Why Run Support Can Make Win-Loss Records Misleading

Nick AllenCorrespondent IJune 28, 2009

A pitchers' win-loss record can be very misleading.

Many factors contribute to the win-loss statistic, one of the biggest factors is run support. With no run support, it's going to be impossible to win, obviously.

So according to the win-loss statistic, a pitcher that goes nine innings gives up one run, and gets no run support at all, isn't as good as a pitcher that goes five innings, gives up nine runs, but gets 10 runs of run support.

That's what makes this stat flawed.

For example:

Scott Kazmir has a 7.69 ERA, but a 4-4 record, he can thank his offense that provides a Major-League-Leading 7.7 runs of run support per game.

Matt Palmer is 6-1 with a 4.47 ERA, but, he also has the 5th best run support among qualifiers this year.

Jason Vargas has a 3.79 ERA which is well below league average, yet he sports a 3-3 win-loss record due to his run support of 2.8 runs per game, fifth-worst in the majors.

In 1992, Jim Abbot had a 2.77 ERA the fifth lowest among AL qualifiers that year, but he went 7-15 that year due to the 2.5 runs of run support he recieved while pitching.

In 2008, Jake Peavy, had a 2.85 ERA, good for sixth best in the majors but a sub .500 winning percentage, with a 10-11 record, because his run support of 3.5 runs per game was sixth-worst in the Majors.

In 2004, Shawn Estes had a 5.84 ERA and went 15-8 just because his offense produced 5.6 runs per game.

I asked Zach Fein to run some numbers for me on run support, ERA, and win-loss percentage and he came up with this:

Using the 88 pitchers that qualified in 2008, the correlation between win-loss percentage and ERA was -0.65; the correlation between W-L% and run support per game was 0.55. The difference between the two is not that large and suggests that run support plays a large role in W-L%.

As well, a regression between the three variables (W-L%, ERA, and run support, the latter two standardized) shows that every point of ERA affects W-L% by -0.08, while every run of run support affects W-L% by 0.07. There's minimal difference between the effects of ERA and run support on W-L%.

--

A pitchers win-loss record shouldn't be used to justify that one pitcher is better than another, due to the variables that go into a win or a loss.

Related

    Darvish Placed on 10-Day DL with Triceps Tendonitis

    MLB logo
    MLB

    Darvish Placed on 10-Day DL with Triceps Tendonitis

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report

    Kershaw Nears Return from Biceps Injury

    MLB logo
    MLB

    Kershaw Nears Return from Biceps Injury

    ESPN.com
    via ESPN.com

    Vlad Jr. Might Be the Future of Baseball

    MLB logo
    MLB

    Vlad Jr. Might Be the Future of Baseball

    SI.com
    via SI.com

    M's Acquire Colome, Span from Rays

    MLB logo
    MLB

    M's Acquire Colome, Span from Rays

    Kyle Newport
    via Bleacher Report