NFLNBANHLMLBWNBASoccerTennis
Featured Video
Brewers vs. Athletics (06/08/2026)

The Other Twin: Justin Morneau Is Still Underrated

D.A.Jul 12, 2009

I'm a White Sox fan and the Twins are nowhere near the top of my list for favorite teams, but Justin Morneau is still underrated.

Morneau won the Most Valuable Player award in 2006... and he's still underrated. Morneau won the home run derby in 2008... and he's still underrated.

In 2006, when Morneau won the MVP award, the focus was on how Derek Jeter was snubbed out of the award, not on how great of a player Morneau was.

TOP NEWS

Pittsburgh Pirates v Houston Astros

Trades That Would Break the Internet 🤯

Los Angeles Dodgers v. Washington Nationals

Ranking Every Team's 3-Year Plan 📝

Chicago Cubs v. Pittsburgh Pirates

Cy Young winner surprises local Little League

In 2008, when Morneau won the home run derby, the focus was on how great of a performance Josh Hamilton had, not on the power of Justin Morneau.

Now, we still can see that Justin Morneau is one of the most underrated players in the game. He's constantly being overlooked by writers and bloggers for the First Basemen on the East Coast. To be honest, Morneau is better than Kevin Youkilis and Mark Teixeira. The numbers don't lie:

Morneau.310
2170.965
Teixeira
.2762163.920
Youkilis.2961652.989


Keep in mind, Justin Morneau doesn't have the players around him that Mark Teixeira and Kevin Youkilis do. Minnesota has about one-third the budget of the Yankees and about one-half the budget of the Red Sox. The point? He produces more with less. Alex Rodriguez, Jorge Posada, Hideki Matsui, David Ortiz, Jason Bay, and Jason Varitek provide a lot more protection than Jason Kubel, Michael Cuddyer, and Joe Crede.

Offensively, Morneau gets the nod. What about defense? Mark Teixeira and Kevin Youkilis play great defense at first. But what about Morneau? He also plays great defense. His glove is by far underrated. He has committed just as few errors (one) as Youkilis and Teixeira at first base and has also made excellent defensive plays.

Not only is Morneau overlooked because of the East Coast first basemen, he's also underrated because of the other Twin on team, Joe Mauer. Yes, Joe Mauer is great. But this offense is still centered around Justin Morneau. Without Morneau, this offense would be nowhere. No player in the American League has created more runs than Justin Morneau.

So people, please recognize who the premier first baseman in the American League is. It's not Kevin Youkilis, Mark Teixeira, Carlos Pena, or Miguel Cabrera. It's Justin Morneau, and it's time that he starts getting respect.

Brewers vs. Athletics (06/08/2026)

TOP NEWS

Pittsburgh Pirates v Houston Astros

Trades That Would Break the Internet 🤯

Los Angeles Dodgers v. Washington Nationals

Ranking Every Team's 3-Year Plan 📝

Chicago Cubs v. Pittsburgh Pirates

Cy Young winner surprises local Little League

MLB Power Rankings

Phillies Surge in New Rankings 📊

MLB: MAY 27 Yankees at Royals

Every Team's Biggest Cut Candidate 🪓

Ranking Best Players at World Cup 🌟
Bleacher Report7h

Ranking Best Players at World Cup 🌟

hero

TRENDING ON B/R