25 Cubs, 25 Comments.

Ed LeiserCorrespondent IJune 9, 2009

As this up-and-down Cubs season continues, I wanted to express my thoughts on the current state of Cubs baseball. 

June has brought much of the same for the Chicago Cubs: close games, injuries, poor hitting, great pitching, and more frustrating moments than I care to remember.

Everyone knows the old adage that says you win as a team, you lose as a team.  Baseball is obviously no different. Twenty-five men occupy an active roster and each man has a certain role to fill on that team. 

There are the speed guys, the defensive stars, the big boppers, the aces of the rotation, the trusted relief pitchers, the shut-down closer and so on.

The Cubs' current roster is not what anyone would have envisioned this late in the season, but injuries and poor play have played a major role in that.

For better or worse, this 25-man roster will be called on to get the Cubs rolling. In no particular order, I now will share my comments on this team.


Geovany Soto, Catcher:

First, it was his participation in the World Baseball Classic. Then, it was an injury to his throwing shoulder that sidelined him in early April. Now he is losing at-bats to...Koyie Hill? 

Geo, what happened to you?  His 23 walks against only 30 strikeouts suggest his fortune can change, but when?


Derrek Lee, First Base:

Bothered by neck problems early and often, Lee has yet to get on track. He is aging before our eyes and is not much of a threat in this lineup.


Bobby Scales, Second Base:

There's a reason the 31-year old only made his major-league debut this year (he's not very good).


Ryan Theriot, Shortstop:

Basically the only speed threat on this team, his .291 average has helped the Cubs keep their heads above water while other high-priced players have struggled.


Mike Fontenot, Third Base:

Aramis, when can you return?


Alfonso Soriano, Left Field:

He can't run, he can't field, he can't get on base, he can't lay off breaking balls or off-speed pitches. A constant headache is all you're ever guaranteed of getting with this guy.


Kosuke Fukudome, Center Field:

He is in the top three of most Cubs' offensive statistics; where would this offense be without him?  But unlike last year, can he sustain his success?


Milton Bradley, Right Field:

Where do I begin?  Suspensions, nagging injuries, ineffectiveness. One big paycheck currently going to waste.


Koyie Hill, Catcher:

He is the Cubs' backup catcher.


Andres Blanco, Second Base:

He will be back at AAA-Iowa in hours.


Jake Fox, DH:

If he had an actual position, he might have some value on this team.  He does not, and he does not.


Micah Hoffpauir, First Base/Right Field:

He is a key lefty off the bench for Piniella, but not good enough to play every day.


Reed Johnson, Outfield:

There's a guy like him on just about every team. So I'm not going to glorify him here, though I do like him.


Ted Lilly, Starting Pitcher:

Solid as a rock. If I wanted to be picky, I'd complain about his 11 home runs allowed, but let's just let that slide for now.


Ryan Dempster, Starting Pitcher:

Would you have guessed that he would be leading the team in strikeouts?  Dempster got paid in the offseason, but has managed to put together a nice run of late and a solid season so far.


Carlos Zambrano, Starting Pitcher:

The only thing holding him back from being a Cy Young Award contender is Carlos Zambrano. There's no room for stupid suspensions and ill-advised injuries for the team's highest paid arm.


Randy Wells, Starting Pitcher:

Has zero wins to show for his stellar performances. Doesn't seem fair.


Sean Marshall, Starting Pitcher:

Appears to be headed back to the bullpen once injured starter Rich Harden returns.  Marshall is always stuck in the rotation-to-the-bullpen muck it seems.


Jose Ascanio, Relief Pitcher:

I like what I've seen from the flame-throwing right-hander so far, but ten innings is not a large enough sample size.


Kevin Gregg, Closer:

I did not like the acquisition in November and I still don't.  Also, his goggles are stupid.


Angel Guzman, Relief Pitcher:

He's been awesome and will likely assume Carlos Marmol's role as primary setup man in the seventh or eighth inning.


Aaron Heilman, Relief Pitcher:

He's issued 17 walks in only 25 innings, which is not good any way you slice it.


Carlos Marmol, Relief Pitcher:

But 27 walks in 27 innings is much worse.


David Patton, Relief Pitcher:

How is he still on this team with an ERA over six?


Jason Waddell, Relief Pitcher:

Rich Harden's arrival this weekend will result in your bus ride back to AAA-Iowa, Jason.


Note: Aramis Ramirez, Aaron Miles, and Rich Harden are not currently on the 25-man roster, so I did not include them here.  With the way Miles and Harden have performed at times this year, I'm not sure I would even want to comment on them.





    Theo Spikes Rumors: 'Essentially Zero Trade Talks'

    Chicago Cubs logo
    Chicago Cubs

    Theo Spikes Rumors: 'Essentially Zero Trade Talks'

    via MLB

    Red Sox Officially Activate Pedroia from DL

    MLB logo

    Red Sox Officially Activate Pedroia from DL

    NBC Sports Boston
    via NBC Sports Boston

    Red Sox Parting Ways with Hanley Makes Sense

    MLB logo

    Red Sox Parting Ways with Hanley Makes Sense

    Henry McKenna
    via The Big Lead

    Angry Sox Fans React to Stunning Hanley Move

    MLB logo

    Angry Sox Fans React to Stunning Hanley Move

    via masslive.com