Defining The X-Factor For The Carolina Panthers

Austin PennyAnalyst IJune 15, 2009

In the wonderful world of the NFL, teams and members of the media alike are in a constant search for a bit of information or insight that will put them a notch ahead of the competition.  That search is never as heated as it is during the offseason, when teams are scrambling to shuffle their rosters and coaching staffs to improve on last season’s shortcomings. 

Both teams and the media outlets that cover them embark on a hunt unparalleled by any free agent bid or trade scenario.  They search for the one player, unit, package, or even sometimes the single play that will be instrumental in the team’s success. 

They are searching for the infamous “X-factor.”

The fan’s thirst for knowledge in the 21st century is unlike anything ever seen in the past.  Every stat, every situation, every detail, and every story is covered from every angle imaginable.  And it is not uncommon to see these measurements and calculations often prove to be irrelevant or off base. 

Such is not the case for the X-factor. 

Simply defined, the X-factor is the one thing that will make or break your team. 

It’s not as obvious as a starting quarterback or starting middle linebacker.  It’s that piece of the puzzle that, if used correctly, could change the landscape of your entire season.

On the other hand, if your X-factor turns out to be a bad apple, it could poison your entire team.  In layman’s terms, the X-factor is the difference maker.

When pondering the recipient of this title for the Carolina Panthers, you can make many valid arguments.  You could go with the obvious, such as Jake Delhomme, but you would be merely scratching the surface of what the X-factor title is all about.  It’s not about what should make your team better; it’s about what could make your team better. 

So, I figure what better way to determine the Panthers X-factor than by opening the question up to the community and sparking a little friendly debate.  I’ll lay out a few of my votes and turn the topic over for discussion.

Julius Peppers:  Yes, I know, it’s an easy choice.  But you can’t bet on Peppers being in a Panthers jersey for the 2009 season yet.  As much as he has spoken about his next career destination, he is still a vital part of the Panthers defense and his absence will be known should he not suit up.  In Ron Meeks’ new defense, the front four will be largely responsible for rushing the quarterback, and nobody on the Panthers roster can touch Peppers’ ability in that department.

Richard Marshall:  Ken Lucas took a lot of the heat last year for a sub-par performance by the Panthers’ secondary.  Lucas is on the other side of the country now and the young Marshall is stepping into his place.  Marshall has shown sparks of brilliance since being drafted by the Panthers in 2006, but will have to step his game up to a full-time gig in 2009.  If he can become a shut-down corner, that will take some of the pressure off of Chris Gamble and the Panthers will be solid at cornerback.  Shoring up the secondary will go a long way to improving the defense that let the Panthers down late last year.

Ryne Robinson:  A wildcard, sure, but the return game is become ever-prevalent in the NFL.  If Robinson can become the returner that the Panthers coaching staff believes he can, the offense will have better starting position and some pressure will be taken off the defense by improving field position.  Robinson missed all of 2008 with a knee injury but is back and will be expected to take the place of Mark Jones.  Robinson worked as the team’s returner in 2007 and showed progress as time went on.  If Larry Beavers makes the Panthers’ roster, it is likely he will be able to take some of the workload from Robinson.

Dwayne Jarrett:  If Jarrett can start producing material for a highlight reel that rivals that of his college days, then the Panthers will have Steve Smith’s homemade opposite.  Muhammad is a fine number-two receiver, but he’s getting up there in age and won’t be around for too much longer.  Jarrett was drafted to be the wide-out of the future for the Panthers, but so far he has turned out to be a bust.  If Jarrett can break out of his shell in 2009, the Panthers will have a triple-threat with Double Trouble, Smith, and the former USC standout.  If not, the Panthers will likely be forced to juggle Ryne Robinson, Jason Carter, and Kenneth Moore at the third receiver spot.

Offensive Line:  As is the case with any run-heavy team, the Panthers’ offensive line will play a huge part in their success or lack thereof come September.  All five starters are returning, leading one to believe that the unit will continue their solid play from 2008.  That must happen in order for the Panthers to remain near the top of the league in rushing, which is the team’s bread and butter.  Anchored by Jordan Gross and his new six-year deal, the offensive line is lacking some of the depth it sported last year, but should be in good shape for ‘09 barring any major injuries.

Tight Ends:  The Panthers spent a good lump of money on making sure Jeff King didn’t leave town as a restricted free agent.  Now it’s time to put that money to use.  King has shown steady improvement during his time in the league, and he is accompanied by Dante Rosario and Gary Barnidge; two other very capable tight ends.  If the Panthers’ running game is as successful as it was last season, teams will be forced to cheat to stop it, thus opening up the passing game.  With three athletic tight ends, there will almost always be a mismatch with whoever is checking them.  If the powers-that-be would insert some short routes, they could serve as a glorified run or even as a game changer in the right situation.  Whatever the case, the tight end needs to be utilized more in Carolina.

These are a few likely candidates for the title of the Panthers’ X-factor.  Now I’ll open the floor to my fellow fans to start the debate.  Have another player or unit in mind?  Let’s hear it.


 Austin is the Carolina Panthers' Fan Voice at  Visit him here.