Chicago White Sox: Ozzie Guillen Needs To Shape Up or Ship Out

Is Ozzie Guilen the most hated man in baseball? Maybe not, but what Dan Pieroni thinks is likely is to make you wonder.

by Dan Pieroni (Scribe)

6 comments

315 reads

May 17, 2008

Share this Story

  • Email to a friend
  • Print this article
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to Digg

Currently UnEdited

This article has not been edited yet.

MLB, Chicago White Sox, Ozzie Guillen, Editorial, Editorial

Baseball is full of colorful characters. From the zany antics of the Loyal Order of Buffalo Heads in the 1970s to the modern day theatre that is Lou Piniella throwing a base into right field, there's no shortage of interesting characters in the Major Leagues.

More often then not, these quirky characters are embraced by fans for their unpredictable behavior and penchant for driving authority figures up the wall. However, if 15 years of careful baseball watching has taught me anything, the game is also full of people that fans love to hate for one reason or another.

The way I see it, there are three types of hated characters in baseball: the dishonest ones, the ones who leave your favorite team for greener pastures and/or more money, and the crybabies who feel they're always being hassled by the fans or the media.

The dishonest type of player is one who continually denies rumors about them that everyone knows is probably true. In this modern era of steroid allegations, the choice is obvious as to who the modern day poster child of this group is. If I have to tell you, then you obviously don't follow the game.

The greedy type of player is one who constantly complains about not earning enough money. When contract time approaches, he and his agent squeeze every penny out of the organization that is desperate to keep him because he means a lot to the team. When a player and his agent don't agree with what the GM thinks the player is worth, the player leaves for more money elsewhere. Modern day examples of these players are Johnny Damon and Torii Hunter.

Finally, there are the whiners and complainers, the ones who can't stand the fact that someone or something is more popular than they are. They're also the type of people who take any sort of criticism as a personal attack on their ability. They're not above telling off the media or the organization when this occurs. Most of the time, the manager is the biggest moaner on the team. Billy Martin is the classic example, tbut he modern day example is Chicago White Sox manager Ozzie Guillen.

Guillen's a guy who has yet to understand two facts of life in the rough and tumble city of Chicago. Number one: The White Sox, no matter how hard they try, are always going to be the second most popular baseball team in Chicago. Number two: Chicago is a passionate sports town full of fans and figureheads that are going to second guess moves the manager makes.  They're also going to kick the team when they're down because they want to win. Guillen has yet to understand these two universal truths.  instead of making the best of situation, he continue to hold grudges against certain members of the media and the more popular baseball team on the north side of the city.

Even though the Cubs have not won a World Series in exactly 100 years, there is still an aura about them. They've earned a reputation as a bunch of lovable losers and play in one of the most intimate and popular ballparks in the major league. A team that has those intangibles is hard to top in an American city, let alone Chicago.

Guillen doesn't see it that way.  He believes that his team should be the most popular team in the city because they won a World Series. What he doesn't realize is that that happened three years ago and the White Sox have not returned to that caliber of play since. Therefore, instead of being angry at the Cubs for merely existing and the Cubs fans for not acknowledging the fact that his team has been more successful in recent years, he should learn to co-exist with Cubs.  It's only fair because they were there first. You don't see Willie Randolph moaning to the New York press that his team gets no respect because he's mindful of the fact that the Mets are second to the Yankees in popularity. Guillen needs to stop whining about the respect issue, he's always going to be number two in the city whether he likes it or not.

Chicago is also a rabid sports town, there is more then one newspaper as well as two sports radio stations. Columnists and talk show hosts exist to give he readers and listeners what they want to hear. When the going gets tough, they're going to second guess people and tell others how they would have done it better. In passionate sports towns, that's an everyday occurrence. In Guillen's world, it's unfair and intolerable under any circumstances. If you criticize him, be prepared to be berated with salty language by an angry Latino who is tired of being hassled.

