Is Glen Sather Finished Making Moves for the New York Rangers?

Michael Stein by Scribe Written on August 22, 2009
NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 14:  Michal Roszival of the New York Rangers poses for a portrait at Madison Square Garden on September 14, 2006 in New York, New York.  (Photo by Getty Images) (Photo by Getty Images)

Glen Sather...yet again...has totally changed the Rangers roster, from top to bottom.  We have the toughest coach since the iconic Mike Keenan.  The two best penalty killers on possibly the best penalty killing team are gone.  Our free agent prize from two years back, Scott Gomez, was happily shipped up north. 

Added to an anemic-like goal scoring team was quite possibly the most exciting Slokak ever.  We picked up a few big ifs, like Tyler Arnason, Brian Boyle, and Enver Lisin. Our most exciting winger from last year is gone, and probably off to Russia.  To me, none of these though are our biggest issue.

Without a doubt, our blueline is where questions remain. We are still, so far at least, left with two of the most questionable free agent acquisitions, being Michal Roszival and Wade Redden.  Now, prior to last season, I have been a fan of Roszival's.  He's shown me the potential to be a solid offensive defenseman. 

Wade Redden on the other hand, has been a bust since he's been on Broadway.  Because of that, Redden is unmovable (especially at $8 million per), but Roszival might be trade bait.  At $6.5 million a year, for a No. 2 or 3 blueliner, he might be a solid option.

Normally, I'm a guy who believes that a team must have players who can get the puck to their forwards.  The Rangers are stocked with youth who can almost certainly do that.  Both Michael Del Zotto and Bobby Sanguinetti are billed as exceptionally skilled offensive defenseman. 

I truly do not believe that while getting third pairing minutes, either one of them can come close to their potential.  For them to get the minutes, the guys playing those minutes have to be shipped.

The Rangers also lack that tough blueliner to help play in the harder areas.  Dan Girardi  and Marc Staal are solid players, but they need some help.  Interestingly enough, a guy who himself has a ridiculously bloated contract, Jeff Finger, might truly be the guy the Rangers should look at. 

Finger is nothing more than a solid, team first, defensive defenseman.  Will he man the point on the power play?  No.  Will he throw up that breakaway pass and hit the open man?  No chance.  However, will he block shots?  Yes.  Will he help to clear the crease?  Absolutely. 

These are skills that we lack, and truly need.  In Toronto, with the acquisitions of Mike Komisarek and Francois Beauchemin, Finger becomes expendable, and with only Tomas Kaberle as a top notch offensive blueliner, they could use another puck mover.

However, I really am not sure that we need anyone Toronto has to offer.  We could use another solid piece up front though.  Players like Prospal and Kotalik are iffy to say the least.  At worst, Prospal's gone in a year if he puts up a duplicate of last season.  Are players like Gratchev, Stepan, and Anisimov guarantees to succeed?  Who knows. 

I do know of one forward who has the ability to play all three positions, and is one of the most dynamic goal scorers in the game, and is definitely available.  This is Phil Kessel.

Now, what do the Bruins need, to give up a player like Phil Kessel?  They certainly want a puck moving defenseman; they almost gave up Kessel for Kaberle during the Entry Draft.  Now however, they'd want a little more.  This is what I propose:


Who's Moved:

Rangers trade Michal Roszival, Artem Anisimov, Ryan McDonagh, and a second round pick.

Bruins trade Phil Kessel and Byron Bitz

Toronto trades Ian White and Jeff Finger


Who's Acquired:

Rangers acquire Phil Kessel and Jeff Finger

Bruins acquire Ian White, Artem Anisimov, and Ryan McDonagh

Toronto acquires Michal Roszival, Byron Bitz, and the Rangers' second round pick.

The Rangers here are trading a lot of youth.  However...when have they not?  Also, have they ever had the depth of prospects they boast today?  I don't believe so.  I still think that they have plenty of youth going forward. 

The Rangers traded an extra offensive defenseman that I don't believe they need with the prospects they have.  Sanguinetti and/or Del Zotto will fill the void. 

They also traded prospect McDonagh, who by all accounts, was acquired to be part of a Dany Heatley deal that since hasn't come to fruition.  They are also trading from an area of depth, that being defense.  They acquire the defensive stalwart they need in Finger, while adding that top six guarantee of a monster, to line up with Gaborik for the next decade. 

Single Page
Vote Now! - Author Poll

Should Glen Sather continue to add to the team?

  • Leave it as it is
  • Add a free agent
  • Make a trade
vote to see results
Results - Author Poll

Should Glen Sather continue to add to the team?

  • Leave it as it is

    12.3%
  • Add a free agent

    7.7%
  • Make a trade

    80.0%
  • Total votes: 65
(0)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

58 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

943
reads

58
comments

written on August 22, 2009 Preview/Prediction

Top Stories from NHL.com

NHL on B/R | Official Partners

The best Rangers newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.