith because they see a team with some amazing players (Mauer, Morneau, and Nathan), but they're surrounded by a far less talented supporting cast. At what point does the GM become responsible for not being able to provide his young stars with a suitable supporting cast that can bring a winner to Minnesota?

As frustrating as this must be for Twins fans, I'm still inclined to give Smith more time.

It'll be a massive disappointment if the Twins miss out on the playoffs given what Joe Mauer has been able to accomplish this season, but this club barely missed out on the playoffs last season and has been right in the thick of things this season even with all their injuries and bad play.



    Ohtani Surrenders HR, Strikes Out 2 in Debut

    MLB logo

    Ohtani Surrenders HR, Strikes Out 2 in Debut

    Mike Chiari
    via Bleacher Report

    Ten Ways to Improve Major League Baseball

    MLB logo

    Ten Ways to Improve Major League Baseball

    Clarity Could Come on Martinez on Saturday

    MLB logo

    Clarity Could Come on Martinez on Saturday

    NBC Sports Boston
    via NBC Sports Boston

    Heyman Ties Twins to Lance Lynn

    Minnesota Twins logo
    Minnesota Twins

    Heyman Ties Twins to Lance Lynn

    1500 ESPN Twin Cities
    via 1500 ESPN Twin Cities