And so, I offer the following advice to both Ozzie Guillen and the White Sox organization - toughen up. Guillen needs to stop taking every piece of criticism so personally. It would also help if he dealt with reporters in a more tactful way. I understand that English is not Guillen's native language and that the press can be brutal, but that still doesn't give him the right to disrespect them by using offensive language that would make Tony Montana blush.

The organization, whether it be Jerry Riendorf or GM Ken Williams that does the talking, needs to be cognisant of the fact that Guillen is considered a nuisance to many people in the media. The fans may love him because he's blunt and honest, but he has yet to replicate the success he had three years ago.

I'm not calling for Guillen to be fired. I'm merely suggesting that anger management or a heart-to-heart conversation may be just what the doctor ordered to rectify this situation. If Ozzie continues to burn bridges with the media and Cubs fans, it will create as domino effect. The White Sox won't get much press, and the fans won't go to the games. If Guillen can stop taking criticism so personally and understand he'll always play second to fiddle to the Cubs, he'll earn more respect from the media and his peers. 

comments (6) write a comment »

  1. Ozzie has no room to complain about being second fiddle in the city. If the White Sox had kept winning and competing for the playoffs following the 2006 season (in which they won 90 games and broke attendance records), the Sox would at least be close to equaling the Cubs' popularity. But, because the team tanked in 2007 and now is fighting to stay above water in 2008, their popularity has dropped significantly and may end up around 2003, 2004 levels before this is all over.

    Although, baseball isn't a popularity contest. As a Sox fan, I'm happy my team has won a championship in my lifetime, and no amount of popularity that the other Chicago baseball team has will take away from that.

  2. It's not fair that the Sox "always have to play second fiddle to the Cubs." It's also incorrect to say that; the popularity of the teams goes in cycles. For a long time in the middle of the century, the Sox were not only better than the Cubs, they were also the bigger draw. The same goes for the 1970s.

    I hate to say this, because everyone always makes it out to be a "bitter Sox fan," but it sounds like Cubs fan talk to say that Ozzie should shape up or ship out. Joe Cowley's column in the Friday Sun-Times was a good illustration of what most people think of Ozzie and unfortunately, it's not a question of his character. Do most people in the media honestly think of Ozzie as a nuisance? ESPN and Jay Mariotti certainly do. But since when do outside factors determine how a person should behave and act? If Manny can be Manny, why can't Ozzie just be Ozzie?

  3. Let's think about this...how many World Series have the White Sox won in the last 100 years compared to the Cubs? I think it's 2-0. That's how you measure on how well an organization is run.

    The crap about attendance is bogus. Look at the Florida Marlins...they've won 2 championships in 15 years of existence. They don't draw as many fans, but they've won. I would consider them a much more successful franchise thatn the Cubs--end of conversation.

    The greatness of an organization is based on championships and winning. End of discussion.

  4. Now, back to Ozzie...he speaks the truth. People just can't accept a manager that speaks how he REALLY feels and doesn't feed them bullshit. He catches flack because he's a little outrageous, but if people haven't realized that he is, they have no idea who they are dealing with.

  5. Everybody wants Ozzie (and Kenny Williams) fired. I hope where you work, that people want you fired, too. See how you like that.

  6. This is directed towards sports, who's obviously a smart-Aleck who wants to stir up trouble. I'm currently unemployed, so I don't even have a job, because society likes to hire ignorant people like you, instead of hard-working folks like myself.

    I don't like Ozzie, and I refuse to call him a good manager, until he cleans up his crybaby act and shows some class towards the media. It doesn't mean I'm right, it's just my opinion. If you read carefully, I didn't even suggest that he should be fired, I merely suggested that he seek anger management, that's all.

    You're obviously offended that I trashed someone you admire, but that still doesn't give you the right to insult me because you don't like what I said. If you're gonna trash at least read the whole article.

write a new comment


Edit this Article Article History

A partner of