Which of Romelu Lukaku, Loic Remy and Wilfried Bony Is Top Striker to Target?

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Which of Romelu Lukaku, Loic Remy and Wilfried Bony Is Top Striker to Target?
Jan Kruger/Getty Images

Lost behind the allure of the impending World Cup is the usual hype and fascination with the transfer window.

Aside from Liverpool, Premier League clubs have performed relatively few transactions thus far, presumably waiting for a chaotic post-Brazil frenzy.

Finding that elusive free-scoring forward will be the task of many scouts this summer. Three of the Premier League's top sixin Arsenal, Tottenham and Evertonall have a vacancy in this department.

Stu Forster/Getty Images

Of the many options, Romelu Lukaku, Wilfried Bony and Loic Remy are three potential good fits, each acclimatised to English football and already linked with various summer moves.

If this trio were to switch employers, here's a look at which would be best.

First of all, it's important to tally together their Premier League production from last season.

Lukaku vs. Remy vs. Bony PL 2013/14
Lukaku Remy Bony
Games 29 (2) 24 (2) 27 (7)
Goals 15 14 16
Assists 6 3 4
Goals + Assists per 90 mins 0.74 0.73 0.73
Shots per 90 3.4 3.8 3.9
Shooting Accuracy 63% 49% 44%
Chance Conversion 21% 22% 18%
Chances Created per 90 1.1 1.3 0.9
Passing Accuracy 66% 81% 74%
Aerial Duel Success 38% of 238 38% of 92 43% of 240
Successful Dribbles per 90 1.4 1.2 0.9
Dispossessed per 90 1.9 1.5 2.3

Stats via Whoscored.com and Squawka.com

The first thing to note is just how impressive each return is.

All three strikers produced a season of high-class finishing, clearly boosting the campaigns of Everton, Swansea and Newcastle, respectively.

In Everton's case, Lukaku helped push a consistent top-seven side to the highest points tally of any club not finishing in the Premier League's top four. 

Stu Forster/Getty Images

Newcastle and Swansea endured rather more testing seasons, brightened—and at times rescuedby the goals of their main striker.

In terms of quality, there's relatively little to differentiate between them. Each produced a similar goal return for the minutes they played, involved in a goal in three out of every four matches played.

Aside from the elite, relentless performers such as Luis Suarez and Sergio Aguero, this puts them among the top strikers in the country.

Lukaku is the more accurate shooter, Remy is the marginally more clinical finisher and Bony was able to fire in a more regular supply of shots.

Paul Thomas/Getty Images

Stylistically, it's clear to see the subtleties in their play and the system they were asked to perform in. Judging by blocked shot percentages, Bony (16 percent) is the more instinctive, one-touch finisher. 

Lukaku (27 percent) and Remy (28 percent) are more likely to take a touch or run at a defender, also emphasised by their greater dribble success.

Bony's strength and control also offers the most in hold-up play. Lukaku was targeted a similar amount but posted a lower success rate, while Remy was rarely asked to compete in the air.

The Frenchman is far more slick linking up with others in the passing game, while also providing more chances for his team-mates.

Away from the numbers, Lukaku's blend of raw pace, power and intelligent movement can terrorise any Premier League defence.

Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images

So, what does this all equate to?

Were there much of a contrast, then it would be simple to categorise, but while there are differences in their game, each is adept at leading a line and firing in a substantial quota of goals.

All three strikers will produce a similar return if afforded similar opportunities next season. Therefore, the key aspect is value, a team's system and the player's age.

Which striker is the better summer signing?

Submit Vote vote to see results

At 25 and 27, respectively, both Bony and Remy are the more finished products. Upon purchase, they have little potential to increase in value, which should be taken into account with price.

Bought and signed to a long-term deal, their value will gradually diminish as they approach 30.

At just 21, Lukaku still has considerable room to develop, making him a far more attractive buy. His value will continue soaring for the next few years, making it smart to sign him now, if at all possible.

If all three are available for similar fees, Lukaku is the clear choice to target. Despite the fact he will produce a similar return to Bony and Remy, his transfer represents far more sensible business.

Given how hard it is to obtain proven Premier League finishers, QPR, Chelsea and Swansea should think carefully before letting these proven forwards go.


Statistics via WhoScored.com and Squawka.

Follow B/R on Facebook

Transfer News

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.