Yesterday, first baseman Jeff Bailey suffered a high-ankle strain trying to make a play on Brad Penny's acrobatic flip to first base Saturday. He's likely to hit the disabled list, a loss, given that the Sox are about to face two left-handed pitchers.
How can the Red Sox replace Bailey against left-handed starters? The Boston Globe came up with an idea: Green at third, Lugo short, and Youkilis at first. Inserting Kotsay against lefties is unlikely given he's just aggravated his calf.
I've come up with a couple other scenarios. First, to maximize offensive production, put David Ortiz at first base. This would allow Rocco Baldelli to become the DH and leave J.D. Drew in the lineup. I'm far more comfortable with Ortiz and Drew in the lineup than I am with Kotsay and Lugo.
Second would be to place outfielder Jonathan Van Every on the 60-day disabled list to remove him from the 40-man roster (Van Every recently had knee surgery), and then promote a hitter from Triple-A to hit against lefties.
The problem with this is that the top two candidates to be recalled (Chris Carter, Paul McAnulty) are left-handers. For a platoon at first base, that's not helpful. The Sox could always make a waiver claim or a small trade for a warm body through the All-Star Break or simply decide to ignore the platoon issues and bring Carter/McAnulty to the bigs.
Carter (who is already on the 40-man) is hitting .262/.319/.416 in Pawtucket, so it's unlikely he gets the call. McAnulty is similarly not performing at .241/.327/.427.
If the minors aren't going to help, we're limited to the first two options above. The option of Papi at first gives the Sox the most offense, but it is highly unlikely. It seems as if we're going to be stuck watching Lugo struggle to field a ball for the next couple of days.
Anyone else have any better ideas?